The Jefferson Journal

Michael W. Thompson



Give It Back!

The state's budget surplus is approaching $2 billion a year. It's time to rebate some of it back to the taxpayers.


 

If the local grocery store overcharges you, you get a refund. Today our state government has overcharged you, but you won’t get it back without political pressure. Let me explain.

 

Bucket loads of money are flowing into the state treasury far beyond what is needed to meet the approved budget. Just look at the numbers. When the General Assembly passed the current two-year budget in May 2004, it also raised our taxes by $1.5 billion to “fill the gap” and pay for “needed additions” in public education, Medicaid and other “essentials.”

 

And then when the General Assembly convened this past January the state had a surplus of $1.4 billion after only 6 months of the two-year budget. It was readily spent. And now, with the closing of the state’s books on June 30, there is an additional surplus of $544 million. That’s almost a $2 billion surplus in the first year of the two-year budget cycle!

 

The Rainy Day Fund (the state’s reserve account) is now fully funded. This means large chunks of future surpluses won’t have to be funneled into it.

 

So, there are gobs of extra tax dollars flowing into Richmond – far beyond what was required to finance the current two year budget.

 

And we are only half way through the two-year budget! There is no reason to believe that surpluses won’t continue into the second half of the budget cycle.

 

But not one of Virginia’s political leaders has called for a major tax rebate. Those who opposed the recent tax increase aren’t promoting a tax rebate. They point to the surpluses and say that the tax increase wasn’t needed. But they aren’t saying this extra money should be sent back to the taxpayers. Why not?

 

Yet the surpluses in the two-year budget could very well be twice as large as the recent tax increase and maybe more!

 

With the Rainy Day Fund totally funded, it would not be difficult to earmark the next $750 million for a major tax rebate of $100 per person. How to distribute this tax rebate can be determined later – a check for each person, a rebate to those who file income taxes, or some other fair and equitable way to refund this clear overpayment of taxes.

 

I’m talking about a tax rebate from the “extra” money that is available because the state is bringing in billions of dollars more than was planned for in this budget cycle. This huge surplus is actually an overpayment by us taxpayers and should be considered such.

 

A major tax rebate is good public policy and it is good politics.

 

If Governor Warner really wants to draw a bright line of difference between Senator Hillary Clinton and him, he should call for a major tax rebate.

 

If Jerry Kilgore wants to bring a truly exciting issue to the governor’s race, he should call for a major tax rebate today. You can see the yard signs and bumper stickers now:  “Give it Back!”

 

This campaign would ring as loud and clear just as Jim Gilmore’s “No Car Tax” campaign and the George Allen’s “Welfare Reform” and “No Parole” campaign did a few years back.

 

If Lt. Governor Tim Kaine wants to soften his image as a very liberal Democrat, he should call for a major tax rebate from the boat loads of money that are pouring into the state coffers.

 

If the House Republican Caucus wants to protect its current majority and build an even larger margin, it should call for a major tax rebate.

 

If the Democrat Caucus wants to change its image and push the Republicans back on their heels, then it should call for a major tax rebate.

 

If those state Senators who worry about their re-elections in two years because of support for the recent tax increase, they can buy off a lot of heartburn by supporting a tax rebate.

 

But so far, no one is calling for this “tax overpayment” to be given back to the people. There is an ominous silence by our elected leaders and those who want to lead us over the next four years.

 

Why are all the anti-tax Republicans and all those “gee-we-wish-we-didn’t-have-to-raise-your-taxes” Democrats so willing to spend this incredible surplus and not give some of it back in a tax rebate?

 

The political leader who picks up this issue and runs with it will catch the imagination of the voters and will be rewarded with victory on Election Day this November.    

 

-- July 25, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Michael Thompson is chairman and president of the Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy, a non-partisan foundation seeking better alternatives to current government programs and policies. These are his opinions and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Institute or its Board of Directors.  Mr. Thompson can be reached here.