Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Professor, Pundits Busy over Holiday Break

 

While others partied and celebrated the holiday season, Virginia Pundit Watch maintained its vigilance, if only to stay sharp for the expected avalanche of commentary during the upcoming General Assembly session.

 

University of Virginia professor and pundit Larry Sabato is not looking forward to the 2003 session. “This is a downer of a General Assembly coming,” he told Barbara Berlin on the public television program Perspectives. Sabato sees little chance of any tax increases passing and declared flatly, “You can forget about privatization of ABC stores.”  He does not favor amending Virginia’s constitution to allow a two-term governor.

 

Standing on the opposite side on the one-term limit is Virginia Commonwealth University Professor and pundit Robert D. Holsworth. Holsworth, who served as the Executive Director of the Wilder Commission, defends two terms in a Washington Post op-ed. He also makes a compelling case for the Wilder Commission diagnosis of the state’s problem:

 

Virginia's government operates more as a set of independent fiefdoms than as an integrated organization with common purposes.

 

He challenges the General Assembly:

 

Legislators can begin tackling the tough job now -- in the 2003 session -- or they can wait until the next session, or the next, hoping that festering problems will resolve themselves and pretending that other states are not really passing them by.

 

Holsworth also tacked the relationship between state government and local governments. On that hot-button topic, Susie Dorsey of the Dailey Press joined him. Dorsey is "incredulous" that Governor Mar R. Warner wants to turn some DMV functions over to local government:

 

Here's a man who promised to streamline government. Instead he proposes passing a state function to local commissioners of revenue and treasurers. Instead of streamlining government, he is creating yet another justification for maintaining a cost of government that hasn't made much sense since huge portions of Virginia shifted from an agricultural economy to the current, more urban, lifestyle.

 

Relations between the state and localities are “strained and almost poisonous,” according to Holsworth, and he sees the distrust of Richmond in Northern Virginia as “potentially destructive.”

State Democrats, perhaps inspired by Governor Warner’s reform agenda, surprised by suddenly expressing an interest in changing the way Virginia redistricts after each census. Lieutenant Governor Tim Kaine led the way in a Roanoke Times piece by suggesting that a commission, not the General Assembly, draw legislative boundaries.

 

Virginia Goes National

 

Governor Warner appeared as a panelist with colleagues from Arizona, Coloradoand Utah in a PBS News Hour segment on state budget problems. He more than held his own. … Former Governor Linwood Holton, in a New York Times op-ed datelined “Weems, Va,” used the Trent Lott controversy to remind readers of his positive legacy on racial issues as an early party-building Republican. He decried the national GOP “Southern Strategy” as “ineffective as well as immoral.” ... Fairfax County Supervisor Gerald Connally talked about the effects of state budget cuts on localities in a brief appearance on ABC’s This Week. … Political strategist couple Mary Matalin and James Carville told a Meet the Press national audience that they shopped at the Apple Blossom Mall in Winchester. …The Wall Street Journal’s James Taranto used a Roanoke Times op-ed by Radford Professor Glen T. Martin for his “Stupidity Watch.”

 

Regular People

 

Long before Democratic Senator and presidential candidate John Edwards promised to champion “regular people,” the Roanoke Times opened its editorial pages to, well, “regular people.”

 

George Shropshire, described as a “laid off truck driver,” offered a call to arms:

 

I urge every working family to step forward and get involved, even to the point that we go forward as "citizen legislators" ourselves, both at the state level and the federal.

 

Run for office and tout the views that we all hold dear, and do what we must without re-election concerns hindering our visions for the future. I know that my wife and I both intend to do so, and we readily encourage others to do so as well.

 

Shropshire attributed his crusade to a “vision” he had earlier in the year amidst what he called the “economic fiasco brought on by former Gov. Jim Gilmore’s ‘no car tax pledge’ and any other supposed representatives pledging to hold the line on ‘new’ taxes.”

 

M. J. Donohue, a “retired telephone company supervisor,” complained about complaints over budget cuts. George Murphy, a “retired law enforcement officer,” criticized Governor Warner for running the state like a business:

 

It seems the current administration is not interested enough in how to raise the capital needed to supply the overall needs of the citizens of our state. It has all outward appearances that all they are interested in is the bottom line. 

 

Pundit or Reporter?

 

Because R. H. Melton of the Washington Post is both a reporter and a columnist, it is sometimes difficult to tell where one role ends and the other begins. He offered a solid front-page analysis of a forward-looking Governor Mark Warner:

 

Warner promised a full agenda for the coming year -- despite having no extra money and facing a General Assembly led by increasingly confrontational Republicans. The governor said he will make it a priority to change the state's tax structure, and he wants enhancements in Northern Virginia higher education and research programs. He plans to address new issues affecting the state's aging baby boomers as well.

 

Warner also declared himself eager to assume a more active role as a Democratic Party leader, both statewide and nationally.

 

Numerous observers of the Governor are quoted, including Chris topher Miller of the Piedmont Environmental Council, who claims Warner did not heed his warnings about the strength of anti-sprawl forces in the state.

 

Maryland Benchmarks

 

The Washington Post’s Shannon Henry previewed actions the state of Maryland plans to catch up to Virginia in attracting technology companies.  She quoted George Pappas, an appointee of incoming Governor Robert Ehrlich:

 

"If Virginia has done better, we want to find out why. We could do a lot better to make [Maryland] more competitive."

 

Was This in the Works Before Lott?

 

Preston Bryant, writing in the Roanoke Times, latched on to the new Republican image on racial issues by calling for a restoration of cuts made to the state's African-American Heritage program. The Virginia Foundation for the Humanities runs the program in conjunction with the Virginia Tourism Corporation. 

 

Pundit Punching Bag

 

Apparently, any issue can be turned into a dig at former Governor Jim Gilmore and car tax relief. Bob Gibson, writing about the UVA pep band-West Virginia flap in the Daily Progress, notes:

 

The Pep Band was led for a year or two by a young clarinet player from Henrico County named Jim Gilmore. As leader, he kept the band in its seats.

 

Gilmore, a minimalist Republican, did not try to set the tone for very dry Wahoo humor for decades to come.

 

Gibson offers ten possible solutions for taming the pep band, but his number one choice involves the former Governor:

 

Strike the band and invite Gilmore back to play The Good Old Song on untaxed car horns.

 

-- January 6, 2002

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.