The Home School Revolution

While the citizens of Richmond battle red tape and political agendas to create a single charter school (See Norm Leahy’s post, “The Patrick Henry Contract“), thousands of others are dropping out of the public education system. They’re called home schoolers, and their numbers are growing at an explosive rate.

At the invitation of Marc Montoni, a past contributor to the Bacon’s Rebellion e-zine, I dropped by a home school expo Sunday held at the Children’s Museum of Richmond to learn more about the movement. No one I talked to had a definitive count of the number of home schoolers in the Richmond region, but estimates ranged from 3,000 to 5,000. There are thousands more across Virginia. Statewide, the movement is growing at roughly 20 percent a year.

Let me be clear: I have no desire to home school my 10-year-old, who attends a private school. But I find much to admire in home schooling. Home-schooled children out-perform their peers in standardized tests and college admissions — and parents lay out only a tiny fraction of the cash that conventional public and private schools require.

I discovered Sunday that “home” schooling is something of a misnomer. The phrase conveys an image of children cooped up at home, books stuck in noses under the watchful eye of their teacher-mom. But if the exhibition booths were any indication, home schoolers get out and about more than most kids. Represented there were children’s gymnasiums, a rock climbing program, fitness centers, a martial arts studio, music studios, and a children’s theater — not to mention the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, the Virginia Science Museum, and the Children’s Museum. The private and not-for-profit sector is most happy to provide a wide array of services traditionally associated with schools.

Far from being solitary types, home schoolers are immensely sociable. Home school parents connect with one another through the Web and e-mail, often forming “co-ops” in which parents share teaching responsibilities, specializing in the fields they know best. At least one co-op in Richmond leases classroom space. Virginia home schoolers have their own magazine that shares news, resources and best practices. Publishers of textbooks, CD-ROMs and computer-assisted learning cater to the home-school market as well.

The structure of the home-school movement, which is roughly 25 years old in Virginia, is very free-form and egalitarian. I sense that the vast majority of participants are middle class: not wealthy enough to pay hefty private school tuitions, but well off enough that mom can stay at home to shepherd the kids. The people I saw were overwhelmingly white, although they defied ideological categorization. Home schoolers include evangelical Christians, libertarians and hippies.

I didn’t linger at the exhibition long enough to collect anything more than the most cursory of impressions, but I left with the notion that home schooling is the future of education in Virginia. While public schools are hamstrung by bureaucracy, home schoolers are experimenting and innovating like mad. Home schoolers are devising new curricula and new pedagogies. They’re embracing new technologies. They’re developing new models for sharing knowledge. And they’re availing themselves of community resources rather than recreating everything from libraries to sports facilities. Home schoolers have no need to invest in bricks and mortar. The community is their classroom.

And now for a word from our sponsor…

Maybe you aren’t going to home school your children, but it is certainly comfortable to earn your degree in the comfort of your own home! Find great information on how you can accomplish that at Online College Degrees.


ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)




Comments


Comments

14 responses to “The Home School Revolution”

  1. I was home schooled. Dozens of my friends were. My kid(s) will be home schooled, or so I hope. Public school seems to accommodate well some unknown chunk of kids (50%? 75%?), but there’s a significant minority for whom it’s not a great fit. For those families fiscally able to spare a breadwinner, home schooling is a great option.

  2. Interesting Fact…

    At Sundays session titled “Panel Discussion- Real Homeschoolers: Surviving the Early Years to Middle School” all four panel participants worked in and outside of the home while homeschooling their children. More interestingly 3 out of 4 own and operate their own companies. I was proud to be one of those 3.

    It is difficult road but it is possible to homeschool and be a breadwinner. While not for everyone it is the best for our family! We wouldn’t have it any other way!

    thanks

  3. I don’t have a problem with home schooling or even Charter Schools as long as we all recognize that our taxes for education apply to all of us whether we have kids or not.

    In other words, the retired guy who pays heavy taxes for education is the same as Mom/Dad who have two kids.

    Both of them owe their fair share of taxes for public education

    —- unless and until we change the rules – for EVERYONE – which would include those who pay taxes and who don’t have kids.

    where we seem to be headed is allowing folks with kids to keep their taxes and to spend it the way they see fit for their own kids education – and, to let “others” pay for the public education system.

    Let’s agree –

    1. – are we going to have a public education system?

    2. – if we say we will have one – then let’s have a fair system for taxing to provide it.

    Let’s agree to NOT tax one group of folks no matter how they feel and then to exempt other groups of folks because of how they do feel.

    thoughts?

  4. Not all homeschoolers are middle class. Some of us make great sacrifices in order to stay home with our children and educate them. We live in smaller houses on the wrong side of the tracks, we eat more hotdogs and we don’t take major vacations.

  5. Kris Bordessa Avatar
    Kris Bordessa

    Not entirely sure what Larry G is getting at, but as a home educator, I can guarantee that my family pays taxes – taxes that my kids don’t benefit from directly, because we are not within the public school system. Folks who use a state funded charter school – and I have, in the past – do have access to minimal funding to help pay for supplies/classes.

  6. Mama Squirrel Avatar
    Mama Squirrel

    Yeah, where do non-homeschoolers get that idea that homeschoolers’ taxes go somewhere other than the public education system, same as everyone else including the private schoolers and people with no kids at all? Maybe someday when a charter school system comes in, but until then we (homeschoolers) pay but (as already pointed out) don’t directly benefit.

