Loudoun Schools Fail Their Most Vulnerable Kids

by James C. Sherlock

Kids and their parents don’t ask much of their schools. Just a quality education in a safe and moral environment. Even at ages before the children fully realize what the words education and moral mean.

The kids themselves have no choice but to take what the school system puts in front of them and do the best they can with it.

Loudoun is the richest county in the United States. Number two is not even close.

Loudoun County Public Schools (LCPS) have helped white and Asian kids from economically comfortable homes. In fact, the Asian kids are such terrific academic achievers and grace Loudoun County schools in such large numbers that their successes mask rot underneath.

But educating the economically disadvantaged as a macro group and Black kids, Hispanics, students with disabilities and English learners as sub-cohorts of that group are the true test of a school system.

LCPS has largely failed those kids. The LCPS administration is responsible and must be held accountable.

The parents that have famously protested important grievances at the LCPS board meetings are right.

But there are groups of parents of economically disadvantaged children that deserve their say as well. I hope this article reaches them to let them know how badly LCPS has treated thousands of their kids.

Loudoun schools have denied far too many of them their futures.

It doesn’t matter that Loudoun is rich. All the money in the world won’t fix incompetent or uncaring. I don’t know which applies here, but the failure is so profound that it may be some of both.

Loudoun often brags about its overall SOL scores, but LCPS must be getting heavy for its Asian kids. There is rot underneath.

I will compare state assessments of LCPS to those of the City of Chesapeake Public schools to illustrate the failures in Loudoun.

Some current data:

  • Loudoun schools: 22% Asian, 48% white. Chesapeake 3% Asian and 47% white.
  • Loudoun economically disadvantaged 19%.  Chesapeake 35%.
  • Loudoun spending $15,507 per child, Chesapeake $10,945

Data from 2028-19 school year, the last before COVID, show the SOL failure rates by cohort in Loudoun compared to those in Chesapeake.  Even more personally, it shows how many thousands of more kids in Loudoun would have passed the SOLs had Loudoun achieved Chesapeake’s results.

So, you can see that Chesapeake demonstrated massive advantages over Loudoun in the math and reading learning demonstrated by Hispanic, Economically Disadvantaged and English Learner kids.

Chesapeake demonstrated advantages in every subgroup in math learning except Students with Disabilities, which was a tie. Thousands of additional Loudoun students would have passed math SOLs had they learned at the same levels as kids in Chesapeake.

Reading is a mixed picture. You can see it above. But, once again, it is not a mixed picture for Hispanics, the Economically Disadvantaged and English learners. Again, thousands more of those children in Loudoun would have passed reading SOLs had they achieved the reading learning demonstrated in Chesapeake.

Clearly, LCPS doesn’t know how to do what needs to be done to help its most challenged students succeed.

The administration has flailed around trying to substitute money and ed-school fantasies for wisdom. It adds ever more staff, driving up costs without apparent value rather than looking elsewhere for what works.

The Virginia Board of Education is charged with making annual reports to the Governor and the General Assembly concerning the condition and needs of public education in the Commonwealth and to identify any school divisions which have failed to establish and maintain schools meeting the prescribed standards of quality.

In the latest report (pg.84), I note that Loudoun County declared itself in full compliance with the Standards of Quality in both 2019-20 and 2018-19 after having been non-compliant in the previous two years.

In a pigs eye.

VDOE posts school quality information for all to see. Virginia bases school assessments on SOL scores.

I averaged the pass rates across every school, every subject and every cohort in LCPS (VDOE school by Subject by Subgroup report). The composite SOL pass rate across subgroups in 2016-17 was 81.2% and in 2018-19 was 77.7%. Performance declined, not improved, over the periods illustrated in the report.

Then I built the spreadsheets you see above.

Disadvantaged kids in too many LCPS schools have been denied their futures while the extraordinary Asian students in Loudoun have masked that failure by their numbers and academic success.

I lay both the misrepresentation in reporting and, far more consequentially, the poor academic performance of students who depend of them, at the feet of the superintendent and the a major slice of senior LCPS administration officials.

I have accessed data from the state. I am aware of the horrid results. Whoever in the LCPS administration submitted the report knew it. The Superintendent and Deputy Superintendent know it.

