Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Masters of Their Domain

 

It was straight out of a Seinfeld episode—an election about nothing. With nothing to analyze, pundits returned to their old reliable theme, taxes, and some took on roles reminiscent of the Seinfeld cast.

 

Playing George Costanza, embittered and opinionated about less than life-and-death issues, was Steve Pearlstein of the Washington Post. Pearlstein hasn’t seen Gov. Mark R. Warner’s tax reform plan, but he’s sure it will be his “legacy.” What he has seen are those standing in the way of his unannounced plan. There’s the hairdresser and dry cleaner, telling the “bloody lie” that their businesses will be impacted if sales tax is imposed on services. There’s the Northern Virginia Technology Council, which “Seem[s] to care more about preventing taxes on Internet transactions than educating the next generation of software engineers.” There’s the Virginia Chamber of Commerce “where small business often equates with small-mindedness.” Worst of all, of course, there’s “Republican demagoguery.”

 

Pearlstein took over the Costanza role from the suddenly less-than-prolific Gordon Morse of the Post and Daily Press. Morse’s best Republican-bashing line was this: “Over our free-lunch dead bodies, say members of the House, where moderation has been pummeled and lies inert.”

 

Playing Kramer, he of counter-intuitive pronouncements, was Jeff Schapiro of the Richmond Times-Dispatch. Reporting on an interview with Jerry Kilgore, Schapiro interpreted Kilgore’s comment, "I don't favor tax increases," to mean “reluctance to say now - clearly, crisply and definitively - that he's a tax hawk up there with the best of them.” Venturing even further into the outer reaches of counter-intuitivity, Schapiro suggested that Governor Warner could astound the political world by proposing a flat tax. Maybe, like Kramer, Schapiro has really good sources.

 

In non-Seinfeld post-election punditry, Preston Bryant of the Roanoke Times predicted that the 15 new members of the General Assembly will be “giddy with excitement and awed by the honor of it all,” followed by “shocked into reality when they’ll be able to deliver on virtually nothing they may have been foolish enough to promise.” Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress analyzed one of the most acrimonious campaigns, the Janis-McGuire spectacle in the 56th House District. “Liar” and “Embezzler” were the key phrases in that race.

 

An Election to Remember

 

The failed transportation referendum of last year continues to attract more commentary than the election of two months ago. Latest to comment on the failed tax plan was “Dr. Gridlock,” Ron Schaffer of the Washington Post. In response to a letter from a reader who attributed the defeat to inadequate mass transit projects, Schaffer wrote:

 

Are you satisfied now? You had a new funding source for transportation projects and rejected it because the plan wasn't perfect. Now you have no new revenue source, and a bunch of needed transportation projects have no funding. I get 400 e-mails, faxes and letters a week, many of them cries for help concerning our inadequate transportation system. When I see assistance defeated by the loud, organized naysayers -- even to study a possible techway at no cost to Virginians -- I get discouraged.

 

Every Penny Counts

 

Washington Post columnist Marc Fisher recounted the story of a Reston woman who attempted to pay her Fairfax County “processing fee” of $55 with pennies. The fee is routinely added to traffic fines and, in this case, the traffic violation was only $30. The citizen was protesting the extra fee, a fee that is not charged by every Virginia locality. Fisher was sympathetic:

 

Ok, it's not the perfect form of protest, and of course it would be easier just to take her case to the judge. But if she wants to make a larger public point than she might make in a single court appearance, this seems like a reasonable way to go.

 

A Heart-Rending Plea

 

Maurice Jones, Commissioner of the Virginia Department of Social Services and Deputy Chief of Staff to Gov. Warner, took to the Roanoke Times op-ed pages to support the nationwide Adoption Awareness Month. Approximately 7,500 Virginia children are in foster care, with 608 eligible for adoption now. Many of these children have special needs and Jones’ department has become much more flexible regarding adoption requirements. He wrote, “We must listen to each of these waiting children who are telling us that they want to be loved and wanted, and want to have the chance to share their own gifts and potential with others.”

 

Comeback Trail?

 

Former Gov. Jim Gilmore did a guest turn on CNN’s Capital Gang, commenting on national politics and international events. Not exactly charismatic himself, Gilmore described Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., as “The most boring candidate I've ever seen in my whole life.” Gilmore credited another former governor, Howard Dean, with clearly defining himself as the “opposition candidate.”

 

-- November 17, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.