The Jefferson Journal

Michael W. Thompson



 

Our Fearless Economic Forecast

 

The good news: Virginia's economy and tax revenues will grow far faster than the national average. The bad news: So will state spending.


 

For the fifth straight year, Chmura Economics and Analytics, Virginia’s premier economic analysis firm, has completed its annual Economic Forecast for the Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy. (This annual report is available on our website.)

 

The outlook for our economy remains bright, although the rate of growth is expected to slow somewhat nationally. As in the past, Virginia’s economy is expected to exceed the growth rate of the national economy. And that means our state government should continue to see healthy surpluses this year and next--a point I shall return to momentarily.

 

Virginia's political and business leaders look forward to Christine Chmura's annual divination of the economic entrails to help predict how business and government funding will fare in the year ahead. She expects the growth rate to slow from 2004's heady 4.4 percent growth rate to a more modest 3.4 percent in 2005. 

 

While spending increases are expected in software, equipment and buildings, she projects that higher interest rates and oil prices will dampen consumer spending. The Federal Reserve is expected to raise interest rates throughout 2005 and 2006, and oil prices are not expected to drop dramatically.

 

The volatility of the price of oil is the big question mark sitting on the horizon. If oil prices continue to hover where they are today, or increase, then our economic growth might slow even more. If the price decreases to what many think is its more normal $30-$35 a barrel, then our economy could outperform this forecast.

 

Chmura expects inflation to remain in check, with rates of 2.9 percent in 2005 and 2.2 percent in 2006.  Low and stable inflation should help our economy remain on track for reasonable and consistent growth.

 

More importantly, Virginia’s economy continues to show healthy growth. Employment in the Old Dominion increased 2.6 percent in 2004, compared to only 1.8 percent nationally. Meanwhile, the latest numbers show, Virginians' personal income increased 3.3 percent compared to 2.4 percent for the nation as a whole.

 

Northern Virginia added the most jobs in 2004 – more than 60,000 – making it the second fastest growing region in our state. Surprisingly, Blacksburg in Southwestern Virginia sported the fastest growing job increase, with a 9.7 percent gain last year.  Blacksburg is the home of Virginia Tech, a growing research university that clearly is helping that region.

 

The only region losing jobs was Danville. Every other major metropolitan area gained jobs last year.

 

This year’s Economic Forecast, entitled “Aging Demographic Shift Amid Economic Expansion,” warns that the aging population nationally and in Virginia brings serious challenges. Locally, Virginia faces acute job shortages in certain occupational categories that could choke growth in some economic sectors. Government and business need to address these shortages sooner rather than later.

 

The challenges of an aging society are, of course, national in scope. The economists at Chmura Economics and Analytics don't mince words: "Changing demographics and increased life expectancy puts the long-term solvency of the Social Security system in jeopardy.” Changes cannot be avoided, according to this Economic Forecast, if the system is to remain economically viable.

 

Now, how does this expanding economy impact on our state government? USA TODAY reported recently that Virginia’s government is experiencing the third highest increase in state income in the nation – over a 14 percent increase in revenue over the last fiscal year.  And there is fully one more year to go in the current two-year budget cycle. 

 

The General Assembly spent more than $1.4 billion in “surplus” earlier this year – money over and beyond what was expected to come into the state coffers after the tax increase. And there are strong indications that an additional surplus of at least that much will be facing the General Assembly when it convenes next year following the election of a new Governor and all 100 State Delegates.

 

An additional surplus of $1.4 billion is about $466 per family in Virginia. It would not be unreasonable for the next Governor and General Assembly to return to each Virginia family $250 or $300 from this additional surplus. The remaining surplus could be “set aside” for the Rainy Day Fund and for one time expenditures for infrastructure.

 

In this way Virginians who pay these taxes will get a “refund” for excess money flowing into the Treasury that was not planned, the Rainy Day Fund would be increased to help prepare for the next recession and whatever is left over would be used for one-time infrastructure expenditures and not to grow the on-going base of government.

 

The state budget is increasing beyond the rate of inflation and population growth. Thus the burden of government is growing on each of us. Despite economic growth that consistently outstrips the national average, the even higher rate of growth in state spending will force another “budget crisis” in four to five years--requiring tax increases or “painful” budget cuts. A tax refund next year would return the excess money to those who pay these taxes and keep government from growing too rapidly. Both are good for the economy.      

 

-- June 6, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

Michael Thompson is chairman and president of the Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy, a non-partisan foundation seeking better alternatives to current government programs and policies. These are his opinions and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Institute or its Board of Directors.  Mr. Thompson can be reached here.