Guest Column

Blue Dog Tales



Join the Club

Just get parental consent first... And then get over it. The flap in Harrisonburg over the Gay-Straight Alliance serves no one but the two extremes.


Who is to blame for the pandering politics? Gay and lesbian organizations, the Valley Family Forum or local political parties?

 

I'm blaming them all.

 

The Blue Dog says it's a real shame the local gay and lesbian community, the Valley Family Forum and Republican Party membership has decided to politicize the news regarding the Gay-Straight Alliance at Harrisonburg High School and use our children as pawns in this twisted social behavior play-of-the- week highlight film.

 

Honestly, our children deserve better treatment--and our children attend public school to learn to add and subtract and read and write, period. 

 

Dr. Thomas Szasz--the legendary psychiatric abolitionist--has written, "Permissiveness is the principle of treating children as if they were adults; and the tactic of making sure they never reach that stage."

 

On a parental note: The Blue Dog somewhat agrees with Szasz's statement because this parent believes that morals and sexuality should be taught at home or the church. Certainly not by our local, state or federal government.

 

The same can be said of public school-system activities and clubs. Our children are not property of the state--and every now and then somebody needs to remind these advocates on the political right and the left.

 

In addition, the Blue Dog doesn't believe public-school clubs should segregate our children by religion, race, ethnicity, or, particularly, sexuality. School clubs should be allowed to exist only if they are part of the education curriculum.

 

The Blue Dog hopes the gay and lesbian community does not go the route as other minorities in the past with their own neighborhoods, style of music, lingo and houses of worship. It's a destructive path.

 

If you want equal treatment in society, let's celebrate differences and find common ground with the social issues. And please, for gosh stakes, find a way to stop building more walls to divide us.

 

In a recent e-mail alert dated Nov. 30, Equality Virginia executive director Dyana Mason said the parental-consent policy for GSA clubs might prevent students who need the support from getting it.

 

Mason wrote, "Requiring parental consent to join these and other clubs would discourage participation by the greatest diversity of students and diminish the educational and social benefits of these organizations. ... We know that the school board has the best interests of the students at heart." 

 

The e-mail from Mason went on to say, "Nonetheless, implementing a parental-consent policy could very well prohibit those students most in need of a peer group--those suffering from ongoing harassment, intimidation or depression--from participating in Gay-Straight Alliances and receiving the educational and social benefits these clubs provide simply because they are afraid to discuss their reasons for joining the club with their parents."

 

I disagree with her analysis. As a parent, I would endorse the use of consent forms for all clubs regardless. Not because of the current controversy with the Harrisonburg High School Gay-Straight Alliance club, but for the need to be aware and involved as a caring and loving parent.

 

By the way, the Blue Dog feels the same way about the need for parental notification concerning abortions for minors. No government entity should allow minors to make adult decisions because it is our responsibility and duty as parents to teach life values.

 

Furthermore, minors by law can play school sports, open a bank account, travel via airlines, receive medical care, attend school field trips, stay after school, and ride the school bus without permission from a parent or guardian. There are probably thousands of other examples.

 

Parental consent is a must, and that's the Blue Dog line in the sand.

-- January 17, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Steven Sisson is a fiscally conservative, Mountain-Valley Democrat, party activist, columnist and serious amateur genealogist. His work is published in the August Free Press  

His e-mail address is:

ValleyBlueDog@aol.com

 

Read his profile