In the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), the assessment against which all states judge their progress, the percentage of Virginia students scoring at proficient or above in the 2024 NAEP exams demonstrate a huge gap between those who are low-income and those who are not – a gap ranging between 25 and 30 percentile points.
For NAEP, proficiency indicates not only solid academic performance and competency, but also the ability to apply that knowledge in real-world situations. Achieving it has been linked to better long-term outcomes, including higher graduation rates and increased job earnings — goals parents wish for their children and for which students should strive.
In the fall of 1991, I had just entered UVA Law School after a year in Japan. My first act on arriving in Charlottesville was to join the University rugby team. (I had played in college and Japan). Grad students comprised the “A side” of the UVA team and, yes, we had some very good players.
One of the best was a diminutive halfback from Yale. Fearless and lightning fast, he led our attack and scored lots of tries. He was also self-effacing and quiet off the pitch; it was several weeks before I learned that my teammate “Jimmy Ryan” was the #1 ranked student in his Law School class and headed to a prestigious clerkship with the U.S. Supreme Court.
That UVA squad made it to the state final, losing a close match to Norfolk RFC. Here’s a close- up of our team photo, just after that loss. (Ryan is standing in the second row; I’m kneeling in the front).
Photo credit: Chap Petersen
Years later, I ran into Jimmy Ryan when he became a professor at the Law School. He had turned down a lucrative career in corporate law to teach young attorneys. Then in 2017, he was named the next President of UVA. A dream job and couldn’t have happened to a nicer guy.
Leaders of the state Senate Democratic Caucus held an online press conference Saturday to express their dismay to the resignation of President Jim Ryan as president of the University of Virginia and outline their legislative priorities in the next General Assembly session.
It was frightening.
There are two main takeaways: First, Senate Democratic leaders are utterly deluded. Second, based upon those delusions, they are planning an unprecedented power grab over Virginia’s public colleges and universities (which is precisely what they accuse their partisan foes of doing).
Senate Democrats have no clue what the thinking is behind Youngkin administration and Trump administration actions. They attribute the most malign of motives to their foes, and they often believe to be true things that are not. It is astonishing that people in power are so misinformed about the intentions of their partisan adversaries. It is difficult to imagine how these people might be reasoned with.
I am not exaggerating. I detail their hallucinations below. And lest you doubt my recapitulation of what they say, view the video, captured by The Cadet, the independent Virginia Military Institute student newspaper.
The Democrat leaders made one, and only one, legitimately debatable point: that the Department of Justice’s department of Civil Rights engaged in over-reach by negotiating Ryan’s resignation for his failure to adhere to an executive order prohibiting racial preferences and Diversity, Equity & Inclusion. I don’t happen to agree with their assessment, but I acknowledge that they are raising a fair point about the raw exercise of executive power — (I might have more to say about this in a future column — and I believe that a public debate would be worthwhile.)
Their antidote: their own raw exercise of legislative power.
The U.S. Supreme Court, in its eagerness to enhance the power of the presidency, has potentially created a real mess over the question of birthright citizenship.
Instead of ruling on the constitutionality of the President’s Executive Order ending birthright citizenship, the Court limited its ruling to the issuance of nationwide injunctions by district courts. The Court ruled that district court judges do not have the authority to issue injunctions affecting persons or entities that were not a party to the case before them. The Court granted the President’s request to stay the nationwide injunctions issued by the district courts, but “only to the extent that the injunctions are broader than necessary to provide complete relief to each plaintiff with standing to sue.”
The injunctions in two instances were issued in cases brought by state Attorneys General, suing the federal government over the implementation of the Executive Order. They were granted standing to sue, the district courts issued nationwide stays, and the relevant appeals courts upheld them. Because the Supreme Court order allowed a district court to issue a stay applicable to the plaintiffs in these cases, i.e. the states, the stay will still be effective in those states.
