Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Same Old, Same Old

There’s one good thing about covering Virginia’s pundits: Take a long vacation and return to find that nothing much has changed. To be sure, the news occasionally offered a surprise, such as the ACC’s and sportswriters’ sudden turnaround on Virginia Tech. But after five weeks away from this beat, most topics remain distressingly familiar. R. H.

Melton of the Washington Post is still describing the kabuki dance of tax reform; Barney Day of the Roanoke Times is still trying to make hay out of the Virginia FREE report; and Gordon Morse of the Daily Press is still reflexively blasting Republicans.

 

In the latest step of the tax reform dance, Gov. Mark R. Warner met publicly with a legislative tax commission after an initial effort to hold the meeting behind closed doors met near universal condemnation. Daily Press political columnists Hugh Lessig and Terry Scanlon described the meeting as providing “clues about some of the minefields that lie ahead,” notably Warner’s role and the issue of revenue neutrality. Also in the Daily Press, Barney Day wrote, “To say the members of the newly formed (count 'em, the fourth in recent years) Tax Reform Commission got off to a clunky beginning last week would be charitable.” 

 

Both open and subtle Virginia-bashing appeared in the op-ed pages last week. Washington Post business columnist Steven Pearlstein, who has dismissed Virginia’s chances of landing a major league baseball, admitted that he has a “Virginia problem.” He’s pained by Northern Virginians’ “standoffishness,” their road network, their desire to have their own medical school, and their reluctance to put “Washington” in the names of their facilities. Patrick Lackey of the Virginian-Pilot unfavorably compared growth policies in Virginia generally and Loudoun County in particular to the managed growth policies in Montgomery County, Md. 

 

Speaking of major league baseball for Northern Virginia, Ralph Nader, in a Washington Post piece, urged local officials to play tough with major league baseball.

 

Tell baseball that they are ready to bid based on fan enthusiasm, transportation lines and other such factors, but not on the size of the public subsidy for a stadium. They should tell baseball that there will be no subsidy, especially in this time of extreme financial hardship for city and state governments.

 

Hot Issue

 

A national issue boiled over to the commentary pages of Virginia newspapers. The Fairness in Asbestos Injury Resolution Act, or FAIR, co-sponsored by U.S. Sen. George Allen, R-VA, was supported in op-eds by Clifford Williford that appeared in the Daily Press and Roanoke Times.  Williford, past commander of the Virginia Veterans of Foreign Wars, noted the large number of state residents who have been impacted by asbestos-related conditions and their long waits for compensation in the courts. On the other side, asbestos litigation attorney Robert R. Hatten charged in the Daily Press that the trust fund established by FAIR would “destroy the right to a jury trial” and “render victims impotent.”

 

The Old Cabal

 

State Sen. Ken Cuccinelli (R-Fairfax), clearly illustrated the divide between traditional business Republicans and the new, more populist Republicans, with this line in a Fairfax Journal (subscription required) op-ed:

 

The Northern Virginia Business Roundtable [is] a small, secretive cabal of politically active business people who have a history of advocating massive tax increases - often in their own self interest but decidedly not in the interests of the much larger business community.

 

El-Amin and the Yahoos

 

Richmond City Councilman Sa’ad El-Amin has resigned and is off to a prison term on income tax charges. Richmond Times-Dispatch columnist A. Barton Hinkle was unsparing in his criticism of El-Amin’s transgressions, but with a twist: he criticized the “Yahoos of America , Virginia Chapter,” for insinuating that the councilman, who is black, is representative of the city’s majority black leadership. Hinkle noted that the legal travails of white officials are not deemed representative of their communities.

 

A Worthy Reform

 

In my June 9th column, I expressed doubt that an electronic state employee grievance system, ballyhooed by the Washington Post’s R. H. Melton, was much of a breakthrough. Amazingly, the Department of Employment Dispute Resolution official responsible for the initiative, Paul Prissel, actually read my commentary and asked if he could demonstrate the system for me. I took him up on his offer and he convinced me that it was a breakthrough not for employees, but for the painstaking bureaucratic requirements of tracking and documenting each grievance. Mr. Prissel, genuinely committed to improving the operation of his agency, was among the nine state employees honored by Governor Warner for cost-saving ideas.


Even Bargains Have Critics

 

Virginia’s local jails are beginning to charge $1 a day for the “room and board” they offer, but Dave Addis of the Virginian-Pilot observed that some are criticizing the pricing:

 

In a news story yesterday, inmates were understandably upset. One complained that she wasn't getting enough for her dollar a day because the Norfolk City Jail has fruit flies.

 

Fruit flies? Heck, I once paid $179 a night for a room on Capitol Hill in Washington that had cockroaches the size of hamsters. They ran up a huge tab in pay-per-view movies, raided the mini-bar, and I think they stole a pair of my shoes.

 

There have been times, while traveling, when I would happily have paid one dollar a night to stay in the local jail rather than $200 a night to stay at the local inn. In some towns they seem to be operated by the same franchise.

 

As Gov. Warner embarks on a push to boost Virginia tourism, local officials should beware of visitors to the state seeking out the $1 package deal.

 

-- July 14, 2003

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.