by James A. Bacon
Deputy Provost Brie Gertler posed quite the conundrum to the University of Virginia Board of Visitors this afternoon: Ninety-two percent of UVA Jewish students felt valued as individuals in 2024, according to a poll by Student Experience in the Research University (SERU). But only 52% agreed that students sharing their religious beliefs were respected on Grounds. Indeed, the percentage of Jewish students feeling the love toward Judaism had declined sharply since the previous survey in 2022.
A similar gap existed for Muslim students, but it was much smaller. Seventy-five percent of Muslim students at UVA felt valued as individuals while only 66% perceived that Muslim students were getting respect. The percentage feeling positive vibes about their religion also declined from the previous year, though only half as much as it did for Jewish students.
The good news, which Gertler emphasized in her presentation, is that the percentage of Jews and Muslims feeling valued and respected was slightly higher at UVA than at four peer universities (University of Berkeley, University of Michigan, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, and University of Texas-Austin).
But she was at a loss to explain how Jewish students at UVA could rate their individual experience so highly while feeling so down about the way their religion was perceived.
What, oh, what could be going on? Was it something in the way the survey questions were worded? Or, given the fact that only a fifth or so UVA students participated in the SERU survey, could there have been some kind of self-selection bias? Or, given the inherent variability in small sample sizes — only 99 Jewish students and 90 Muslims taking part in the survey — were the numbers randomly skewed?
No one seemed to have an answer. Let me throw this out there: Could the dizzying drop in positive vibes have been tied to the fact that the survey took place in March-April 2024, only a half year after Hamas launched its surprise terror attack on Israel? And the fact that Hamas and Israel still were locked in a war? And that pro-Palestinian groups at UVA were holding marches, demonstrations, and die-ins and accusing Israel of genocide? And that many people were blurring pro-Israel “Zionists” with Jews generally? And that dozens of UVA faculty had signed letters in support of the Palestinians? And that the student body had voted to demand UVA divest its endowment of Israeli assets and cut ties with Israeli scholars? And that antisemitic slurs were on the rise? And that many Jewish students felt so cowed that they hid signs of their ethnic identity such as stars of David?
(more…)
