• Virginia is the Queen Mother of Bellwethers

    Delegate Eileen Filler-Corn

    by Chris Saxman

    Honestly, where does one start in trying to explain Virginia politics?

    Wednesdayโ€™s leadership change by House Democrats should not be considered shocking. Democrats had very close contests for caucus control after they won the majority, so losing that majority would naturally jeopardize their leaders.

    Suffice it to say, Delegate Eileen Filler-Corn has never had a firm grip on her caucus having won close leadership elections and she barely lost the vote Wednesday.

    Just one vote.

    Was Wednesday about the younger, more aggressive progressives making a move? Like most things in politics, itโ€™s complicated, but Democrats nationally are losing the enthusiasm of younger progressive voters.

    See my 2024 Electoral College Preview on the Democrats problem with younger voters. (AH – yes – the possible move by Joe Biden to forgive student loan debt.)

    Thereโ€™s more to the leadership change than age demographics. This likely came down to the simple fact that Democrats lost control of the House in November and had no clear plan to win it back. In fact, they could possibly lose even more seats this year. (more…)


  • School Daze

    by Jim McCarthy

    Governor Glenn Youngkin had an opportunity to withdraw his big-footed amendment to a bill that would have moved the election date of the Loudoun County School Board from 2022 to 2023 and vacate the nine board seats for a new election. The original bill sought only to stagger the terms of five of the seats. Now, rejected by vote of Democrats in the senate, the Governor has the choice of vetoing the original bill or signing it.

    Whichever choice is made, it is not likely to diminish the feral fever that has enveloped school board meetings nor will it appease the bloodlust outrage stoked during the campaign.

    Passage of the proposed amendment rested, in part, upon the Dillon Rule, a judicial doctrine from the 1800s which provides that a local jurisdiction may exerciseย onlyย what authority is conferred by the parent state. This principle, in turn, is mirrored by another dominant value that has guided educational policy for centuries called in loco parentis (ILP) or in place of the parent. Historically, as population grew and shifted from agrarian settings to urban and suburban ones with enhanced employment opportunities, the education of youth was entrusted to a public school system with professional personnel. (more…)


  • No, Joe, They’re Not Your Kids

    by Kerry Dougherty

    Letโ€™s try this again, for those eating paste in the back of the class:

    Children belong to their parents. Parents donโ€™t surrender their rights to the people paid to educate their offspring when they drop their kids off at school. Parents want to know whatโ€™s being taught in the classroom and they have a right to have a say in it.

    Yet, just months after Terry McAuliffe lost his bid to become governor of Virginia, Joe Biden made the same mistake that cost McAuliffe the Governorโ€™s Mansion.

    โ€œI donโ€™t think parents should be telling schools what they should teach,โ€ snapped McAuliffe during a debate with Glenn Youngkin last year.

    Those 12 words set him on the path to defeat.

    They also appeared repeatedly in Youngkin for Governor ads and they resonated. Especially because the National School Boards Association had just written a letter to Bidenโ€™s Department of Justice asking that disgruntled parents be declared domestic terrorists. (more…)


  • The Book Burners Next Door

    Photo credit: Washington Post

    by Dick Hall-Sizemore

    James Sherlock alerted us yesterday to a โ€œbigger threat to our nation than Russia and Chinaโ€ by the left. While the Biden administrationโ€™s establishment of an effort to combat online disinformation is somewhat disquieting, its dimensions are somewhat vague. It could be no more than a federal government โ€œfact checker.โ€

    On the other hand, we need only to look to one of our neighbors for a concrete example of the Orwellian future some on the right would impose. (more…)


  • Stoney Versus the Environ-istas

    Image credit: Virginia Public Media

    by James A. Bacon

    Environmental activists in the City of Richmond aren’t happy with Mayor Levar Stoney’s proposed budget. The City’s Draft Climate Equity Action Plan sets a goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions 45% by 2030 — and reaching net zero by 2050 — but Stoney’s budget plan doesn’t provide funding for conversion to electric vehicles, increasing the city’s urban forestry staff, or phasing out natural gas, as environmentalists would like.

