Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Askew Fallout Continues

 

A national tragedy often “freezes” debate about other issues. The loss of the space shuttle Columbia, coming as it did on a Saturday morning, however, did not allow most op-ed pages to make extensive revisions to their Sunday pages. Still, Virginian-Pilot columnist Dave Addis was able to submit his somber reflections.

 

Top issue of the week in Virginia was easily the fallout from the General Assembly’s denial of reappointment to Newport News Judge Verbena Askew. Former Governor L. Douglas Wilder penned a stinging rebuke in the Richmond Times-Dispatch of just about everyone involved in the fiasco. He singled out Lt. Gov. Tim Kaine for admonishing Senator Louise Lucas, D-Portsmouth, saying, “Kaine was wrong for interrupting and interfering with her presentation.”

 

Barnie Day of the Roanoke Times called the treatment of Askew a figurative “lynching.”  Delegate Preston Bryant, R-Lynchburg, also in the Times, defended the Republicans for being “rightly insistent on accountability being brought to Virginia’s judiciary.” Del. Brian Moran, D-Alexandria, writing in the Washington Post, detailed the “extraordinary” treatment that three female judicial nominees had to endure. Roger Chesley of the Virginian-Pilot called for revamping the system of selecting judges.

 

Hugh Lessig and Terry Scanlon of the Daily Press detailed how the General Assembly is “cranky,” with “things getting testy.” One source of crankiness among Democrats was Governor Warner’s absence from partisan battles, according to the Washington Post’s R. H. Melton.

 

In other punditry, Jeff Schapiro of the Richmond Times-Dispatch profiled the lonely tax code modernization crusade of Senator Kevin Miller, R-Harrisonburg.  Elisabeth Muhlenfeld, president of Sweet Briar College, also in the Times-Dispatch, defended Tuition Assistance Grants, pointing out that students at private colleges in Virginia are not predominantly “rich kids.” Melanie Scarborough, in the Washington Post, railed against the proposal to make failure to wear a seat belt a primary offense.  In a bit of hyperbole, she equated it to a pro-choice position: “Keep your laws off my body.”

 

Pundit v. Pundit

 

Kerry Dougherty of the Virginian-Pilot applauded the General Assembly for not offering wrongfully convicted criminal Earl Washington, Jr. one million dollars. Margaret Edds, editorial writer and also a columnist for the Pilot, took Dougherty to task for her views, even as she expressed reluctance to engage in a “catfight.” Edds is writing a book on Washington’s case.

 

The Company He Keeps

 

The Post’s R. H. Melton reported on Governor Warner’s interesting social calendar:

 

In recent weeks, Warner has invited well-known Democrats -- a former governor, a legendary ex-legislator from Roanoke, two partisan newspaper columnists -- to the Executive Mansion for brainstorming lunches. Some said they were struck by his venting about how helpless he felt, given the party's emaciated condition down the block at the General Assembly.

 

Earley Returns

 

Former Attorney General Mark Earley wrote a heartfelt tribute to mentoring young people in the Richmond Times-Dispatch. One could not help but sense that the failed gubernatorial candidate, now president of Prison Fellowship Ministries, has found a calling that combines his faith and passions.

 

Odds ‘n Ends from the Roanoke Times

 

From the state newspaper that prints the most diverse viewpoints as op-eds:

 

According to Bob Egbert of the Sierra Club, some of the best environmental legislation in the General Assembly is being proposed by conservatives … Joe Santos, identifying himself as a Democrat, charged that he and his father received threatening post cards after his letter critical of syndicated talk radio in Roanoke was printed in the Times … A resident of Christiansburg, Jeffrey N. Fawcett, shrilly criticized Governor Warner for cutting funds to Virginia Tech’s Corps of Cadets and took a gratuitous swipe at VMI, too.

 

Yiddish Pundit

 

Governor Warner was handed a plate full of schmutz, according to A. Barton Hinkle of the Richmond Times-Dispatch, and at times has been both a schlimazel and a schlemiel. 

 

Carry Me Out of Tax Heavy Virginny

 

Virginian-Pilot columnist Dave Addis tackled one aspect of debate over the “death tax”:

 

Among the more amusing arguments for doing this -- and there are good arguments for killing the estate tax -- is that if Virginia doesn't repeal the tax at this very moment, its multimillionaires might flee and take up residence in locales that already have killed the tax.

 

Yes, in the minds of your lawmakers, failure to take immediate action on the death tax would lead to scenes reminiscent of the Joad family's migration from the Dust Bowl in "The Grapes of Wrath,'' with miles of highways leading out of Virginia clogged by multimillionaires on the flee.

 

Silk mattresses and Louis XIV armoires strapped to the fenders of chauffeured Lincoln Navigators. Granny perched precariously on the roof in a Chippendale rocker. Fox hounds and thoroughbreds trying desperately to keep stride while lashed to the rear bumper.

 

-- February 3, 2002

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.