• Help Me Out. Let’s FOIA UVa about Trespass Warnings

    Bacon passes around the tin cup

    by James A. Bacon

    Back in April 2018 Jason Kessler, the white nationalist organizer of the infamous Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, found himself the target of a series of lawsuits. He was spotted in the University of Virginia Law School library one day, minding his own business and reading up on the law. Someone recognized him, and word quickly spread. Traumatized by his presence, law school students chased him out of the room. The law school followed up by obtaining a Trespass Warning to bar him from setting foot in the library.

    Later that same year, med school student Kieran Bhattacharya attended a panel discussion on the topic of microaggressions. In a question-and-answer exchange, he shocked many attendees by challenging the presenter’s premises. There unfolded a series of events, now the subject of litigation, that culminated with the issuance of a Trespass Warning forbidding him from entering the grounds.

    As Ian Fleming’s character Auric Goldfinger memorably told James Bond in “The Man with the Golden Gun,” “Once is happenstance, twice is coincidence, the third time it’s enemy action.”

    I have identified two instances in which enemies of the campus Left — one, the detestable Kessler and the other, Bhattacharya, a skeptic of social-justice pieties — have been banned from the university grounds. Could this be, in Goldfinger’s rendering, a coincidence? Or could it signify something running deeper in the UVa culture? Has the issuance of Trespass Warnings become a new tool — unappreciated by the public — for expelling undesirables and enforcing Leftist orthodoxy?

    I do not know the answer, but I want to find out. I have submitted a Freedom of Information Act request for copies of all Trespass Warnings issued by the University of Virginia police department since, and including, calendar year 2017. UVa estimates that it will charge me $880 to locate the records and redact them as necessary. (more…)


  • Even Western Virginia Has Police Shortages

    A criminal justice academy in Salem

    by James A. Bacon

    Police departments in Virginia’s major urban centers are not the only law enforcement agencies where police officers are quitting in large numbers. Roanoke County in western Virginia saw 28 officers leave during 2020, about one fifth of the department, The Roanoke Times has reported. That was twice the number the department would experience in a normal year. The City of Roanoke has 38 vacancies, about 15% of its force.

    Neighboring Montgomery County has lost 26 deputies, about 23% of its manpower over the past 12 months. That compares to only four officers departing in 2019, and two in 2018.

    The Town of Christiansburg (in Montgomery County) has similar issues. โ€œIn years past we would typically receive between 50 and 100 applications when we advertised an opening,โ€ Assistant Chief Chris Ramsey wrote in an email. โ€œNow we are lucky to get ten or fifteen applicants for multiple openings. Only a fraction of those will meet the minimum qualifications and actually appear for applicant testing.โ€ (more…)


  • Challenging UVa.’s Culture of Left-Wing Intolerance

    Note: This column is republished from The Washington Times.

    by James A. Bacon

    A committee appointed by University of Virginiaย Presidentย Jim Ryanย issued a statement this May outlining theย universityโ€˜s policy on free speech. As befitting theย universityย founded byย Thomas Jefferson, a champion of individual liberties, the committee stated its unequivocal โ€œcommitment to free expression and free inquiry.โ€

    The statement of abstract ideals was reassuring. The trick, as Mr. Ryan himself acknowledged, will be applying those principles in real-world situations. And that likely will be easier said than done. Mr.ย Ryanย will have to challenge theย universityโ€˜s culture of left-wing intolerance and expand the range of permissible viewpoints on such ideologically charged issues relating to social justice.

    Faculty members addressing the committee recounted undergoing mandatory โ€œtrainingโ€ sessions in which they were pressured to regurgitate officially sanctioned platitudes. Others spoke of reining in words that might be construed as micro-aggressions. Kenneth Elzinga, a popular economics professor who has taught more students than any other in the history of UVa, described students โ€œwho tell us they are afraid to express their views in the classroom.โ€ (more…)


  • A Warning for Democrats

    Ross Douthat

    By Dick Hall-Sizemore

    Ross Douthat, a New York Times columnist, has written a couple of pieces that provide the bestย  synopsis and analysis of the current controversy over teaching race and racial history that I have seen. (The columns can be found here and here.)