    โ€œIf we are truly serious about this master plan that puts environmental justice at the forefront, we need to put our money where our mouth is,โ€ said Elle De La Cancela, an organizer with the Chesapeake Climate Action Network, as reported by Virginia Public Media.

    โ€œOur funding is not limitless, and we have many priorities in the city,โ€ retorted Stoney spokesperson Jim Nolan in an email. โ€œWe have to provide funding for public education, affordable housing and homelessness, basic city services like sanitation and street cleaning, parks, clean water, all of the above.โ€

    This is one of those rare occasions where I side with Stoney. As mayor, he has to consider the interests of a wide range of constituents — not the least of which include the city’s low-income minorities. Murders are up. Schools are melting down. Surging rents are intensifying the homeless problem. And, oh, by the way, the taxpayers paying for all this would like to maintain a modicum of city services like sanitation, pothole-free streets, litter-free parks and the like. The last thing Stoney wants is to preside over an exodus of middle- and upper-income taxpayers from the city. (more…)


  • George Orwell Call Home

    Nina Jankowitz

    by James C. Sherlock

    This blog, while proudly based in individual research, often offers controversial ideas.

    Uniform agreement is not expected. Debate is encouraged. We learn from one another and even occasionally change a few minds on both sides.

    Yesterday the Biden administration announced the establishment of a federal โ€œDisinformation Governance Boardโ€ in the Department of Homeland Security to “combat online disinformation in the 2022 midterms.”

    Seriously. It was disclosed yesterday afternoon by Secretary Mayorkas in his testimony on Capitol Hill.

    You will not be shocked to learn that neither The Washington Post nor The New York Times has yet covered the story. I just checked.ย Yet it represents a bigger threat to our nation than Russia and China. And it lives within the Department of Homeland Security. (more…)


  • Virginia Democrats in Disarray

    Delegate Eileen Filler-Corn

    by Kerry Dougherty

    Whoa. That was quick. Unprecedented in recent years, too.

    Del. Eileen Filler-Corn, the much ballyhooed first female Speaker of Virginiaโ€™s House of Delegates, as well as the commonwealthโ€™s first Jewish speaker, was tossed overboard Wednesday from her leadership role in the Democratic caucus by fellow party members.

    Five months after Republicans regained the majority in the House of Delegates and swept the top three jobs in the commonwealth, Democratic delegates gave an unceremonious boot to the woman who had headed the party for the past two years.

    Filler-Corn is expected to be replaced by a man.

    Of course.

    The mutiny was reportedly orchestrated by two-term Delegate Don Scott Jr., D-Portsmouth. He gained notoriety two weeks into the 2022 session by attacking Gov. Glenn Youngkin, saying, โ€œSo far what Iโ€™ve seen from his Day 1 activities he is not someone who is a man of faith, not a Christian.โ€ (more…)


  • Conservative-Liberal Common Ground on High Stakes K-12 End-of-Year Testing

    by James C. Sherlock

    I have reported here often on the fierce opposition of much of the public education establishment — read graduate schools of education and the teachers unions — to what they label “high-stakes” testing.

    What many in those groups really object to is the visibility of standards that subjects them to public review and the accountability that testing brings.

    But there are legitimate complaints about the current system.

    • Some teachers feel constrained by the tests. Many think the time devoted to end-of-year testing could be better spent.
    • Others, including parents, contend that accountability is necessary, but they find the information comes too late to be actionable.

    Those are legitimate observations. Florida appears to have found a way to satisfy those issues while maintaining accountability. (more…)


  • U.S. Supremes: No Pause on TJ Revised Admissions Policy

    The U.S. Supreme Court refused to pause Thomas Jefferson High School’s race-based admissions policy that, in the words of activist mom and journalist Asra Nomani, is “destroying the school’s culture and excellence.” The ruling means that the policy, which replaces admissions based on tests, will remain in effect at least one more year while litigation continues. The Federalist has her take on the ruling here.

