• More Money for an “Indecipherable” K-12 Funding Formula?

    by James A. Bacon

    Virginia public schools receive less funding from the state than the 50-state national average, less than the Mid-Atlantic regional average, and less than three of the five bordering states, says a new report from the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC). The state needs to radically update its methodology for calculating Standards of Quality (SOQ), a measure of staff and other inputs that sets the bar for state funding. Adopting all of JLARC’s recommendations would cost taxpayers $1 billion in near-term funding and more than $2.5 billion longer-term.

    Democrats and media allies immediately used the JLARC report to claim that Virginia schools are “underfunded.” As Axios Richmond puts it: “Virginia is cheaping out on public school funding compared to most other states.” Then there was this from House Minority Leader Don Scott Jr., D-Portsmouth: Virginia’s GOP โ€œwould rather fund corporate giveawaysโ€ than studentsโ€™ education.

    Republicans pushed back. Secretary of Education Aimee Guidera and Superintendent of Public Instruction Lisa Coons noted that the report omitted the last two fiscal years, in which Virginia has funneled an additional $3.2 billion in state aid to public schools. More to the point, they contend, without major reforms such as raising educational standards and improving reading competency in elementary schools, “investments in K-12 funding likely will not translate into improved student outcomes.” (more…)


  • Loudoun County Public Schools โ€“ Part 2 โ€“ Sterling

    Park View High School – Courtesy Loudoun County Public Schools

    by James C. Sherlock

    We are told by the left that more money is the answer to better schools. That is what Virginia Democrats are running on as education policy.

    I am comparing two high schools in Americaโ€™s richest county, Loudoun, to control for per pupil expenditures.

    In Part 1 we looked at Freedom High School in Chantilly. Breathtaking results.

    Park View High School, like Freedom, is in Loudoun County. It’s in Sterling.

    Park View has 1,400 students, Freedom 2,000. The demographics are different. The Park View student body is far more economically disadvantaged and heavily Hispanic.

    Asian, White, Black and Hispanic kids from wealthy families at Freedom High all blew away the state assessments in 2021-22. The outcomes were far worse, even among Asian-American students, at Park View.

    Those results can be explained by differences in the learning environments.

    • At Park View 33% of the students were chronically absent in 2021-22; at Freedom 11%.
    • Offenses, Referrals and Arrests and Suspensions reported to the government in 2017-18 (last year available) not only between the two high schools, but even more disturbingly at Sterling Middle, a feeder to Park View, were starkly different.

    Loudoun Countyโ€™s money has not provided a suitable learning environment at Park View or Sterling Middle.

    Because of that failure, despite all of the spending, economically disadvantaged students in Loudoun test no better in math, reading and science than the state average for similarly disadvantaged students.

    The lesson I take away from this is that schools canโ€™t create learning environments and teach at schools like Park View and its feeders using the same methods they do with kids from wealthier families and expect good results.

    A focus on race, ethnicity and money misses the point. The issues are discipline and self respect. Both can be taught. (more…)


  • A Tale of Two UNESCO World Heritage Sites

    by James A. Bacon

    Italians demand that people treat their UNESCO World Heritage sites with respect. Consider the recent example of the idiot caught scratching graffiti onto a brick of the ancient Roman Colosseum. Italians reacted with outrage at video (taken by an equally outraged American) when Bulgaria-born Englishman Ivan Dimitrov used his key to memorialize his devotion to his girlfriend with the phrase, “Ivan + Hayley 23/6/23.”

    According to the Sunday Tribune, Dimitrov faces a potential 2- to 5-year prison sentence and a fine of 15,000 euros. He has since apologized, pleading that he didn’t realize the structure was nearly 2,000 years old. His legal representative hopes to negotiate a plea deal that would enable Dimitrov to pay the fine without serving jail time.

