Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Pro-Tax?  Take a Number

 

No mas. Virginia Pundit Watch is throwing in the towel on trying to keep up with all the pro-tax op-eds and commentary. Each day brings a new voice crying out for more revenue or warning of an “imminent threat” to all that Virginia represents. Anti-tax forces have been overwhelmed in every print venue.

 

Ground zero for pro-tax advocates has been the editorial pages of the Richmond Times-Dispatch.  While its unsigned editorials bravely suggested trimming state spending here and there, its commentary pages were crowded with high-minded advocacy of increasing taxes along Gov. Warner-Sen. Chichester lines. The list of worthies who counseled digging deeper into certain pockets included:  

  • Buford Scott, Chairman of Scott & Stringfellow, Inc. Scott wrote, “With the Governor’s plan we have the chance to preserve and strengthen Virginia’s competitive position among the states.”

  • Charles H. Foster, Jr., Chairman and CEO of  LandAmerica Financial Group, Inc. “Revenue enhancement is unavoidable if we desire to truly address the Commonwealth’s critical needs.”

  • Walter Craigie, former Secretary of Finance.  Craigie didn’t support any particular tax plan, but his warnings against using “easy fixes” to solve budget problems didn’t leave much doubt about where he stood.

Additionally, education advocates like Virginia Community College Chancellor Glenn DuBois, Old Dominion University Provost Thomas Isenhour, and youth political action advocate Jesse Ferguson either praised the glories of funding education or warned darkly of  danger if funding does not rise.

 

Supporting the pro-tax op-ed parade was Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot. She found fault with the Republican tax analysis of former Reagan Administration official Jim Miller, but pro-tax studies by the Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy and an organization call Global Insight were “prudent.”  Sniping at the anti-taxers was her colleague, Patrick Lackey. He invoked Benjamin Franklin, the Founding Father who would “dismiss a man who never changed his mind.” Those anti-taxers, of course, have their ways “set in concrete.”

 

Apparently, Franklin doesn't mind the pro-taxers that never change their mind about the state needing more revenue.

 

Demo Memos

 

Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress wrote a puff piece on a rising Democratic star, Del. R. Creigh Deeds, D-Bath, an “all-but-announced candidate for attorney general in the 2005 elections.” Despite his rural roots, Deeds has statewide “electability,” according to former Charlottesville Mayor Tom Vandever. Gibson lists Roanoke Del. John Edwards as Deeds’ major competition, ignoring another rising star and potential candidate: Del. Brian Moran of Alexandria.

 

In the Washington Post, Gordon Morse, ruminated on the potential revival of the Virginia Democratic Party after witnessing their Jefferson-Jackson Day dinner.  He sees “pragmatism and practicality” in the party, along with Democrats' role as “tribunes of the commonwealth’s fiscal honor” as possible keys to ta return to power.  Morse quotes Del. Moran on the party’s future: “‘We have to have a moderate, mainstream agenda. Falling on our sword for liberal causes isn't going to give us the apparatus of government.’"

 

Outrage to Follow

 

Among the major pundits, only Bacon’s Rebellion contributor Barnie Day has written at length about the passage of House Bill 1357, a bill exempting the legislature from the Freedom of Information Act.  Washington Post columnist Marc Fisher gave the bill his “Nay of the Week” in an on-line chat, but not a single comment about the bill was submitted by readers.  Expect a flurry of pundits to sign on to the essence of Day’s critique.

 

Diversions

 

If the tax obsession of this year’s General Assembly is wearing thin, turn to Hugh Lessig and Terry Scanlon of the Daily Press. They’ve got news on midwives, inadvertent candor, cutting jokes, and, best of all, hazing hijinks directed against freshman legislators.

 

How’d I Do?

 

In my February 2nd column, I made predictions about the Virginia Democratic Presidential Primary held on February 10th. On the plus side, I predicted a big win for Sen. John Kerry, mediocre voter turnout, and the end of General Wesley Clark’s campaign. On the minus side, I over-estimated the residual support for Gov. Howard Dean, picking him to finish ahead of Sen. John Edwards for second.  Edwards was second, Clark third and Dean fourth. I failed to pick Rep. Dennis Kucinich to finish ahead of Sen. Joe Lieberman. Professor Larry Sabato has nothing to fear.

 

-- February 16, 2004

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.