Three Strikes and You’re Out, Mr. Ryan

Jim Ryan

by James A. Bacon

If University of Virginia President Jim Ryan wants to recruit more African-American students, faculty and staff to the university, here’s some advice: stop reinforcing racial paranoia. Stop lending legitimacy to the idea that Blacks at the University of Virginia are under threat.

So far this semester, there have been three racial scares at UVa. First someone threw a rock through the window of the Office of African-American Affairs. Then someone laid a flag bearing an owl symbol next to the Enslaved Laborers memorial and donated an anonymous check to an African-American student. Then someone hung a noose around the neck of a statue of the blind Greek poet Homer.

The three incidents generated alarm about a “larger pattern of racially motived crimes” before the full facts came in. Upon investigation, the first two were found to have no racial motivation and significant doubt has been cast on racial hatred as a motive for the third.

UVa officials deserve some credit for quickly releasing exonerating information as it became available. But rather than dampen unfounded speculation in his early remarks, Ryan legitimized it.

The rock-throwing episode was denounced as racist… until the rock thrower was identified as someone known to the Office of African-American Affairs, and racism could be ruled out. The owl-flag incident was regarded with suspicion as an act of racial disrespect… until the individual involved was identified as a philanthropist who was trying in an odd way to honor the enslaved laborers. The Homer-noose incident caused the biggest stir. Police released a video of an unidentified White suspect. His race, combined with his use of a noose, fueled speculation that his action was racist… until evidence surfaced that he had a very different motive.

The noose was discovered on Sept. 7. The UVa Police Department — which had hired its first manager of diversity, equity and inclusion in 2021 and had implemented a new regime of DEI training — promptly declared the incident a racial hate crime, even though the perpetrator left no graffiti, letter or other communication to illuminate his intent.

Ryan adopted the police department’s assessment without reservation. He, too, declared the incident a hate crime. “A noose is a recognizable and well-known symbol of violence, most closely associated with the racially motivated lynchings of African Americans,” he said in a prepared statement. “The combination of those factors led University public safety officials to determine that this incident met the criteria of a hate crime and that a community alert was required.” Ryan went on to assure members of the UVa community that he was working to keep them safe.

As I blogged at the time, the hate-crime theory begged the question of why someone wishing to intimidate Black people would place the noose around the neck of a dead White poet. The symbolism would have been much stronger if, say, the noose had been slung over a branch near the Enslaved Laborers memorial. Hate-crime hoaxes are commonplace in American universities today, I suggested, and the perpetrator could just as well have been indicting Western Civilization’s canon of works by “dead white men.” (I should have added that there could have been another explanation entirely; as it turns out, there was.)

Regardless, the administration viewed the situation as serious enough to warrant calling in the Federal Bureau of Investigation to assist with the probe. The conviction that the Homer noose was an act of racial intimidation quickly spread. Many African-American students felt besieged. As one Black student told The Cavalier Daily, UVa’s student newspaper: “For Black men and Black women here on this campus and in this country, our life is always threatened. There’s always a noose around our neck. This is nothing new for us. I was hurting, especially when it first happened.”

For all the angst and fear the event inspired, the hate-crime proposition has been all but debunked. On Oct.22, the University Police reported that a “pile of items” had been found next to the Homer statue: two masks, a “civil peace flag,” a Christian cross, and a sealed envelope containing a letter.

The letter indicated that that the statue glorifies pedophilia, and that we “are all so blinded by hatred and racial division” that we “refuse to see the truth that is hidden in plain sight.”

The note goes on to say that, “If you live in reality you will see an old man with a nude adolescent boy in between his legs.”

The message did not contain language of racial, religious, or ethnic animus,

Three days later, Albemarle County resident Shane Dennis was arrested and charged with “intent to intimidate” by displaying the noose, which is illegal in Virginia. Notably, he was not charged with a hate crime, suggesting that law enforcement authorities regarded the pedophilia-protest motive as plausible.

So, what was Ryan’s reaction to the latest twist in the saga? He issued this bland  statement:

We remain committed to ensuring the University of Virginia is a place where all can feel safe in the spaces where they live, learn and work. Although we are relieved that this suspect was apprehended, we will never stop working to ensure that this community is as safe and welcoming as it can be.

Let that sink in. “We can all feel safe,” he said. Safe from what? Safe from threats to pedophiles? Safe from the knowledge that the incident was not racially motivated?

Presumably the latter. This was Ryan’s way of back-pedaling without apologizing for earlier describing the incident as a hate crime and contributing unnecessarily to the anxiety of Blacks throughout the university.

Two days ago I asked UVa spokesman Brian Coy if Ryan felt any regrets about his rush to judgment. I have received no answer.

Hate crimes are a real thing, but they are rare. According to the Virginia State Police Crime in Virginia 2021 report, 35 Blacks were victims of hate crimes in Virginia last year. More than 1.6 million Blacks live in Virginia. That works out to one hate crime per 46,000 Blacks. Not exactly an epidemic. Not exactly a reason for Blacks to fear for their safety. The heightened sense of paranoia at UVa stems not from real-world racial threats but from the obsession with racial identity and the rhetoric of victimhood that pervades the university. Unfortunately, Ryan either shares that paranoia or is too timid to stand up to it.

Ryan wants to increase the demographic diversity of UVa. Apparently, he thinks he can do that by virtue signaling his determination to combat racial bias. Instead, what he has succeeded in conveying is that there is racial bias to be combatted, and that Blacks at UVa have reason to fear for their physical safety. Why would any racial minority want to study or work at such a place?

Share this article


(comments below)


(comments below)


12 responses to “Three Strikes and You’re Out, Mr. Ryan”

  1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    “Notably, he was not charged with a hate crime, suggesting that law enforcement authorities regarded the pedophilia-protest motive as plausible.”

    Casting enough doubt that he would not be convicted for the more serious hate crime charge…. conveniently…

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Perhaps we should adopt the Napoleonic Code of an inquisitorial system.

      We could then charge all white people with hate crimes with a presumption of guilt and leave it to them to prove their innocence.

      That is the modern far left approach, excluding, of course, themselves.

      Not sure how they escape the guillotine except, again of course, that they control the courts of their own opinions.

      1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        Just call em as they are, Sport. He has already skirted the law – the court will be kinder than is deserved.

  2. Sources report that Mr. Ryan wants to give an honorary degree to Jussie Smollett

  3. James McCarthy Avatar
    James McCarthy

    I’m prepared to join a campaign to change UVA’s name to Thomas Jefferson University to bring to closure the endless caterwauling. Your vote?

    1. walter smith Avatar
      walter smith

      I think you just unintentionally had a good idea…

    2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Certainly you joining (starting?) such a campaign would lend it instant legitimacy.

    3. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      I vote we honor both our great founders and name it George Jefferson University. There are other obvious benefits.

      1. walter smith Avatar
        walter smith

        Except UVA is on the West Side…
        That would not be moving on up…

  4. Rob Austin Avatar
    Rob Austin

    Ryan and his Thought Police minions will stop at nothing until the UC-Berkeley- Charlottesville campus is fully realized.

  5. Merchantseamen Avatar

    I dare to say that the “noose” used by Socialists,Nazis, Maoists, Marxist and Communist and let’s not forget the many Democrats. The Marxist alone “lynched” more in 6 years than murdered in this country in 60 years. Could be said for those other ideologies also.

Leave a Reply