    Compare and contrast the reaction to Dimitrov’s offense with the response two years ago when Hira Azher posted the infamous “F— UVA” sign on the door of her room on the Lawn, also a UNESCO World Heritage site. (more…)


  • The Pettiness of Canceling John S. Mosby

    by Donald Smith

    In April, in Georgia, a correction morphed into an overreaction. As part of the ongoing process to change the names of military bases named for Confederate generals, Fort Benning became Fort Moore.ย Around the same time, the National Ranger Memorial Foundation (NRMF) responded to a directive from U.S. government officials.ย The NRMF sent workmen to the Ranger Hall of Fame stone tablet, created and maintained on Fort Moore by the foundation, and covered a single name — John S. Mosby. The workmen also pried up bricks that commemorated Confederates in the foundationโ€™s Ranger Memorial Walk.ย An exhibit on Mosby at the National Infantry Museum was also removed.ย With those actions, an understandable effort to modernize Army base names degenerated into pettiness.

    The Naming Commission, an investigative body established by Congress, recommended that all Army bases named for Confederate generals be renamed.ย I am a great-grandson of Confederate cavalrymen — and I freely admit the commission had a point. In 2022 the Army had more major active-duty bases named for Confederate generals who lost the Civil War than Union generals who won it.ย  ย 

    But the Naming Commission went farther than base names.ย Much, much farther.ย It looked for every street name, every monument, plaque, and sign on DoD facilities that might be perceived to show Confederates in a positive light.ย Like Dr. Seussโ€™ Grinch, it relentlessly searched for every last can of Confederate Who-Hash!ย It then recommended that, with few exceptions, all be removed or changed. Apparently Congress didnโ€™t reject any of the commissionโ€™s recommendations; that has caused names to be covered on stone tablets, memorial bricks to be pried up and (soon) campaign streamers that commemorate Confederate service to be removed from Army National Guard colors. (more…)


  • RVA History: Quintessential Preservationist

    by Jon Baliles

    Historic preservation is important for many reasons, like helping us better understand our past and how to improve it for future generations. One great advocate of preserving Richmondโ€™s history to convey stories forward was Mary Winfield Scott, who passed away in 1983, but whose legacy lives on in neighborhoods across Richmond, and who was the subject of a great piece by Greg McQuade at CBS6.

    Scott was a preservationist who helped save the 18th Century structure known as Linden Row on Franklin Street across from the cityโ€™s main library.

    โ€œ[She] quickly recognized that we were losing places that made Richmond unique,โ€ said Will Glasco, with Preservation Virginia, a group that was born from Scottโ€™s efforts.
    (more…)


  • Anti-Asian Discrimination is Condoned in Fairfax County

    by Carl Noller

    People have been coming to America for centuries, many of them drawn by the opportunities this country offered. It was less who you knew or who you could bribe and more what you knew. Martin Luther King may have put it best when he encouraged us to judge others by the content of character, rather than skin color. Recently, however, Democrats have been telling us that this is all wrong โ€” that race is the critical factor. Diversity, as a social goal, trumps all others.

    We have been electing Democrats in recent years, and, not surprisingly, they have begun implementing that vision, which inflames racial tensions. This can be seen very clearly with the changes in admissions criteria at Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology, ranked the best high school in the nation. The School Board deemed the Fairfax County high school too Asian. The student body needed to be more โ€œdiverse,” more reflective of the community. The School Board engineered this under a revised admissions process, which eliminated the standardized admissions test, eliminated the $100 application fee, and reserved seats in the freshman class for the top 1.5 percent of applicants from every middle school in the county. The effect was noticeable and will increase over the next three classes before leveling off, as those chosen under the old rules graduate.

    (more…)


  • Loudoun County Public Schools – Part 1 – Chantilly

    by James C. Sherlock

    Freedom High Seniors Waiting to Receive their Diplomas. Credit Hazel Nguyen, Design Editor, Uncaged (student Newspaper at Freedom)

    Part 1 of a series.

    Sometimes, even at my age and experience, I am legitimately surprised.

    After writing about the growth of leadership, support and administrative staffs in both institutions of higher learning and the public schools, I thought I had the picture.

    I did not.

    Then I looked at Freedom High School in Loudoun County.

    This article is not meant to reflect criticism, just amazement. (more…)


  • Jeanine’s Memes

    From The Bull Elephant.


