The Club for Growth

Phillip Rodokanakis


 

 

Leadership Vacuum

Some commentators pin the GOP's setbacks in November's election on conservative activists. In actuality, ineffective leadership of the House Republican caucus is the root of the problem.


 

"I don't approve of political jokes... I've seen too many of them get elected." –Anonymous

 

Anyone who served in our military forces is familiar with the saying “Lead or get out of the way.” When it comes to Virginia politics, we have too many politicians who simply stand in the way.

 

Has anyone heard recently from the Speaker of the House of Delegates, William J. Howell, R-Stafford? Just about everyone agrees that the Speaker is a very nice gentleman. But in his role as the Speaker, Howell must act both as a gentleman and an officer. 

 

Perhaps Speaker Howell has been active around his home base—if so, no one outside his District knows anything about it. Few would argue, however, that the leader of the House of Delegates must take a more active role.

 

There is little doubt that in 2004 the House leadership caved in to the triangulation strategy orchestrated by Sen. John. Chichester, R-Northumberland. By proposing a $4 billion tax increase Chichester made Gov. Warner’s $1+ billion tax proposal seem reasonable.

 

The House leadership’s response was nothing short of trying to outsmart the Senate by half. Astonishingly, the House moved from a position of "no taxes" to meeting Warner's tax-increase proposals half-way—and got nothing in return for complete capitulation.

 

Throughout these political machinations, Speaker Howell’s articulated positions were as clear as mud. He touted that the House would hold the line on taxes, while at the same time saying that raising certain taxes would be acceptable.

 

In the end, when 19 liberal Republicans sided with the Democrat minority, the response from the House leadership was muted. Instead of punishing the turncoats for voting against the Republican leadership, the leadership of the House Caucus told the RINOs (Republican In Name Only) to vote their consciences.

 

None of the renegades faced any consequences for their votes; more importantly, none of the committee chairmen who voted for the tax increase lost control of their committees. This ineffective response allowed the RINOs to claim that they did the courageous thing—indirectly implying that the majority of the Republicans Delegates didn’t have a backbone.

 

Later, when conservatives challenged a number of the RINOs, the moderate Republican establishment cried out against the challengers. In the end, conservatives were blamed for the loss of a few Republican seats.

 

When some of the RINOs publicly supported Democrat candidates—as was the case with Delegates Gary Reese, R-Centreville, and Jim Dillard, R-Fairfax—no one from the Republican establishment spoke out against them for abandoning the Party or blamed them for the eventual loss of two Republican seats.

 

Reese’s humiliating loss to Chris Craddock—a neophyte who trounced him with 66 percent of the primary vote—has left him emotionally imbalanced. In repeated letters to the editors published in the local papers he has gone out of his way to extol the Democrat candidate, Chuck Caputo.

 

At the same time, Reese has been decrying that his beloved Republican Party has been commandeered by right-wing extremists. In his last letter published in the Centreview, Reese went as far as listing by name a number of Republican activists.

 

These are some of the same activists who in prior years had campaigned and voted for Reese. They only turned against him when he abandoned the Republican caucus and conspired with the opposition party in enacting a tax increase against the basic creed of the Republican Party.

 

What makes Reese’s ramblings so ironically amusing are his hypocritical and selective accusations of who he terms extremists. Given the fact that even U.S. Representatives Tom Davis and Frank Wolf held a fundraiser for Chris Craddock, he must also consider them to be right-wing zealots.

 

No one has directly attributed the loss of the Republican seats held by Reese and Dillard to the leadership vacuum in the House of Delegates. Had Speaker Howell made it clear that there would be hell to pay for any Republican who voted with the Democrats, the final outcomes of the 2004 tax increase and the 2005 elections, would have been entirely different.

 

Republican moderates are lamenting the loss of a few seats in the House of Delegates and generally blame conservative activists. At the same time, no one is pointing the finger to a Republican leadership that remains muted and rudderless.

 

-- November 28, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Phillip Rodokanakis, a Certified Fraud Examiner, lives in Oak Hill. He is the managing partner of U.S. Data Forensics, LLC, a company specializing in Computer Forensics, Fraud Investigations, and Litigation Support. He is also the President of the Virginia Club for Growth.

 

He can be reached by e-mail at phil_r@cox.net.

 

Read his profile here.

 


 

To visit the VA Club for Growth website
click here.


Subscribe to the 

Club for Growth

free news updates