    He starts off with a perceptive comment on the current state of affairs: โ€œItโ€™s becoming hard to tell what the argument is about.โ€

    In the first column, he summarizes ย progressivesโ€™ goals as wanting to change the way that schools teach American history by exorcising the Lost Cause hagiography and broadening the โ€œnarrative of race beyond the Civil War and the civil rights era.โ€ They also want to โ€œweave these revisions into a more radical narrative of U.S. history as a whole.โ€ He notes that conservatives โ€œoften see themselves as objecting to the most radical parts of progressive revisionism, not the entire project.โ€ He concludes onย  a hopeful note:

    ย  โ€œYou could imagine, out of this controversy, potential forms of synthesisโ€”ย  in which the progressive desire for a deeper reckoning with slavery and segregation gets embedded in a basically patriotic narrative of what the founding established, what Lincoln achieved, what America meant to people of many races, even with our sins.โ€ (more…)


  • Loudoun County High Schools Beaten Soundly by Virginia Beach in Math SOLs

    by James C. Sherlock

    This is part 3 of my recent series on Loudoun County schools in general and its high schools in particular. It will confirm what we have already discussed.

    I will here compare Loudoun schools in 2018-19 math SOL performance (last year pre-COVID) and other metrics with the schools in Virginia Beach. A spreadsheet with the data for each is posted that includes the same data for Wise County.

    Take a look. It is rendered as a heat map. Dark green is outstanding and dark red is bad. The comparison is with statewide averages. The rest of the palette is rendered accordingly.

    Loudoun residents wonโ€™t like the outcome.

    In parts 1 and 2 I showed with state data that Loudoun County high schools greatly outspent and yet underperformed the schools in Wise County in the Virginia coalfieldsย  There are specific Loudoun high schools that drove down the overall results.

    The identical comparison between Loudoun and Virginia Beach high schools yielded the same results.

    Exactly. (more…)


  • The Flags in Our Hearts

    In my Henrico County neighborhood, many residents don’t need to wait for Independence Day, the 4th of July, to display the American flag. They do so year-round. (I took the photo above more than a month ago.) They are not bigots. They are not white nationalists. They are patriots. They love their country. It’s that simple.

    Yes, our country is flawed. We have not managed to repeal human nature, and rapid, disruptive technological change outpaces the ability of our institutions to keep up. We have much work to do, and we always will. But our nation has stamped out more evil and it has brought more freedom and more prosperity to the world than any other in the history of mankind. I won’t be flying the flag, because such overt displays of patriotism are not my way. But I carry my love of country in my heart every day, as most all of us do.

    — JAB


  • Loudoun County School Board Needs to Clean up its Own Equity Mess

    by James C. Sherlock

    The Loudoun County School Board gets to lecture absolutely no one about equity.ย The richest county in America has shoehorned most of the high schoolers among its record low percentage of poor children into one of its 15 high schools, Park View High.

    That in itself is not an indictment. ย They go to school where they live, and in Loudoun County most live in Sterling near Dulles Airport in the Park View High School district.

    What is utterly unusual, and a disgrace, is that having placed them in Park View, LCPS has failed to educate them.

    For context read my report yesterday. Only 60% of Park View’s Black students passed SOL math tests; 70% of its Hispanics.

    Virginia Department of Education data puts the lie to the school boardโ€™s incessant claims of systemwide systemic racism. Eighty-six percent of Briar Woodโ€™s Highโ€™s Black students passed math SOLs, as did 90% of its Hispanic students. Those are virtually the same as the white student 88% pass rate state wide. (more…)


  • Virginia’s First Anti-Racists

    Maybe it’s not so surprising that Black students in Wise County schools out-perform their racial counterparts in Loudoun County (see previous post) when you consider that far Southwest Virginia was the first region of the Old Dominion to integrate — years before Civil Rights legislation was enacted. Frank Kilgore, a long-time coalfields booster, sent two photos as evidence. The first, above, shows the first integrated Little League team in the South — Norton, Va., 1951. (more…)


  • Are Poor Rural White Wise County Evangelicals More Antiracist than the Wealthy, Urbane Citizens of Loudoun?

    ย  ย 

    by James C. Sherlock

    Many are fascinated with the nationally infamous Loudoun County School Board. Board members seem preoccupied with driving social change without pausing to look at data. ย 

    I have thought someone ought to check how the Loudoun students have been faring in SOLs to see if there are academic issues that need to be addressed.ย ย 

    State data show that in too many Loudoun high schools Black, Hispanic, immigrant and the poor students performed poorly in math SOLs.ย The data are presented relative to state average math SOL pass rates for those cohorts, which in many cases themselves areย very disturbing in an absolute sense.

    It is not a resource problem. ย 

    Loudoun is the nationโ€™s richest county in median household income and neighboring Fairfax County is among the top few. Median household incomes in Loudoun were $142,299 and Fairfax $124,831. The state average median household income was about half Loudounโ€™s. ย 

    Again as before, 2018-19 remains the base year for assessments because that was the last year that SOLs were not interrupted by COVID and subsequently the last year for which the state has district and individual school evaluation data.