Maryland was one of the states involved in those suits in which a stay was ordered. So was North Carolina. Virginia was not.
The Department of Justice (DOJ) tried for three months to get answers to questions about the University of Virginia’s Diversity, Equity & Inclusion program but never received a substantive answer, Harmeet Dhillon, assistant attorney general for the Civil Rights division told CNN news anchor Jake Tapper.
“They didn’t respond at all?” Tapper asked yesterday on his cable news show.
“They asked for extensions and extensions and extensions,” Dhillon replied.
Dhillon said she’d sent a “sheath of letters of increasing urgency” asking UVA to confirm that it was compliant with Students for Fair Admissions, the U.S. Supreme Court ruling forbidding racial discrimination in university admissions. They didn’t reply, she said. “Today, they still haven’t, almost three months after I started writing letters to the university law school, the medical school, the nursing school, and others. So, that’s really troubling.”
“I haven’t gotten anything in writing from UVA, unlike many of the other institutions of higher learning,” she said. “I’ve had chancellors come meet me. I’ve had lawyers come meet me. They’ve given us reams and reams of documents. Not UVA.”
Conservatives will rue the day when they permit the federal government to coerce the resignation of any university president, especially one at a state university that answers to its legislature, governor, and citizens.
Image credit: Chat GBT
by David Toscano
Observers of higher education had been predicting that University of Virginia President Jim Ryan might be ousted by U.Va.’s governing board, now controlled by appointees of DEI opponent and Trump ally, Governor Glenn Youngkin. Instead, it was Trump’s Department of Justice that forced Ryan into an early departure.
The threats were familiar — echoing those aimed at Columbia and Harvard: Conform to our views, or we’ll make it difficult for your institution and students. But unlike Harvard, where the president and board chose to fight, Ryan lacked sufficient support from both U.Va.’s Board of Visitors and the state’s Republican governor to do so. As he wrote in his message to the University community, Ryan wanted to stay but could not “make a unilateral decision to fight the federal government in order to save my own job.”
Ryan and U.Va. have thus become the latest casualties in a sweeping political campaign against American higher education — arguably the most aggressive in our nation’s history.
Jim Ryan resigned as president of the University of Virginia today and there goes a man of integrity who followed his own lights and acted upon his own beliefs. But then the political winds shifted, outside forces cranked up the pressure and it finally got to be too much.
Wait, this sounds familiar.
Oh, yeah, we got the same thing in October, 2020, when retired Army Gen. J.H. Binford Peay III stepped down as superintendent of Virginia Military Institute.
Here was another man of incontrovertible integrity who followed his own lights and acted upon his own beliefs. But then the political winds shifted, outside forces cranked up the pressure and it finally got to be too much.
Peay’s resignation followed unprecedented intervention coming out of Richmond and orchestrated by then-Governor Ralph Northam and the progressive powers that had ascended in the Virginia General Assembly.
This time we have Ryan’s resignation in the wake of unprecedented intervention coming out of Washington, D.C. and orchestrated by President Donald Trump and the conservative powers amassed in the U.S. Justice Department.
It may be time to do some rethinking about how best to govern Virginia’s public colleges and universities.
When I served on the State Council of Higher Education, academic freedom was a core educational value. Apparently no longer. We learned today the University of Virginia Board of Visitors caved in into President Trump. They him force out UVA President Ryan because the federal government bureaucrats didn’t like what UVA was doing.
When I served on the State Council of Higher Education for Virginia (SCHEV) board, I was the lone voice standing up for academic freedom against bullying state government. At least I understood why the others were against me. They feared taking on state officials.
Unfortunately, I was naïve. I didn’t realize academic freedom had a financial price in Virginia’s higher education system.
Money talked, not academic freedom.
It’s OK, apparently, to the lecture poor people and the less fortunate about how they should stand up for their rights at all costs.