The school board should consider cleaning house. The Superintendent needs to go.

LCPS lists 42 senior staff in the Superintendent’s office. Under that organizational structure, I recommend the board also consider replacing the Deputy Superintendent and his nine senior subordinates.  They are directly responsible for the quality of schools.

And find out exactly what the Equity Director has been doing in the face of the dreadful academic results of protected classes.

But act.  Now.

Share this article


(comments below)


(comments below)


11 responses to “Loudoun Schools Fail Their Most Vulnerable Kids”

  1. Baconator with extra cheese Avatar
    Baconator with extra cheese

    The data indicates that Loudoun Schools are perpetrating white supremacy. I think Loudoun should double down on their work agenda to prove otherwise.

  2. DJRippert Avatar

    But, but, but …. Kendi says racism is structural. So, the poor results for children of color (except for the inconvenient Asians) is society’s fault, not the school district’s fault. If those domestic terrorists (i.e. parents) would just go away and stop participating in school board meetings the district could get back to the job at hand … teaching “woke theory”.

    Besides, the SOLs are, like everything else in American society, racist.

  3. Deborah Hommer Avatar
    Deborah Hommer

    That’s consistent with BrightBeam’s Jan 2020 report “The Secret Shame; How America’s Most Progressive Cities Betray Their Commitment to Educational Opportunity for All.” https://brightbeamnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/The-Secret-Shame_v4.pdf

    I think there are a few reasons for this
    – their priorities are misplaced
    – they apparently refuse to look at their failures and fix them
    – they attempt to blur their failures by changing school zones, essentially bring in higher scoring kids to poorer scoring kids. I want to know why they don’t just get in there and help these kids.

  4. DJRippert Avatar

    I still remember the bumper stickers that said, “Don’t Fairfax Loudoun”. I understood and agreed with the sentiment. Liberals from failed states move in, nobody pays attention to local elections, developers and the rent-seeking BoS run amok with zoning, transportation systems falter through under-investment and liberal policies turn once-great school systems into mediocre operations.

    What a shame.

    What’s the next bumper sticker? “Don’t Loudoun Fauquier”?

    1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      The great irony of that story. A Republican led Board of Supervisors welcomed development with open arms. Who moved in? The blue team. Ditto in Prince William. Fauquier has one more generation of old school local leadership left. But that is it. The creep of sprawl is on my door step.

      1. how_it_works Avatar

        Ahh, Prince William County..where Wal-Mart is considered a major employer.

  5. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    The key people to replace are actually deep into the 42 member layer of upper LCPS management. Replace the Director of High School, Director of Middle School, and Director of Elementary School. These three people wield the greatest power over the principals. Great leadership at this position can lift academic achievement and create a positive school climate.

  6. Jane Twitmyer Avatar
    Jane Twitmyer

    I do not know about the specifics of the charge BUT …. Loudoun County has twice as many students in their system as Chesapeake. Therefore, it is not accurate to compare the numbers of kids who fail between the two systems. I am sure there is more to be done everywhere so that all kids are served well, but this comparison does not show ‘horrid’ results in the Loudoun system.

    1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
      Eric the half a troll

      I agree it may not be a perfectly fair comparison but in this case James may be onto something. If we are truly interested in equity, we should be learning from those districts where the least advantages are doing well as much as (if not more than) we are emulating the districts where the most advantaged are doing well.

      I hope LCPS board and administrators dig deeper into what is happening in these districts and adopt some lessons learned. The hispanic figures are interesting. I suspect there is something else going on here. It might be informative to look at distribution of hispanics throughout the system. If Loudoun schools has them concentrated while they are more uniformly distributed across Chesapeake’s system, that may be one of the factors. I honestly don’t know the answer to that question. James may.

    2. vicnicholls Avatar

      How do you get just because there are more students means more failing is ok? It shouldn’t matter the #. Look at Wise. It has constantly shown how well they can educate kids who are not in the best position in life.

  7. […] special staff and too few classroom teachers compared to Virginia districts like the City of Chesapeake that considerably outperform Loudoun with far fewer Asian kids, an otherwise similar demographic […]

Leave a Reply