Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



What a Difference a Veto Makes

 

It seems like only yesterday that Virginia’s pundits were tossing barbs at Gov. Mark R. Warner amidst a drumbeat of criticism directed at the Republican-controlled General Assembly. Warner  should be putting up more of a fight and providing more leadership, they argued.

What a difference a veto makes.

 

Now that the governor has vetoed estate tax repeal, centerpiece of the Republican agenda, he has been rehabilitated by no less a personage than R. H. Melton of the Washington Post. Melton reported that Democrats now see a “more self-assured chief executive and party leader.” 

 

The vote during the one-day veto session will be an important test of Warner's leadership, but on a purely partisan level -- and also for bigger budgetary reasons -- he has already won. Warner has drawn a bright line between his Democratic administration's fiscal restraint and a Republican majority determined to deliver a major tax cut smack in the middle of Virginia's worst budget crisis.

 

Jeff Schapiro of the Richmond Times-Dispatch doesn’t want Warner to take any chances. He urged the governor to make the case that his veto is the patriotic thing to do during wartime.

 

Poor Rhoda Elliott, president of Bill’s Barbecue and a first-hand observer of the estate tax in action, was probably swimming against the tide with her op-ed in the Times-Dispatch supporting repeal.

 

Nanny of the Highway

 

After an outpouring of support for restoring funding to VDOT’s Safety Service Patrol, James Simpson of the Potomac News gave the other side:

 

The fact is, when government attempts to act like a nanny there are unintended adverse consequences. While the Virginia State government is trying address the demands of various special interest groups, tasks that are part of its core mission are neglected.

 

Having the state provide this type of service not only alleviates a motorists' responsibilities, but it discourages folks from becoming a member of AAA or patronizing a towing company or service station, thereby making it yet another government program that damages the private sector.

 

For good measure, Simpson also opposed funding for wildflowers on highway medians.

 

College Corner

 

The Virginia Tech Board of Visitors’ decision to establish a race and gender-blind admissions policy has spawned an enormous outcry. A. Barton Hinkle of the Richmond Times-Dispatch called a Roanoke Times editorial criticizing the new policy as “sophomoric.” Many arguments in favor of racial preferences rely on the fact that “legacy” preferences exist, but Hinkle cut the legs out from under that position by opposing legacy preferences, too.

 

Meanwhile, Virginia Tech Emeritus Professor of Chemistry John Mason dished some dirt on the Board in the Roanoke Times and a real sophomore at the university, Jana Renn, asked, “When did equality become such a bad thing?”

 

No SOLs in Our Name?

 

Marc Fisher of the Washington Post alerts us to a new phenomenon: parents boycotting standardized testing. In some New York State jurisdictions, up to 60 percent of parents kept their children at home during state tests in 2001.

 

Why such antagonism to tests? Most boycotters don't mind the concept of standardized tests -- they're part of how we measure performance in this society. What they object to is the effect testing is having on America's classrooms.

 

"Testing is reducing the quality and quantity of the curriculum," says Mickey VanDerwerker, president of Parents Across Virginia United to Reform SOLs. "It is driving spending into test prep materials and away from high-quality resources."

 

Virginia's SOLs will become a barrier to graduation next year. Thus far, resistance to the tests has been "quiet, with some parents keeping their children home on test days," VanDerwerker says. But "as students and schools move closer to state-mandated consequences, it is likely that resistance will become more direct and more focused."

 

If students do show up for their tests, they shouldn’t get to use calculators, according to substitute teacher Robert Terry in the Roanoke Times.

 

-- March 31, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.