Patrick McSweeney


 

Wake Up Call for Virginia GOP

Paula Miller's victory in last month's special Congressional election demonstrated Democratic Party unity and organizational strength. Republicans better get their act together.


 

The contrast was striking. On December 13, Republicans celebrated as Virginia’s electors cast their ballots for George Bush. The next day was a big downer for the GOP as a Democrat was elected to the Virginia House of Delegates in a special election in Norfolk to replace Republican Thelma Drake, who was recently elected to replace U.S. Representative Ed Schrock.

 

Each party raised the stakes in the December 14 special election. Gov. Mark R. Warner, a Democrat, campaigned for his party’s candidate, Paula Miller.  The GOP candidate, Michael Ball, was boosted by high profile support from U.S. Senator George Allen, Attorney General Jerry Kilgore and U.S. Representative Drake.

 

Turnout was light despite the participation of prominent statewide politicians and the substantial amount of campaign contributions that poured in to both campaigns. Miller appears to have outspent Ball during the brief race in this highly competitive district.

 

Although Drake prevailed over a strong Democratic opponent in last month’s congressional contest, the voters in her former legislative district supported John Kerry by almost 62 percent. The election between Miller and Ball appeared to be a toss-up.

 

Two things about the election must give Republicans great concern. First, the Democrats showed organizational strength, which is an important factor in a low-turnout election. Second, some moderate Republicans supported Miller over Ball in part because of Ball’s opposition to higher taxes.

 

Ball reopened wounds from the bitter tax battle earlier this year in the General Assembly. He announced he would have voted against increasing state taxes, as Drake had done. This activated supporters of the $1.4 billion biennial state tax increase, who contributed heavily to Miller’s campaign.

 

Because of Warner’s obvious political aspirations, he had much at stake in the special election. A victory for anti-tax forces in this Democrat-leaning district would have been a severe political blow to the governor.

 

This election has larger meaning than the pick-up of a single House seat for the Democrats because of its implication for elections next year. The Democrats’ 2005 playbook will obviously include the tactic of labeling GOP anti-tax candidates as reckless ideologues bent on cutting back popular government programs and unwilling to take on pressing problems. Republicans can anticipate an effort in 2005 to ally pro-tax Republican and independent voters with a newly energized Democratic base.

 

If the GOP remains a house divided, it will lose control of one or both chambers of the General Assembly during this decade. Yet, there is no sign that Republican leaders are prepared to take the steps required to reverse course.

 

It will take more than simply papering over the deep division within the GOP. The party and its candidates must construct a common vision. That vision must appeal to the traditional Republican base in order to succeed. The electoral math won’t work otherwise.

 

The current GOP leadership in the State Senate and the 17 House Republicans who supported the huge tax increase earlier this year refuse to acknowledge this political reality. If both parties embrace a pro-tax agenda, voters will ultimately gravitate to the party that is more comfortable pursuing that agenda – the Democratic Party.

 

The GOP and its candidates must endorse a spending reform agenda to recapture forward momentum and cohesion. Warner himself has handed the GOP all it needs — his promise to cut $1 billion a year. When will Republicans wake up?

 

-- January 4 2005

 

 

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Contact Information

 

McSweeney & Crump

11 South Twelfth Street
Richmond, VA 23219
(804) 783-6802

pmcsweeney@

   mcbump.com