  7. Mama Squirrel Avatar
    Mama Squirrel

    And, as Angie says, many of us have come from middle-class backgrounds but, technically, would be counted as living at or slightly below the poverty line. But, at least at our house, we’ve done the math and figured out that having me work part time (or having my spouse look for a slightly higher-paying job) would just bump us into the next tax bracket; so we might as well stay where we are, eating our hot dogs (on low-sodium rolls).

  8. “Not entirely sure what Larry G is getting at…”

    Ditto. It’s bit of a weird insert. I’ve never seen any concern over the taxes that go to education from homeschooling parents. We tend to consider education important and qare more than happy to pay our share.

  9. I do not homeschool but I have many friends who have or do; however, I take exception to Mr. Bacon’s comment “Home-schooled children out-perform their peers in standardized tests and college admissions…” and think he should add the word “Many” or any other similar word of his choosing. My second (of 2) child is a National Merit Semifinalist and currently ranked #1 in her senior class at an urban public school. In our home, we value knowledge over grades and we weren’t even aware of her class rank until the end of her 10th grade year when she was 3rd. She is not a “points junkie” but she is a quite remarkable young woman. She is (still) a Girl Scout, is in band, and is a manager of the girls’ varsity soccer team and will be applying early decision to an Ivy in a few months.

    That said, she has told me that if she has children she will not send them to public school. There are times when she does not enjoy school and that makes me sad but she would not leave because of band and her friends. She has had excellent teachers and some not-so-excellent ones but thankfully the exceptional ones have outnumbered the so-so ones. She has also said that she doesn’t really care if she gives a speech at graduation or not (if her ranking falls) because they wouldn’t let her give the speech she would want to give anyway-critical of the educational system presently in place.

    And Mama Squirrel, I KNOW that homeschoolers spend a great deal of their budget on books or curriculum and enrichment such as music lessons, art supplies, and museum trips, microscopes and visits to the zoo or the planetarium because education is that important to them and STILL pay taxes to fund public education. Even though we don’t homeschool, it makes me angry when people who have no idea what commitment it takes say that homeschooled kids get no “socialization” or get a sub-standard education simply because they may not be educated by a “professional”. I have given up trying to enlighten them.

  10. just to explain my tax about taxes.

    From many of the folks who are not satisfied with the public school system and want alternatives to it – many also want vouchers – in theory because their kids are not using public school resources.

    I was pointing out that folks without kids – also don’t have kids not using school resources but they still pay taxes for schools also.

    The issue with respect to whether or not each of us pays our fair share of taxes for public schools is separate and independent from whether or not we have kids that use the public schools.

    The folks who want their money back so they can use that money for non-public school education are no different that a retired guy wanting a rebate for police/fire rescue/etc because he did not use those services and would rather provide his own anyhow…

    I am no supporter of more and more money for public schools without accountability…

    I do believe that schools need to be more accountable for cost effectiveness…

    but I also believe that Public Schools are necessary and needed – and that we all owe our fair share of the bill to run them – regardless of whether we have kids or our own kids use Public Schools.

    The truth is – if you look at your property tax bill – and then look at how much it costs to educate one kid – that your property taxes (most folks) don’t even come close to paying the bill.

    so how is the shortfall made up?

    It’s made up by folks who pay taxes who don’t have kids.

    Does this make any sense?

    If it makes sense – does anyone agree or disagree with the philosophy?

  11. Taxes paid to fund education are intended to do just that. If the children are educated outside the public school setting, are they not still being educated? Is that not the purpose of funding education with our tax dollars?

    Taxpayers who do not have school-age children still benefit from the education of the children in their communities.

    Giving the parents of school-age children the choice of how to spend their child’s allotted education monies seems like a way to make the system more in-line with our capitalist economy, rather than a socialist economy so many seem to fear.

  12. Anonymous Avatar

    As a Mom of four, now grown children, and the Grandmon of homeschooled children in Richmond, I attended the expo on Sunday. I am constantly amazed at the enthusiam of parents and children I meet. After dealing with public school systems in NC and VA for many years, I feel the home schooled children are getting the best of both worlds-most important is the one-on-one educational attention which is carefully planned for them and their needs.

  13. re: “Is that not the purpose of funding education with our tax dollars?”

    Because if you have kids – you are not paying all the costs of educating them to start with in most cases.

    Essentially what you are advocating is getting a rebate on your property taxes because you will pay for your kids education.

    Where does that leave the guy who is paying property taxes for education and has no kids?

    Should he continue to pay or should he also get a rebate?

    Again – don’t get me wrong on the issue of funding public education.

    The public system of education is not very cost effective and their solution to the need for improvements invariably involves more money rather than reform and changes.

    But what kind of a society will we have if we no longer have public education and every parent will be directly responsible for the education of their kids?

    If you are a person who believes that you should have the right to get a rebate to take personal responsibility for the education of your kids – would you also agree that everyone else also have the same right to the same rebate – for cause?

    Why not give rebates to everyone – and let everyone deal with the issue themselves?

  14. April Michelle Davis Avatar
    April Michelle Davis

    It is nice to see that a parent who has no interest in homeschooling would come away with the positive aspects that homeschooling offers after being at the expo for such a short period of time. Bacon’s review brings hope that homeschooling will not always have the stigma that it has had for so many years.

    For more information about homeschooling, go to http://www.VAHomeschooling.com/blog.

Leave a Reply


ADVERTISEMENT