  • UVa Admissions Trends: Whites Down, Asians Up, Blacks a Question Mark


    by James A. Bacon

    As the University of Virginia community debates the implications of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling restricting the use of race in higher-ed admissions, The Jefferson Council is publishing publicly available data that provide context for the discussion.

    UVa’s office of Institutional Research and Analysis publishes three types of admissions data (applications, admissions, and yield) broken down by race/ethnicity back to the 2016-17 academic year. Three trends stand out:

    • Once a dominant majority of UVa students, Whites officially became a minority (47%) of the entering 1st-year student body in 2023;
    • Asians were the fastest-growing racial/ethnic group at UVa, applying in greater numbers, being accepted in higher percentages, and (other than Whites) accepting those offers in higher percentages;
    • Despite applying and being accepted in growing numbers, the percentage of Blacks accepting their offers actually declined slightly, in contrast to the other racial/ethnic groups.

    (more…)


  • RVA 5×5: Referendum Waiting In The Wings

    by Jon Baliles

    Three weeks or so ago, the regurgitation of the casino referendum got a round of approval from almost everyone on City Council in a meeting that was filled with unearned righteousness about how it was going to save the city (kudos to Councilwoman Katherine Jordan for the lone no vote).

    Richmond BizSense reported that:

    Councilmembers contended that misinformation about the project the first go-round warranted putting it to the voters a second time. They stressed that the development (no longer being referred to as a casino), would not involve funding support from the city and would create jobs and economic opportunities for Southside and the rest of the city.

    Of course, most people knew this the last go-round because the advocates of the casino spent $2.5 million on billboards, mailers, and ads telling us ad nauseam about the โ€œbenefitsโ€ of a casino and how it wouldnโ€™t cost the city anything. Now, they want to pretend we were too stupid to know that the real reasons they were pushing the first time around werenโ€™t what they spent $2.5 million promoting.
    (more…)


  • Mr. Saddam Salimโ€™s Strange Acceptance of Political Endorsements

    Saddam Azlan Salim

    by Emilio Jaksetic

    In the upcoming November 2023 election, the Democratic Party candidate for Virginia Senate District 37 is Saddam Azlan Salim. Salim won the Democratic nomination by defeating Chap Peterson in the June 20, 2023 primary.

    A profile of Mr. Salim is available on Ballotpedia. A hypertext link in the Ballotpedia profile goes to Salimโ€™s campaign webpage. Among those endorsements are three by progressive prosecutors: Commonwealth Attorneys Steve Descano, (Fairfax County), Buta Biberaj (Loudoun County), and Parissa Dehghani-Tafti (Arlington County/Falls Church). On the face of it, those endorsements reflect the traditional practice of candidates to solicit and accept endorsements in support of their campaigns. However, the endorsements by the three progressive prosecutors are a problem for Salim because he is running for a seat in the Virginia Senate.

    Soliciting and accepting the endorsement of a particular person or group does not mean or imply that the candidate is in complete agreement with every act performed or statement made by the endorser. However, the three progressive prosecutors have made a point of claiming that their โ€œcriminal justice reformsโ€ are good for Virginians and expressing their intent to continue pursuing them.

    The endorsement of Salimโ€™s candidacy by those three progressive Commonwealth Attorneys indicates the following: (1) those prosecutors believe or know he is sympathetic to their โ€œcriminal justice reformโ€ efforts; and (2) they want voters to consider their endorsements as a reason for voting for Salim because they believe many voters are in agreement with their โ€œcriminal justice reformโ€ efforts. Furthermore, Salimโ€™s acceptance of their endorsements indicates he is sympathetic to, or in agreement with, the โ€œcriminal justice reformsโ€ of the three progressive prosecutors.
    (more…)


  • Bacon Meme of the week


  • Where Do Dems Stand on Civil Immunity for Law Enforcement Officers?

    by James C. Sherlock

    Photo credit: Richmond Times-Dispatch

    Being a law enforcement officer is tough under the best of circumstances.

    Do you think that exposure to losing your house and car in a civil suit for something you did in a split second to protect the public and yourself and did not have reason to know was against the law would deter you from a job in law enforcement?

