No Good Deed Goes Unpunished

Barnie Day


 

 

The Advance

 

Republicans have a lot to think about when they lick their wounds at the Homestead this weekend. A little friendly advice: Think fiscal responsibility.


Editor's note: This column was written before the "Advance" on Dec. 3.

 

Virginia Republicans gather this weekend for their annual “advance” at the Homestead in Hot Springs. They will celebrate two close but still apparent statewide wins, lick the loss of the governorship wounds and try to find their center again, the core belief that defines them as Republicans. They needn’t look far.

 

Patrick McSweeney may be the clearest thinking Republican in Virginia. That the former Virginia GOP chairman is clearly thinking “Republican” long-term, there can be little doubt. His political brethren should heed him. Virginia Democrats should pay close attention, too.

 

Writing last week (See "A Republican Party Agenda," Nov. 28, 2005), McSweeney argued that Virginia Republicans will find the commonality that binds them to a majority—and it is still a clear majority, the election notwithstanding—of Virginians again when they articulate—not just a “cut, cut, cut” in taxes message—but the linkage between that and spending.

 

Has Virginia “gone Democratic” overnight? No, no, no—not by a mile. Anyone who thinks it has is delusional. Why the Kaine win then? He, and Mark Warner before him, especially Warner, did a much better job on this linkage issue in the minds of Virginia voters.

 

The electorate is not some mass of idiocy. Virginia voters can—and do—connect the dots. And they know disconnect when they see it—and they saw disconnect wholesale in Jerry Kilgore’s “no new taxes but spend, spend, spend” campaign and punished him for it.

 

Of course, there is a flip-side lesson to this for Virginia Democrats. Is Tim Kaine’s win a signal that it is acceptable now to let down the spending floodgates in Virginia? No. That is the last thing it is.

 

Virginia Republicans may be “advancing” at the Homestead this weekend like the Union Army “advanced” back to Washington after First Manassas. Some of their early sessions are likely to resemble the organizational meetings of Third World parliaments—and I plead guilty to taking some pleasure at the thoughts of that—but my guess is that their elders, those who remember how they gained political dominance in Virginia, will prevail in correcting the course for them.

 

Said McSweeney last week: “Unless the GOP makes fiscal discipline the centerpiece of its agenda again, it will surely lose the support of limited-government conservatives who have traditionally constituted the largest segment of the party's base. Simply declaring that the party supports fiscal conservatism won't be enough. To restore voter confidence, Republican elected officials must exhibit the courage to hold the line on spending, lop off some low priority programs and consider innovative ways to achieve the same program objectives at lower cost to the taxpayers.”

 

Kate Griffinm the current Republican chairman in Virginia, may find a whip and a chair handy going into the weekend, but the front end of these affairs is not what matters. What matters is the cohesion coming out.

 

The grass-roots Republican majority is still here in Virginia. It didn’t go anywhere. Make no mistake about that. Virginia is still a Republican state. The only question is how long it will take the Republican Party of Virginia to realize that. A good predictor on that one will be how long it takes the RPV to come to its collective senses.

 

Why should Virginia Democrats pay attention to any of this?

 

Virginia voters—many traditionally Republican—have again loaned the governorship to Virginia Democrats for lack of a better option, and then only so long as Virginia Democrats behave responsibly with it—only so long as they continue to demonstrate and acknowledge understanding of, to “message,” the cost-benefit linkage of government.

 

Surely the governor-elect and Democratic leaders in the Virginia House and Senate understand this. It is imperative that they do.  

 

November 28, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Contact

 Information

 

Barnie Day

604 Braswell Drive
Meadows of Dan, VA
24120

 

E-mail: bkday@swva.net

 

Read his profile and back columns here.