    The school still ranks No. 1 in the latest U.S. News & World-Report ranking of the top high schools in the nation. But Nomani questions how long it can hold on to its lofty reputation. As noted in the previous Bacon’s Rebellion post, TJ’s freshman class this year had weaker math backgrounds than previous classes. Despite a ramp-up in tutoring for struggling students, the number of dropouts, though relatively small, is up significantly this year.

    “According to people familiar with the school, the situation has become so bad the principal has instructed counselors to connect her with students considering leaving the school, so she can meet with them and keep her numbers down, something she didnโ€™t do regularly before,” writes Nomani.

    Says an anonymous source for Nomani’s story: โ€œOur countryโ€™s No. 1 school has become the Titanic.โ€ย 

    — JAB


  • More TJ Students Students Are Dropping Out

    by Asra Nomani

    For months now, parents and community members have been hearing distressing stories about how educrats failed students in their rush to fill the Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology Class of 2025 through lower academic admissions standards hastily implemented in December 2020.

    The school started a new remedial Algebra 1 after-school program and the school is seeing Class of 2025 students dropping out at an alarming rate, by most accounts because they werenโ€™t prepared academically for the rigorous coursework.

    My data analysis: Record numbers of freshmen students fleeing TJ

    For example, in data that I pulled from theย school districtโ€™s official website,ย the school district reported that of the 550 students admitted in the Class of 2025, the school started off โ€” first of all โ€” with only 541 students in September 2021.

    One student from the Class of 2025 left the school in October. Two students left in November. Another four students left in December. One more departed in January, with two more leaving in February and then another two more saying goodbye to TJ in March, bringing the Class of 2025 to 529 students.

    Thatโ€™s 12 students who dropped out of the school to return to their base school, most likely. The number may not seem large but consider that only one student dropped out the entire year before from the Class of 2024.

    (more…)


  • An Environment So Hostile, No Reasonable Person Could Endure It

    Photo credit: NBC29

    by James A. Bacon

    On June 11, 2021, after a series of orientation meetings and training sessions to discuss “anti-racism” at the Agnor-Hurt Elementary School, Albemarle County officials held a final training session. A presenter showed slides showing a disparity in the racial breakdown of the school division’s employees and new hires.

    Responding to the presentation, Emily Mais, an assistant principal at the school, suggested that it would be useful to compare the racial breakdown of the hires to that of the applicant pool to determine if the racial disparity was due to the district’s selection process or to the lack of minority applicants. In her remarks, she was thinking “people of color” but she inadvertently used the word “colored” instead. She immediately apologized for her slip of the tongue.

    The verbal miscue prompted a response from Sheila Avery, a teacher’s aide who presented herself as a representative of other Black employees. In Mais’s rendering of the story detailed in a lawsuit filed in Albemarle County Circuit Court, Avery accused her, in the complaint’s words, “of speaking like old racists who told people of color to go to the back of the bus.” Avery’s verbal abuse was so severe that several staff members expressed their alarm in communications to Mais during and after the session.

    And so began Mais’s surreal journey through a school system that, in the name of expunging racism, has elevated racial consciousness and racial grievance to levels not seen in decades, demoralized White teachers by impugning them as racists, compelled Mais to make a forced apology to the school staff, and through her example cowed other employees from expressing reservations about the anti-racist training. (more…)


  • Election Mulligan

    by Jim McCarthy

    Virginiaโ€™s new governor has proposed a legislative amendment preempting the normal election cycle and terms of office for a county school board in what can only be described as a โ€œdo over.โ€ The amendment moves a school board election date from 2023 to 2022 and authorizes a new election for the nine-member body.