    Truth is, it would deter all of us.

    Virginia Democrats in 2021 introduced legislation to eliminate under Virginia law a peace officer’s ability to offer an immunity defense in state courts against civil lawsuits for actions that violate constitutional rights:

    A. Any law-enforcement officer, as defined in ยง 9.1-101, who, under color of law, subjects or causes to be subjected, including failing to intervene, any other person to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities granted to such person under the constitutions and laws of the United States and the Commonwealth, shall be liable to the injured party for compensatory damages, punitive damages, and equitable relief….

    B. Sovereign immunity and any limitations on liability or damages shall not apply to claims brought pursuant to this section. Qualified immunity is not a defense to liability imposed by this section.

    A 2017 per curiam (unanimous) opinion by the Supreme Court reiterated a long-existing legal standard that qualified immunity is an available defense for law enforcement officers unless there is “clearly established law giving each individual Officer fair notice that his particular conduct was unlawful.โ€

    It is hard to imagine that the Supreme Court, unanimous there, would permit a state law that denied civil immunity without fair notice of the illegality of specific acts.

    Regardless, under the 2021 Democratic bill in Virginia, officers were to be in jeopardy in civil suits whether or not they had fair notice that their actions, split-second or otherwise, were unlawful. ย They were specifically to be required to judge the constitutionality of specific actions.

    With a gun in their face.

    It draws a very clear line for political debate. (more…)


  • Speaking of Banning Books

    by John Massoud

    Earlier this month, a Warren County resident was complaining about a โ€œsmall group of people who wish to ban booksโ€ from the Samuels Library. The writer talked about how many of the speakers that evening were not Warren County residents, or may have just purchased a library card so they could speak.

    The writer may not be aware of this, but by that last statement, he was trying to suppress free speech. Several of the speakers who were supporting allowing these books in the children’s section of Samuels Library were trying to suppress free speech. One of the more egregious examples was a young lady who early in the meeting said that โ€œchurches should not be allowed to speakโ€ because they โ€œdonโ€™t pay taxes.โ€ What she meant to say was that no person who attends a church should be allowed to speak. So people who attend church, who pay their taxes, should not be allowed to speak, yet anyone who agrees with those wanting to show porn to kids should be allowed to speak as they wish. This according to the logic of those who want to show porn to children.

    People like the writer say they are 100 percent for free speech. Yet they want anyone who disagrees with them to not be allowed to speak. The writer does not support free speech. He supports free speech if you agree with him. With that being said, here are the books that many leftists want banned (and in some cases have gotten banned):

    Of Mice and Men

    Adventures of Huckleberry Finn

    To Kill a Mockingbird

    Six books written by Dr. Seuss

    For the record, I, like pretty much every person today, finds use of the N word despicable. Yet, the fact is that โ€œHuck Finnโ€ is an American classic. Should Huckleberry Finn be banned because Mark Twain used a word which may have been acceptable in the late 1800s but is now rightly seen as disgusting? Of course not. Dr. Seuss is coming under fire because some radicals’ sensibilities are offended over artwork. Dr. Seuss was the least racist person of his time. (more…)


  • Democrats Tiptoe Towards an Education Platform

    By James C. Sherlock

    Northern Virginiaโ€™s morning newspaper, The Washington Post, arrived on lawns and driveways on Monday with cautious suggestions for Democratic education platforms for the 2023 and 2024 elections.

    Virginia Democrats, having lost the Governorship to education issues, are running in 2023 and have the first shot nationally at trying to find a winning message.

    Right now Democrats like Lashrecse Aird are running on a single-issue education agenda – more money. ย She offers that, exclusively, as her vision for education.

    Teachersโ€™ unions find additional funding to be the single acceptable โ€œreform.โ€ย  And they run Democratic education policy.

    Every Virginia Senate Democrat likely to have more comprehensive views of education reform lost in primaries. ย To teachersโ€™ union-backed candidates.

    The Postโ€™s Jennifer Rubin has helpfully broken Democratic elite silence on some education issues, but not the most important one.

    In her circles, she is otherwise relatively fearless.

    (more…)