Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Swindles, Lies, and Broken Promises

 

The Virginia General Assembly adjourned on Saturday—“mercifully” for a “sorry spectacle” according to Barnie Day in the Daily Press—so most pundits have not had time to write their definitive verdicts. When they do, it’s hard to imagine that the 2003 session will be rehabilitated by a surly Virginia commentariat that has almost universally panned it from the start.

 

The relentlessly partisan Day highlighted his choice for the most egregious action of the General Assembly: putting more tax burden on “average” Virginians by ending the estate tax. He dubbed it a “swindle.” Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot started looking past adjournment. “The sense of impending fiscal doom seems to have lessened,” she wrote, urging Governor Warner to propose an overhaul of Virginia’s tax code, an item the General Assembly punted, in advance of the November elections.

 

Their Mothers Would Be So Proud

 

R. H. Melton of the Washington Post came pretty close to calling members of the General Assembly liars and cheats, but instead used phrases like “casual lies,” “double-dealing,” “distortions,” and “partisan deceit.” According to Melton, “Every promise in Richmond also carries an asterisk, an escape clause that permits the promiser to renege if voters back home complain or pressure is applied.”

 

Them, Too

 

A. Barton Hinkle of the Richmond Times-Dispatch reminded us that not all perfidy is at the state level. He chronicled the misadventures of the Richmond City Council even before news broke that one council member had been indicted on a Federal tax evasion charge.

 

Whodunit?

 

You may not have known he was a suspect, but Richard Cullen of the McGuire Woods law firm was exonerated by Barnie Day of the Roanoke Times in the case of who killed the two-term governorship bill. Detective Day fingered the Republican Majority Leader in the House:

 

Pure and simple, the governor’s marquee issue fell victim to a partisan ambush. Who engineered it? My bet is Morgan Griffith. I’d say he made it a ‘loyalty’ vote to deny Warner a win. I could be wrong. But I doubt it.

 

Diff’rent Strokes

 

Last week, we noted Gordon Morse’s Washington Post column. On the same day, the venerable Daily Press editor published a different piece for his own paper.

 

In the WP version, Republicans were “blinkered, provincial, self-aggrandizing, ecclesiastic and dumb.” Democrats were “flaccid, uninspired, inert, confused and dumb.”

 

In the DP version, “The familiar, more moderate, more level-headed politics of Virginia's not-so-distant past are kaput.”

 

Some Things Never Change

 

Rob Hedelt of the Fredericksburg Free-Lance Star returned to the General Assembly after a 15 year break. He found more partisanship, less experienced legislators, but the same little pecan pies at Chicken’s, the snack bar in the Capitol.

 

Other Roanoke Voices

 

The Roanoke Times found a Virginia Tech professor who didn’t want to write an anti-war op-ed screed. Sam Riley, a communications professor, satirized the Lee Ware, R-Powhatan, bill allowing guns to be brought into bars (it failed). And, after several op-eds calling for construction of I-73, B. E. Goehring, a businessman, argued against the new highway, supporting the upgrading of US Route 220.

 

The Great Mentioner

 

Hugh Lessig and Terry Scanlon  of the Daily Press ((registration required) were poking around UVA Professor Larry Sabato’s Crystal Ball website and found Governor Mark Warner listed as a “dark horse” candidate for the Democratic Presidential or vice-presidential nomination. 

 

Complaint of the Week

 

Kerry Dougherty of the Virginian-Pilot took on windshield “dings”:

 

Not only do I have a ding in my windshield, I have two. A big one, the size of a quarter, in the center of the window. And a smaller one on the passenger side.

 

Hey, I live in Tidewater, the cracked windshield capital of the world. Everyone has dings.

 

Fixing your windows around here is fruitless. And expensive.

 

-- February 24, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.