Guest Column

Blue Dog Tales


 

Kaine On Death and Taxes

 

Choir boy Tim Kaine is a political moderate informed by his Catholic beliefs. But look for the Kilgore team to paint him as a liberal for his record on tax hikes and the death penalty.


 

The Blue Dog personally views Lt. Gov. Tim Kaine as a moderate-to-conservative politician. Kaine has never been an Amway Christian, nor does he hold a lifetime membership to the C-E Club (i.e., only attending church service on Christmas and Easter holidays).

 

(Definition time ... Amway Christian (n.): A pretentious Christian who has forgotten the original message of Jesus Christ to be of assistance with those less fortunate.)

 

Yes, there's no doubt that Kaine is a serious and devout Catholic. His stands against abortion, except to safeguard the mother's health, and non-support for gay and lesbian marriages and same-sex civil unions place him within Virginia's social-right mainstream.

 

But the religious convictions that lead Kaine to oppose the Virginia death penalty are questionable with the majority of citizens who support the law. It's his weakest link. Virginians overwhelmingly favor the death penalty, three to one.

 

That's going to hurt the Kaine choirboy image.

 

Jerry Kilgore gubernatorial-campaign spokeswoman Carrie Cantrell said, "Already there has been much discussion about Tim Kaine’s record of activism against the death penalty. Going back to his days at Harvard Law School, Tim Kaine has demonstrated an impassioned opposition to the death penalty, comparing our criminal justice system to the Soviet Union, speaking at rallies against the death penalty and calling for a moratorium on the death penalty."

 

Cantrell went on to say, "The first major-party gubernatorial candidate to oppose the death penalty since capital punishment was reinstated in 1976, Kaine has spent his entire career in opposition to this founded deterrent to crime, the death penalty-- sanctioned only for the most heinous crimes committed against individuals.

 

"For Tim Kaine to now say he will 'uphold the law' is deliberately deceptive and a transparent attempt to hide his record. The law of Virginia allows the governor without reason or explanation to implement a moratorium of the death penalty on a case-by-case basis by pardoning or commuting sentences of death row inmates."

 

The Kaine campaign's director of communications, Mo Elleithee, replied in kind. "That’s nothing more than an attempt to confuse and frighten voters. Clemency has historically been granted by Virginia governors in only the most rare of circumstances, and Tim Kaine will follow that tradition. Any other application would violate the spirit of his oath of office."

 

As a Virginia politician, Kaine has committed himself to upholding Virginia law concerning the death penalty. He's never wavered on those statements throughout his political career.

 

Elleithee said, "Because of his strong faith, Tim Kaine believes in the sanctity of life. Therefore, he has a faith-based opposition to both the death penalty and abortion. But when he places his hand on a bible to take an oath of office to uphold the law, he takes that oath as seriously as his marriage oath. He will enforce the death penalty in exactly the same way as have the eight previous governors--four Democrat and four Republican.

 

"Jerry Kilgore seems to be saying that people with strong faith-based beliefs are incapable of keeping an oath of office. That’s insulting, and it’s wrong."

 

The Washington Post reported that Kaine's associations with the American Civil Liberties Union and death-penalty cases, according to GOP sources, were going to polish off and sink his Democratic campaign.

 

An anonymous GOP operative told the Post, "You watch, that's how the campaign will unfold."

 

Show me the money

 

OK, the death penalty is looming large on the gubernatorial campaign. And Kaine can expect to take a huge hit ... but what about those 2004 historic Virginia tax increases?

 

Our friend on the hundred-dollar bill, Benjamin Franklin, once wrote, "Our Constitution is in actual operation; everything appears to promise that it will last; but in this world nothing is certain but death and taxes."

Yes, death and taxes are certain issues in the upcoming 2005 Virginia gubernatorial race …

Most politicos and pundits would agree that Kaine's support for the 2004 General Assembly tax increases is going to be hard to overcome, but the political issue is manageable due to GOP complicity in both the House and Senate.

 

Republican statewide candidates cannot use the tax increase against their Democratic opponents without potentially harming General Assembly GOP incumbents that voted for Gov. Mark Warner's 2004 budget.

 

That's a gotcha.

 

No doubt in my mind, senators John Chichester, Tommy Norment, Russ Potts and Emmett Hanger could possibly find themselves on another Democratic governor’s Christmas-card list in 2005.

 

As for Kilgore, he might be sending those pro-tax Republicans a lump of coal.

 

Kilgore's substance vs. dogma

 

Is resigning as Virginia's attorney general a sign of faltering leadership?

 

"As for the tone of the campaign, we believe that this is a race about who is best suited to lead Virginia. Therefore, questions about leadership are fair game - and this is an example of his lack of leadership," Elleithee said.

 

As for Kilgore's political status, he's always been a staunch leader amongst Virginia's conservatives - both socially and fiscally.

 

Cantrell said, "As the newspapers are pointing out, this campaign will be a classic match between the conservative Jerry Kilgore and the liberal Tim Kaine. Over the course of the next 10 months, we will debate the issues that are important to the people of Virginia and the philosophical differences between the two candidates.

 

"It will be clear to the people of Virginia that Tim Kaine is out of touch with the values of a majority of Virginians as it relates to the public policy of Virginia."

 

There's no need for Kilgore to tread lightly on those issues because a majority of rural Virginians will vote only for the R candidate, while avoiding D candidates on Election Day.

 

But nothing is a gimme in this election year.

 

Case in point: Kilgore's milquetoast support of anti-tax General Assembly members during the 2004 historic tax-and-spend session.

 

Like a lemming jumping into the cold seas of Virginia public opinion, lukewarm water-loving disciple Kilgore eventually scampered behind the leadership of Sen, George Allen and soon-to-be Richmond mayor Doug Wilder, who took a unified stand against the tax increase.

