Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Politicians Turn Pundits

 

Op-ed columns by members of the General Assembly were the highlight of the Virginia pundit week.

 

Days before being sworn in as Speaker of the House of Delegates, William Howell, R-Stafford, used a Richmond Times-Dispatch column to sketch his agenda in broad terms:

 

If the Governor believes tax increases are right for this Commonwealth, he should propose them - not leave the task of leadership to others.

 

For my part, I am opposed to increasing the tax burden on our citizens, especially during these tough economic times.

 

I'm convinced that we will be far better off in the years to come if we again reject tax hikes and instead focus on allocating our resources to the core responsibilities of state government - especially education, job opportunities, and the health, safety, and security of our citizens.

 

R. H. Melton of the Washington Post saw challenging times ahead for the Speaker:

 

Howell said he will be considering ways to privatize some state functions, restrain government spending and other long-term projects that he said will leave a "Republican impact" on Virginia for years.

 

Howell has also acknowledged that, at times, he will feel "frustrated" by Republicans' election-year preoccupation with abortion and other divisive issues that have never been a priority for him but are for many of his troops.

 

However, Howell's expansive view of Republicanism will collide one day with a strain of conservatism that is gaining ground in the state GOP and doesn't leave room for a lot of dissent.

 

Some of that conservative “strain” was apparent in a piece by Scott Lingamfelter, R-Woodbridge, that appeared in the Potomac News. He argued for his constitutional amendment legislation to allow school choice in Virginia. Former Richmond Times-Dispatch columnist turned think tanker Robert Holland also beat the drum for school choice and vouchers in a Roanoke Times column.

 

Sen. John Chichester, R-Fredericksburg, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, explained the budget mess in a Richmond Times-Dispatch op-ed.  Like Governor Warner, he asked for an “honest discussion” with taxpayers on core functions of state government. Unfortunately, he didn’t suggest the when, where, and how of such a discussion.

 

Delegate Linda “Toddy” Puller, D-Fairfax, praised Governor Warner’s stewardship of VDOT in the Washington Post. She urged passage of his transportation reform package.

 

Mailing It In

 

While Howell, Chichester, Lingamfelter, and Puller probably labored over their op-eds, Preston Bryant, R-Lynchburg, Roanoke Times columnist and General Assembly delegate, just dropped off a metaphor posing as a column before heading to Richmond .  He compared the General Assembly to a horse race, calling Governor Warner a “yearling.”

 

In the Shadows

 

Most columnists offer an e-mail address or their newspapers provide a forum that readers may utilize for comments. Not Gary Jacobsen and the Potomac News. Described only by “lives in Woodbridge ,” Jacobsen provides his regular commentary without any contact information.  Writing from the shadows might be tolerable for light fare, but Jacobsen’s biting opinions, such as describing one General Assembly delegate as a “carpetbagger” and another as “most annoying,” cry out for an opportunity to respond.

 

Half Disclosure

 

Gregory Werkheiser wrote a spirited defense of tenure for college professors in the Daily Press. He was responding to a bill sponsored by Del. David Albo, R-Springfield, that would deny tenure for faculty hired after June of this year.  Unfortunately, Werkheiser was only identified by his college degrees and service on the Washington Council of the College of William and Mary. There was no mention of his Democratic Party ties, including service as a speechwriter for President Clinton and Hillary Clinton.

 

College Corner

 

Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot revealed a quiet movement toward making Virginia’s premier colleges more independent. They would “trade declining reliance on the public purse for more autonomy in a host of areas, including adoption of tuition rates.” Meanwhile, Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress traced a decline in the University of Virginia’s influence. He included this revealing quote from newly-elected Senator Jay O’Brien, R-Fairfax: "I have always been jealous of the success that UVa and Tech have had compared to George Mason, which I represent."

 

Pundit Review

 

Reginald Shareef completed an exhaustive, two part review of his Roanoke Times columns for 2002. While this is a commendable exercise that more pundits should emulate, Shareef didn’t have many second thoughts.

 

The Real Story

 

Forget all the noble talk about the world’s oldest continuous democratic body in the western world.  Dave Addis of the Virginian-Pilot tells us what the legislature is really about:

 

General Assembly sessions of the recent past have endorsed the notion among the citizens of the commonwealth that state government exists for two primary purposes: to spend money, and to grant vanity license plates to every resident of Virginia who has a hobby.

 

Errata: Last week I misspelled the name of Fairfax County Supervisor Gerald Connolly.

 

-- January 13, 2002

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.