Under pressure from the Department of Justice, University of Virginia President Jim Ryan has submitted his resignation to resolve a DOJ investigation into the University’s Diversity, Equity & Inclusion, reports the New York Times. The Board has accepted Ryan’s resignation.
In a letter to Rector Robert Hardie, Ryan said that he had planned to step down at the end of the next academic year but “given the circumstances and today’s conversations,” he had decided with “great sadness” to tender his resignation, according to a source whom the Times said was briefed on the contents of the letter.
On March 7 the Board ordered Ryan to dissolve its Diversity, Equity & Inclusion programs and end all racial preferences. Due to frustratingly slow compliance, the Board followed up by tightening oversight over his efforts. On April 28 the Civil Rights division sent a letter demanding evidence that the University had complied with the March resolution. Governor Glenn Youngkin read the Board the riot act, demanding action on DEI, and Democratic Party legislators jumped into the picture by rejecting Youngkin’s nomination of board member Ken Cuccinelli, an act that quickly grew into a constitutional controversy as the legislators and the governor disagreed over whether they were empowered to do so.
Yesterday the Times reported that the DOJ officials had demanded Ryan’s resignation based on conversations with three anonymous sources who had been “briefed on the back-and-forth between the University and the Justice Department” but did not want to be identified discussing “negotiations that were supposed to remain private.” In retrospect, it is clear that the negotiations centered on the terms and conditions of Ryan’s departure.
It was unclear when Ryan will leave, the Times reported. In the letter, he said the resignation would be effective “no later than August 15, 2025.”
Scott Douglas Gerber, a current Virginia resident and occasional contributor to Bacon’s Rebellion, reached a settlement with Ohio Northern University that includes reinstatement to his job and complete vindication to his reputation.
ONU terminated his employment as a tenured law school professor after he objected to the University’s race-based hiring practices. ONU sent campus security and armed police officers into his classroom to forcibly remove him, according to America First Legal, which represented him in his litigation.
Aside from allowing him to retire at his “rightful faculty rank” with all benefits intact, ONU formally acknowledged that Gerber was never a risk to anyone in the ONU community, never acted with moral turpitude, and provided “outstanding teaching, scholarship, and service” throughout his tenure.
Under the terms of the settlement, according to the Bluffton Icon, Gerber submitted his retirement letter ending his employment. Both sides agreed not to disparage one another, and Gerber agreed not to publish a memoir entitled, “Cancelled.”
Gerber, a graduate of the University of Virginia Law School, recently criticized his alma mater for its DEI policies, which we republished here.
You know what would be cool — if the UVA School of Law hired Gerber. You know… to demonstrate how committed it is to intellectual diversity.
No Kings protest in Petersburg. Image credit: USA Today
by Derrick Max
Senator Tim Kaine recently sent out a fundraising email where he quoted the Washington Post that the Virginia “elections are seen as a referendum on the Trump administration.” This suggests that voters should cast their ballots based on how they feel about our current President, rather than the pressing issues facing our Commonwealth today. This kind of rhetoric may play well with partisan crowds and national talking heads, and it may attract donors, but it does a disservice to Virginia voters who deserve a debate focused on real leadership on state issues, not recycled grievances about the President’s agenda.
With the primary elections behind us, it should be clear: Donald Trump was not on the ballot, and he will not be on the ballot in November. What is going to be on the ballot is the direction of our Commonwealth — critical decisions about Virginia’s economy, energy availability, education and schools, taxes, public safety, infrastructure, and the role of government in our daily lives.
These are not abstract questions; they are concrete policy choices that will affect every Virginian regardless of party affiliation. And, as the President drives more decisions and control down to the states – state policy should be the primary concern of Virginia voters now more than ever.
Mark Warner, once a moderate Democrat, has become a partisan hack.
by Kerry Dougherty
It’s unseemly, not to mention unpatriotic.