 

Kilgore has his challenges within the ultra-right conservative community due to his statements concerning transportation-funding issues as well.

 

His proposal and support of transportation bonds are the bone of contention amongst anti-taxers along with his recent remarks concerning other methods of transportation funding.

 

With raised eyebrows and a long, deep sigh, an anti-tax friend recently said, "Kilgore is on his own" - with the upcoming campaign due to that bond-beating road path.

 

What about Kilgore's dogma vote-getting potential? It's debatable whether Kaine will have an upper hand with the Catholic vote. But most would agree that 

Kilgore has a lock on the conservative social issues with the growing numbers of Virginia evangelical that vote religiously.

 

As far as other issues... Mr. Kilgore has done a respectable job as attorney general with public-safety issues since the terrorist attack on 9/11. He should do well with swing voters (i.e., Security Moms and NASCAR Dads) if he campaigns on those issues involving Virginia's security. Most pundits have forgotten that the Pentagon in Virginia was also targeted that tragic day.

 

Discussing the Kilgore agenda, Cantrell said, "Jerry Kilgore is running for governor to reform government so that we unleash the potential of all Virginians - educational excellence for every child, keeping people and commerce moving, protecting our communities from those who want to do harm, and creating economic opportunities. Who serves as the governor of Virginia is important for our families and for our future.

 

"Jerry Kilgore has spent almost his entire career keeping our streets and communities safe, and protecting the rights of victims. He's going to take that same passion and make our great Commonwealth an even better place to call home."

 

Democratic fear factor

 

Maybe it's fear driven, but Virginia Democrats have been complaining about the powerful Republican political machine gearing up to defeat Kaine and the other statewide candidates.

 

Democrats should be accustomed to that GOP attack machine by now. Elleithee is a campaign vet and has faced off with Republicans for the top spot in the state as Warner's campaign aide. Let’s not forget, Elleithee came out on the winning side.

 

That GOP boogieman excuse is well worn by Virginia Democrats and frankly, folks, it's beginning to sound like a broken record across the Commonwealth.

Virginia Democrats need to please stop calling 9-WAAA-WAAAA!

 

Hey, Mo Elleithee! It's not the negative political wordsmithing, but those 20-plus direct mailers sent statewide that are funded by the GOP contribution machine. Repetition, misinformation, repetition, misinformation, repetition, misinformation ...

 

That's another gotcha. It's time-tested strategy for most of Virginia's political campaigns.

 

I'm not sure yet whether the Kaine campaign retaliation in the media this past week will help or harm the Democratic candidate. Like I said before, it's early in the campaign season to let the dogs out.

 

As an astute political friend noted, "The Virginian Pilot editorial 'Kaine should muzzle his attack dogs' is there forever, and will probably be used in GOP direct mailers."

 

Those double-misinformation twins of the Republican Party--Ray Allen, the "prince of darkness," and Scott Howell, the "grim reaper"--probably willk do some of their best work against Kaine if his campaign spokesman keeps supplying them juicy tidbits of information. They might eventually morph Choirboy Kaine into Karl Marx's first cousin.

 

There's no doubt in my mind that the direct-mail legend of Virginia is Republican Ray Allen. He's the best.

While his like-minded buddy, Howell, is best known for his work across America, such as the advertising work produced by this Dallas-based operative linking former Georgia Sen. Max Cleland with Osama bin Laden in 2002.

 

It’s a dynamic duo.

 

Stop feeding those political attack dogs!

 

But on the flip side, there are a few Democratic alter egos within direct-mail community, throughout the USA, that would love to tackle and slam-dunk Kilgore's sporadic legislative record.

 

I'm sure that the $5 million contribution to Kaine from the Democratic National Committee will be used to pay that bill as well.

 

With those dollars, maybe the campaign might hire Michael Moore to direct a 30-second spot?

 

Err ... Mr. Kaine, on second thought (because Moore has those Hollywood left-wing, liberal connotations) maybe you ought to pass on that misguided suggestion, OK?

 

Elleithee told the Blue Dog, "The Kilgore campaign has been hitting Tim Kaine with brass knuckles for months, going so far as to attack his faith. ... We’re going to keep our discussion on the issues and on the topic of who is best suited to lead--but we’re also not going to be anyone’s punching bag."

 

Cantrell replied, "The Tim Kaine campaign claims that we are attacking his religious views but that is far from the truth. The issue of the death penalty is worthy of public debate and discussion. We are having this debate in the context of the public policy of Virginia, and what the next governor is going to do with the power he has relating to the death penalty."

 

Word of advice: Tim "TKO" Kaine really needs to concentrate and focus on Virginia's smart-growth initiatives and link Virginia’s transportation issues to our future challenges because these are important issues dealing with Virginia’s quality of life.

 

Hey, Choirboy Kaine, nobody likes to be picked on, but it takes two to fight. And it's OK to fight back! But Mr. Kaine, you need to first tackle Kilgore's big campaign issues, such as crime and immigration in the Commonwealth.

 

Kaine once gave the Blue Dog some campaign advice as a General Assembly candidate. He said, "Steve, try to be more, err ... positive."

 

The Blue Dog says listen to your own advice and put away those brass knuckles, Tim.

 

Shake more hands and kiss more babies and address the issues important to Virginia's future.

 

-- February 14, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Blog!

 

Post a comment on the Bacon's Rebellion blog.

 


 

 

Steven Sisson is a fiscally conservative, Mountain-Valley Democrat, party activist, columnist and serious amateur genealogist. His work is published in the August Free Press  

His e-mail address is:

ValleyBlueDog@aol.com

 

Read his profile