Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Attack of the Anti-Taxers

 

Pro-tax forces dominated the run-up to the 2004 General Assembly session with daily commentaries dotting the op-ed pages. The anti-taxers have struck back with a deluge of argument and invective.

 

Two former governors led the offensive in the

Richmond Times-Dispatch. “The high tax lobby will be disappointed,” said Gov. Douglas Wilder, but he cited his fiscal management during the early 90’s as an antidote to raising taxes. He gently rebuked Gov. Mark Warner with this comment: “How can anyone justify raising taxes and telling people you're lowering their taxes?” Gov. Jim Gilmore was anything but gentle on his successor, citing “Warner’s stage-managed tax-increase show -- with all of its high-tax hoopla and orchestrated rave reviews.”

 

Senator Ken Cuccinelli, R-Centreville, in the Roanoke Times, reminded Gov. Warner that he promised not to raise taxes and called it a campaign fib that “snowballed into a ‘Big Lie.’”  He called for “spending reform,” but cited no budget lines that he would cut.  Warner’s promise and spending reform was also the take-off point for Melanie Scarborough in the Washington Post, but she dared suggest areas to be considered:

 

The localities' perennial demand for more money raises an obvious question: If their social service programs are effective, why doesn't the need for funding ever decrease? Doesn't anyone ever get off drugs? Find a job? Recover from depression? Eschew juvenile delinquency?

 

Even if new clients come in as rapidly as old ones are rehabilitated, shouldn't the needs remain static -- not grow?

 

There were balanced calls in the new taxes versus spending reform. Times-Dispatch editorial page editor Ross MacKenzie offered this guidance:

 

The Assembly should keep in mind this mantra: Cut spending where it can, abolish taxes on death and food, and raise cigarette, gasoline, and general sales taxes where consequently it must.

 

Also in the Times-Dispatch, A. Fletcher Magnum, a former State Council of Higher Education official, analyzed long-term demographic trends, warning they might, in the future, force Virginia to choose between equally unacceptable options, “cripplingly high taxes or draconian cuts in government services.”

 

Pro-tax commentaries did not disappear. Jeff Schapiro of the Times-Dispatch blasted former governor and current US Senator George Allen for his anti-tax stance. While admitting that Allen delivered “low-key” remarks to General Assembly Republicans about fiscal responsibility last week, he used his column to recite a litany of complaints about Allen’s financial stewardship as governor and his votes as senator. Schapiro obviously got something off his chest and should be feeling better now.

 

In Fighting TRIM

 

Del. Allen Louderback, R-Luray, has a tax reform plan he calls “TRIM—Tax Reform and Income Modification.”  He patiently and persuasively explained his plan in the Times-Dispatch, including his controversial proposal to impose sales tax on services. Louderback contrasted his broad reform with Gov. Warner’s plan, asking, “Where is [his] restructuring of the code to make it fairer and simpler?”

 

Strange Bedfellows

 

Maryland Republican Governor Robert L. Ehrlich, Jr. is hardly a favorite of Virginia Democrats, but Del. Albert C. Pollard, Jr., D-White Stone, enthusiastically embraced his “flush tax” idea as a means to save the Chesapeake Bay. Writing in the Washington Post, Pollard said he has introduced HB 1418, a lower-cost version of Erhrlich’s tax — a surcharge on sewage bills with the proceeds going to upgrade sewage treatment plants.

 

Another NIMBY Issue

 

How many neighborhoods would welcome a methadone clinic in its midst? Reginald Shareef of the Roanoke Times dissects an on-going controversy over a clinic that will soon open in Roanoke, and General Assembly bills that would ban methadone clinics within a half-mile of schools and licensed day care centers.

 

Snow School Today

 

After the season’s first major snowfall in heavily populated regions of Virginia, the annual controversy over school closings for inclement weather appeared.  Washington Post columnist Marc Fisher, a “make ‘em go to school” advocate, praised this on-line questioner’s suggestion: “Why don't school districts just push the state to pass a law stating that schools are not liable for negligence based upon a decision to open or close schools in inclement weather?”

 

Fearless Prognostication

 

Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot, writing before Gov. Howard Dean’s total meltdown and Sen. John Kerry’s prodigious bounce after winning Iowa, described the excitement Virginia Democrats were feeling about their February 10th primary. Virginia Pundit Watch predicts mediocre turnout because of the Kerry surge and a big victory for the Massachusetts senator. Dean, Edwards, Clark, Sharpton and Lieberman will trail him, in that order.  Clark’s poor showing, after his huge ad buys on state media, will drive him out of the race.

-- February 2, 2004

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.