
by Jon Baliles
There have been a lot of embarrassing moments in the history of city government, but one that will soon be in the Hall of Fame is taking place before our eyes, with the latest edition occurring last Tuesday in the John Marshall Courthouse. A trial that began more than 18 months ago has turned into a full blown circus with clownish embarrassment as the cost to the city has already gone through the roof with the Mayor claiming what you are reading about from reporters (who are actually in the courtroom) is not true.
The truth is that under the big top, the city is being represented by a third- party legal team led Jimmy Robinson, Jr. of the Ogletree Deakins law firm. Robinson was confrontational with Judge Claire Caldwell on Tuesday because she called him out for making statements that directly contradicted what he had told both the court and Graham Moomaw from The Richmonder concerning a motion filed on November 5th (and she read his emails aloud to the court).
It got to the surreal moment that when Robinson began to admonish Judge Caldwell and raised his voice towards her, the Sheriffโs Deputy serving as bailiff moved from her position on the side wall of the courtroom into a position between the lawyerโs table and the judge, and at one point told Robinson to calm down. The judge also at one point told Robinson to โlower your voice.โ
If your legal strategy includes sparring with the judge to the point and volume where the bailiff gets concerned enough to take a defensive position, then youโre no longer making a solid or coherent legal argument; you donโt need to be a lawyer or stay at a Holiday Inn Express to figure that out. Before we get to more of Tuesdayโs fireworks however, rewind to the last hearing in September.
(more…)









