Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Warner Wins Battle of the Op-Eds

 

It wasn’t “Point-Counterpoint,” or even “Clinton/Dole, Dole/Clinton,” but Gov. Mark R. Warner and Senator Thomas Norment, R-Williamsburg went toe-to-toe on the estate tax in the Richmond Times-Dispatch op-ed pages one day before the General Assembly veto session. When the dust had cleared, Warner’s op-ed carried

the day. The Senate failed to override his veto of the bill abolishing the estate tax.

 

No one, of course, attributed Warner’s win to the power of his punditry. Barney Day, Daily Press and Roanoke Times columnist, credited it to actions “that warmed the hearts of Democratic partisans everywhere.” According to Day, Warner was “right” on the issue and went after a victory:

 

He wined and dined the votes he needed. He begged and cajoled. He lit the phones up back home, particularly in a few districts where he needed to flip votes. He staked out his position emphatically. He made a case. He worked the process. And he won - really against the odds.

 

With his usual flair for couching his opinions, Day declared estate tax repeal “ truly idiotic.”

 

Jeff Schapiro of the Richmond Times-Dispatch didn’t even pause to marvel at the estate tax veto before identifying a new crusade for Gov. Warner. Schapiro, calling the Republicans “smug,” assailed their barring of in-state tuition breaks for illegal aliens. Noting that Warner’s amendments to the measure failed, he made this suggestion:

 

Here's an idea that would make his one-time mentor, former Gov. L. Douglas Wilder, proud: Veto the bill and issue an executive order that would put into effect his standards for protecting the higher education system and those resident illegal immigrants who honorably aspire to partake of it.

 

Schapiro as much as admitted he was indulging in wishful thinking:

 

Waiting for Gov. Mark R. Warner to get tough with the General Assembly is like waiting for Godot: Anticipation yields to the realization that it's probably not going to happen.

 

Suck-Up of the Week

 

Preston Bryant, a Republican Delegate and Roanoke Times columnist, wrote that Attorney General Jerry Kilgore “is a man for our state's times. He knows his job, and he does it.” Bryant praised Kilgore for his victory over Gov. Warner on redistricting, his stance on the Republican eavesdropping case, and for gaining Virginia as the venue for the first sniper trials. 

 

Barney Day couldn’t resist taking a shot at his colleague, alluding to the “pathological adulation laid on by some of his [Kilgore’s] columnists.”  

 

The Business of Business Isn’t Higher Ed

 

Washington Post columnist Steven Pearlstein did a piece on the lack of business support for higher education in Maryland and Virginia:

 

Unlike in Boston or San Francisco or even Austin, key players in the Washington corporate community have not stepped forward and adopted higher education as their cause, lavishing campuses with money and using their political muscle to protect them as they would their own operations. Consider David Packard and Stanford or Michael Dell and the University of Texas.

 

Others offered different explanations. Pearlstein quoted George Mason University President Alan Merton saying, "Around here, there is no identifiable business community. That's the problem." The man who knows that there is a business community blamed voters:

 

At the Virginia Chamber of Commerce, President Hugh Keogh explained that while the business community is concerned about the "long-term deterioration" in the state's higher-education system, it is loath to take on what would be a quixotic campaign to reverse it in the face of an electorate determined to cut taxes no matter the consequences.

 

On a positive note, at least for those who compare Virginia to Mississippi, Pearlstein noted a study that put Maryland at No. 37 and Virginia at No. 28 in terms of state support of public higher education as a fraction of personal income.

 

College Corner, Continued

 

Virginia’s Mary Washington College and Chris topher Newport University were named to the list of “100 Most Underrated Colleges” by the Washington Post’s Jay Mathews.

 

Pundits Draft Bruce Smith in First and Second Round

 

Former Virginia Tech and NFL football star Bruce Smith got a lot of advice from the Roanoke Times.  Smith, named to the Virginia Tech Board of Visitors by Governor Warner, was advised by Times editorial writer Shanna Flowers to begin attending meetings and do battle with a Board that eschewed affirmative action by adopting a “race-neutral” policy. Radford Professor and Times columnist Reginald Shareef had contrary advice, mischievously suggesting that Smith also oppose legacy preferences and NCAA sports preferences.

 

Neither pundit drafting Smith to support their educational philosophy noted the irony that Smith never earned a degree from Tech.

 

Gratuitous Sexual Reference of the Week

 

Reader Valerie L’Herrou took exception to sexual references concerning the French in last week’s Paul Goldman column. This week, A. Barton Hinkle’s hilarious Times-Dispatch send-off of the recently released “Guide to Virginia Protocol and Traditions” offers a Virginia sexual reference:

 

Recently I was invited by my cousin Cleetis to go hunting around Tazewell for the weekend. What is the order of precedence?

 

Order of precedence before the hunt: Cousin Cleetis, his immediate kinfolk, you, your immediate kinfolk, Cleetis' good buddies, your good buddies. After the hunt: The guy who bagged the most game, the guy who drank the most beer, the guy who skipped the hunting and bagged Charlene, everyone else.

 

-- April 7, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.