Confederate History Month Proclamation

If Gov. Kaine chooses to flip flop on his promise NOT to do a Confederate History Proclamation, here is some grist for his speech writers.

The quotes below come from my current read, “History of the English-Speaking Peoples” by Sir Winston Churchill – one of the greatest men of the recently past century.

The North, it was said, was enriching itself at the expense of the South. The Yankees were jealous of a style and distinction to which vulgar commercialism could never attain. They had no right to use the Federal Constitution which the great Virginians Washington and Madison had largely founded, in order to bind the most famous states to their dictates. They maligned and insulted a civilization more elevated in manners, if not worldly wealth, than their own. They sought to impose the tyranny of their ideas upon states which had freely joined the Union for common purposes, and might as freely depart when those purposes had been fulfilled.

Upon Lincoln’s call to arms to coerce the seceding states Virginia made without hesitation the choice which she was so heroically to sustain. She would not fight on the issue of slavery, but stood firm on the constitutional ground that every state in the Union enjoyed sovereign rights. On this principle Virginians denied the claim of the Federal Government to exercise coercion.

This decided the conduct of one of the noblest Americans who ever lived, and one of the greatest captains known to the annals of war. Robert E. Lee

Most of slaves, who might have been expected to prove an embarrassment to the South, on the contrary provided a solid help, tending the plantations in the absence of their masters, raising the crops which fed the armies, working on roads, building fortifications, thus releasing a large number of whites for service in the field.

The Army of Northern Virginia “carried the Confederacy on its bayonets” and made a struggle unsurpassed in history.

On the death of Virginian Thomas ‘Stonewall’ Jackson: His loss was a mortal blow to Lee and the cause of the South.

On the charge of Pickett’s Virginians at Gettysburg: General L.A. Armistead with a few hundred men actually entered the Union centre, and the spot where he died with his hand on captured cannon is today revered by the manhood of the United States.

Lincoln had entered Richmond with Grant, and on his return to Washington learned of Lee’s surrender. Conqueror and master, he towered above all others, and four years of assured power seemed to lie before him. By his consistency under many varied strains and amid problems to which his training gave him no key he had saved the Union with steel and flame. His thoughts were bent on healing his country’s wounds. For this he possessed all the qualities of spirit and wisdom, and wielded besides incomparable authority. To those who spoke of hanging Jefferson Davis he replied, “Judge not that ye be not judged.” On April 11 he proclaimed the need of a broad and generous temper and urged the conciliation of the vanquished.


ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)




Comments


Comments

3 responses to “Confederate History Month Proclamation”

  1. Agree with you completely on Churchill.

    While I’m with you on Lee as a good and great man, let’s not varnish over the truth about the slaves: the slaves may have helped keep things running, but they were still slaves and the South still kept men as property. Were there many other issues in the Civil War? Absolutely. Would slavery have eventually collapsed under its own weight? Very likely, yes. Did the South hold human beings in bondage for the purpose of extracting labor from them? Yes.

    The South may have been more noble and genteel than the North, but their gentility and leisure was built on wealth made from fields fertilized (to paraphrase Faulkner in Absalom, Absalom) with human blood.

  2. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    Only a compleat (is that olde English speelling?) moe-rahn (two words in Ft Benning, GA) would argue for slavery in any frame of reference.

    On my Mother’s side, my direct ancestor, Daniel Webster Holland, thought it was a sin against God. Yet, he fought until the surrender in Greensboro,and one brother was killed at Seven Pines, one brother was wounded outside Richmond, and the last brother fought for a year when he was 15.

    I agree that slavery was a sin against God. Segregation is sinful. Racism is too.

    The British Empire eliminated slavery in 1833. A mere 30 years before our ‘unpleasantness’. Russia ended serfdom in 1860. The Muslims still practice slavery in Africa.

    Love Faulkner’s ‘Unvanquished’ as well as Absalom, Absalom – read so many years ago.

    The South kept men as property longer than the North. Every state had slaves in 1776. 5 of the victorious Northern states changed their laws/constitutions after April 1865 to exclude Black men from voting. Everything has to been seen in context. Still, great quotes from Winnie.

  3. NOVA Scout Avatar
    NOVA Scout

    The story is so important to a balanced appreciation of what American became as a nation and an idea, that I would hope Kaine and successors would not miss an opportunity to broaden the observance to “Civil War History Month.” Given what Virginia endured during the War, “Confederate” is too narrow a term. Some of Virginia was occupied by United States Forces throughout the ward, much of it was Union controlled at one time or another during the war. Some communities, including my own, voted not to secede in the referendum. Many Virginians have ancestors who fought for the North and many have come to the Commonwealth long after the War ended. But Virginia occupies a unique position among the states as the primary battleground in the madness that, in retrospect, seemed destined to happen that there might be a new concept of our national purpose and identity. Virginia should always be ready to offer itself as a focal point of remembrance for both sides in the conflict.

Leave a Reply


ADVERTISEMENT