I’m talking about the Democrats and assorted lefties in the media who this week were gleefully calling the American B-2 bombing of key Iranian nuclear sites a failure. Their premature celebrations were based on a leaked initial damage assessment that was labeled “low confidence.”
By trumpeting this slice of misinformation they were essentially cheering for Iran.
A country that wants us all dead.
How much must they hate Donald Trump to be siding with the Islamist extremists running Iran?
Yet there they were, hoping that the chief exporter of terrorism in the world was able to hold onto it’s enriched uranium so it could quickly build bombs to drop on Israel and ultimately the U.S.
All to make Donald Trump look bad.
These people are sick. Reopen the asylums.
We’ve come to expect this sort of nasty schadenfreude from the likes of CNN, MSNBC, and assorted nasties in Congress.
Oh look. Virginia Sen. Mark Warner initially found reports of minimal damage at Fordow “interesting.” Continue reading.
PJM generation mix at noon Thursday. Hydrocarbon fuels produced 67% and nuclear about 23%.
By Steve Haner
Once again, a spell of hot weather has proven that our economy and comfort depend on hydrocarbon fuels. As you can see from these simple pie graphs from the PJM regional energy market, two-thirds of the electricity sustaining Virginia on a recent hot afternoon was produced by natural gas, oil and coal.
One graph shows wind and solar provided a pittance of power, a nominal, merely symbolic amount. Wind energy is notorious for fading during hot spells. And the disappearance of solar from the grid as the sun sets can produce incredible spot prices for additional megawatts of electricity that then become needed. The marginal price in Virginia exceeded $3,000 within the PJM trading network earlier this week.
That is $3 per kilowatt hour, not the 15 cents per kilowatt hour most Virginians usually pay for the power itself. Yes, sometimes solar power is cheap. Then it dies in the dark and the cost to replace it will crush our economy and wallets. Gas, coal and nuclear power run our world and cool our houses, and they don’t go down at sunset or when the wind dies.
The PJM Interconnection, which includes Virginia among its 13-state operations region. apparently functioned well in the hot spell. It was not any hotter than we see most summers, but PJM was hitting records. There were times on the public metering of PJM when it was clear the reserve margins were getting tight. An unexpected disruption – a failed power plant or transmission line – could have triggered brownouts or worse.
Additional generation is needed, preferably inside Virginia, and it must be reliable and dispatchable (works on demand). The time to start was two or three years ago, but so far only solar and wind are being added. The quickest dispatchable option is natural gas. The impediment to getting it is the obsolete Virginia Clean Economy Act (VCEA).
The New York Times is reporting that the Trump administration has demanded that the University of Virginia fire President Jim Ryan as the condition for “resolving” the federal government’s investigation into the school’s DEI efforts.
President Trump has declared DEI illegal. No courts have done so. As much as they dislike Ryan, do conservatives really want to endorse the federal government dictating that a college president and the college’s policies align with the personal policies of the President of the United States? If so, this country is on the path to becoming an autocratic Hungary.
The year: 2075. The American colonies on the Moon are getting restless under Washington’s tyrannical rule….
This second edition of “Dust Mites” has a snazzy new cover, includes helpful lunar maps, and is 5,000 words tighter than the original. The sequel, “Trogs,” is scheduled for publication this summer.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
About
Bacon’s Rebellion is Virginia’s leading politically non-aligned portal for news, opinions and analysis about state, regional and local public policy. Read more about us here.
Fund the Rebellion
Shake up the status quo! Your contributions will be used to pay for faster download speeds and grow readership. Make a one-time donation by credit card or contribute a small sum monthly.
Can’t wait until tomorrow
For your Bacon’s Rebellion fix?
Enter your email address to receive immediate notifications of new posts by email.
SUBSCRIBE
Search Bacon’s Rebellion
Categories
Archives
The Jefferson Council
Protecting Thomas Jefferson’s Legacy at the University of Virginia
Forgot Your Password?
Shoot me an email and I’ll generate a new password for you.