    Politically, the move, an increasingly familiar trope among some conservative legislatures, echoes the โ€œbig stealโ€ theme and tactics to magnify electoral results by officials. While not drawing inordinate attention, it is, at its core, a pernicious attempt to scuttle the democratic process that seated the board at its last election.

    The ostensible rationale is related to the handling of sex crimes by the Loudoun County School Board occurring in late 2021 at the height of the campaign season. The Republican gubernatorial candidate, and ultimate winner, capitalized on the contentious issue declaring his conclusions while calling for an investigation stating: (more…)


  • A Different Tone

    by Dick Hall-Sizemore

    There have been some complaints lately about how the Richmond newspaper should be called the Richmond Times-Dominion, due to its biased coverage in favor of the utility. While I agree with a lot of the criticism about taking a Dominion news release, rewriting it and then publishing it as news, a sentence in a story in todayโ€™s RTD struck me because it is definitely not in the line of that narrative:

    โ€œDominion has a history of being a top donor to Virginia politicians, who in turn write laws that help the utility earn extra profit at the expense of its customers.โ€

    Of course, the reporter writing the story is Patrick Wilson, one of the newspaperโ€™s best reporters.


  • If You’re Not on the “Anti-Racist” School Bus, Maybe It’s Time You Got Off the Bus

    Photo credit: NBC29

    by James A. Bacon

    During anti-racism training last June, Emily Mais, an assistant principal at Agnor-Hurt Elementary School in Albemarle County, used the term “colored people” instead of “people of color” when referring to staff demographics. She made a “slip of the tongue,” she says, but she apologized anyway.

    Not everyone was prepared to forgive. Sheila Avery, a teaching assistant at the school, chastised her at the training session and several times afterwards, according to a lawsuit filed a week ago. Avery allegedly cursed her openly, calling her a “white racist bitch,” and told other employees she was a racist who intentionally demeaned Black people.

    Other employees were afraid to defend her for fear of retaliation, Mais says in the complaint, which was filed April 13 and reported by The Daily Progress and other local media outlets. The relentless criticism caused her such emotional distress that she resigned. But district administrators would not allow her to leave on good terms without first issuing a groveling public apology to teachers and staff. That apology, the complaint says, “was carefully orchestrated by district officials to humiliate, shame, and traumatize.”

    Mais believed she was subjected to a hostile work environment on the basis of her race.ย After state and federal equal opportunity officials showed no interest in her case, she filed suit against the Albemarle County School Board. Her treatment, the complaint says, is the direct outgrowth of so-called “anti-racist” training policies enacted by the Albemarle school system — a program derived from Critical Race Theory that “scapegoats, stereotypes, labels, and ultimately divides people based on race.” (more…)


  • The Latest Wrinkle in the Law-Enforcement-for-Rent Saga

    by James A. Bacon

    The Office of Attorney General (OAG) under former AG Mark Herring failed to adequately conduct a search for documents requested under the Freedom of Information Act by climate-change skeptic Christopher Horner, a Richmond Circuit Court Judge has found. The court ordered the OAG, now under Attorney General Jason Miyares, to conduct a new search.

    The issue arose from communications between Herring’s OAG and the State Energy & Environmental Impact Center (SEEIC) backed by billionaire Michael Bloomberg. Under an arrangement agreed to by the OAG, SEEIC would fund the hiring of an OAG attorney to “advanc[e] progressive clean energy, climate change, and environmental positions.” Horner, a Keswick resident and senior fellow with the Competitive Enterprise Institute, exposed the communications but hit a dead end in further inquiries when the OAG claimed an exemption for working papers.

    The larger legal issue is whether Virginia’s Attorney General is allowed to strike deals with private parties to fund positions on his staff that the General Assembly has not approved in its budget. Although Herring negotiated a deal to pursue a left-leaning cause, his action could have created a precedent for a successor to collaborate with conservative groups to harness the power of the OAG to pursue conservative causes. (more…)