    The Loudoun County School Board and its school superintendent need to investigate why students in all racial and social cohorts in profoundly poor Wise County in Southwestern Virginia crushed Loudoun students in high school math SOLs.

    Maybe they will learn something. And then perhaps the students will.

    You know, real school board work. (more…)


  • Bacon M.I.A.

    So much to say, so little time! Unfortunately, I’ll be Missing in Action over the next few days while attending to family matters. I’ll parachute in, if time permits. But I’m counting on the rest of the Bacon’s Rebellion team to cover for me in my absence. — JAB


  • Were Virginia Lawmakers Stoned When They Legalized Pot?

    by Kerry Dougherty

    No one ever accused the current members of the Virginia General Assembly of crafting elegant laws.

    But the new bill that legalized marijuana this week is so confusing that the lawmakers must have been stoned when they wrote it.

    The measure was supposed to take effect on January 1, 2024, with a framework in place for regulating, selling and taxing marijuana. But the majority in the General Assembly couldnโ€™t wait that long so they concocted a cockamamie plan that divided the legalization into two ridiculous parts.

    As of Thursday it became perfectly legal for anyone over 21 in Virginia to possess up to one ounce of pot.

    But it wonโ€™t be legal to BUY marijuana in Virginia until January 1, 2024. By then, the rules governing the sale and distribution will be crafted by the governor-appointed Virginia Cannabis Control Authority.

    Sort of like the parole board, only with the munchies. (more…)


  • Fight the Machine, File for an Exemption!

    by James A. Bacon

    The Young Americans for Liberty chapter at Virginia Tech delivered a petition with about 500 signatures urging the university to end a policy requiring students to be fully vaccinated against COVID-19 to take classes in the fall, reports The Center Square.

    โ€œThis arbitrary order is a blatant violation of the studentsโ€™ rights to medical freedom,โ€ said Ian Escalante, a YAL regional director. โ€œIt is time for us to set the government school system straight, and let them know that they will not be controlling our students.โ€

    Virginia Tech had no response to the petition other than to refer to a previous statement by President Timothy Sands: โ€œDuring the past two semesters, we weathered significant surges in COVID-19 cases in Blacksburg. We did this through robust testing, self-quarantine, masking, and physical distancing. We must do everything possible to avoid repeating the challenges of the last 14 months. … It is essential that every student who can be vaccinated, is vaccinated.โ€

    No, it is not essential that every student be vaccinated. COVID-19 survivors don’t need to be vaccinated. That suggests to me that there might be a more effective way to fight the bureaucratic machinery at Virginia Tech (and other universities) than petitioning to abolish the vaccination requirement altogether. (more…)


  • Youngkin Gets Romneyfied

    Glenn A. Youngkin

    by James A. Bacon

    The Associated Press has just published a story highlighting the plight of newly retired Judy Pavlick in a mobile home park in Sunnyvale, California. When the park was acquired in 2015 by the Carlyle Group, a Washington, D.C.-based investment firm, “things began to change.” Pavlick’s rent surged 7%. Additional fees followed. The higher costs forced her and her neighbors, “many on fixed incomes and unable to relocate” to “sometimes choose between food and medicine.”

    Here’s the kicker:

    The deal, one of hundreds Carlyle executed in recent years, could become a political liability for the companyโ€™s former co-CEO, Glenn Youngkin, who is now running as the Republican candidate for governor in Virginia and highlighting his experience โ€œbuilding businesses and creating jobs.โ€

    I knew this was coming. It was inevitable. We saw this attack before — in 2012 when Mitt Romney ran for president against Barack Obama. The Obama campaign highlighted Romney’s track record as CEO of Bain Capital, which financed the acquisition and turnaround of dozens of companies, often restructuring businesses and laying off workers in the process.

    Youngkin is being Romneyfied. The AP article was just the opening salvo. (more…)


  • The Louise Lucas Recall Attempt

    Louise Lucas

    by Kerry Dougherty

    This may come as a shock, but I donโ€™t like whatโ€™s happening to State Sen. Louise Lucas, D-Portsmouth.

    No, this isnโ€™t a coded message to signal that Iโ€™m being held somewhere against my will. I honestly believe that attempts to get the courts to remove her from office are misguided.

    Make that court.

    With the proper number of signatures, citizens in Virginia may ask a circuit court judge to decide if a public official should get the boot.

    The threshold number of signatures is relatively small, too. Just 10% of the number of voters in the last election, which in this case comes to 4,651. The Virginian-Pilot reports that the petitioners claim to have thousands more names than needed. (more…)


  • VMI Officer Commissions Among Minorities