Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Hurricane Isabel Leaves Trail of Bloviation

 

Virginia’s pundits offered a variety of commentaries in the aftermath of Hurricane Isabel, ranging from the pugnacious to the personal.

 

Winner of the Rush Limbaugh Award for courting controversy was A. Barton Hinkle of the Richmond Times-Dispatch. Hinkle defended price 

gouging as a rational economic response to shortages in the aftermath of the storm. He also defended those speculators who bought up storm necessities and resold them with a high mark-up. They were just “imitating” Gov. Mark R. Warner’s business model — Warner became wealthy by reselling government licenses he got for free. In the Virginian-Pilot, Kerry Dougherty called some price gouging contractors “scoundrel, vermin, and hurricane hairballs,” but stopped short of endorsing all but limited restrictions on the practice.

 

University of Virginia Environmental Sciences Professor and Cato Institute Fellow Patrick Michaels, writing in the Washington Post, blamed the extensive damage caused by the storm on our love for trees:

 

In today's blame game, people are pointing fingers at Pepco and Dominion Virginia Power, when the cause of all the mess is right out there in the backyard, planted and neglected since the house was built. The power companies can't come in and saw down trees on your property that stand 60 feet from the residential power line. If they had the authority and the will to do so, there would hardly be any shade left in Falls Church. Imagine the hue and cry from our suburban culture, which worships trees as ardently as Egyptians once venerated cats.

 

Dave Addis of the Virginian-Pilot discussed the implications of the fine print found in homeowners insurance. Many homeowners discovered after storm damage that their deductibles had increased. He called for insurance companies to direct some of the creativity they put into advertising toward advising customers of insurance changes.

 

Jeff Schapiro of the Richmond Times-Dispatch speculated on the politics of the storm, especially on the issue of taxes:

 

Never mind that the hurricane could prove the strongest argument for strengthening the services on which Virginians depend: police, rescue, transportation, schools and health. Maybe Isabel will be a reminder that all this costs money - and might require even more from taxpayers.

 

Hugh Lessig and Terry Scanlon, writing in the Daily Press, noted how the storm affected election campaigns, canceling events and then impacting the issues candidates confronted.

 

One Virginia pundit, Jesse Todd of the Daily Press, shared the personal devastation that Isabel visited upon his home. He wrote of the things he would have after the storm that he could not have imagined before the storm:

 

Have a tree on my house (big enough to await a crane). Have a smashed chimney cover, smashed gutters, smashed porch railing. Have flashing ripped off to open the underside of the roof to rain. Have no electricity. Have no phone service. Have a car with a broken windshield, broken windshield wiper and numerous dents.

 

Nonetheless, Todd believes himself “incredibly lucky.” As Virginia returns to “normal” after Isabel, it’s a belief worth contemplating.

 

Tax Heroes

 

Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot praised Del. Allen Louderback, R-Luray, and David Jarman of the Virginia Organizing Project for their advocacy of tax reform proposals. That’s the good news, but the bad news for Edds is, “Virginia [should not have] to rely on a two-term delegate, a grassroots organizing group, and newcomers to the state such as Jarman to do the heavy lifting on tax reform.”

 

Patrick Lackey, Edds’ colleague at the Pilot, continued his on-going crusade against tax cuts and for higher taxes by writing, “I view paying taxes the same way I view buying a car. I don't want to pay too much, but I want to pay enough to get a car that runs and a government that works.”

 

The Big Kahuna

 

The Virginia Republican eavesdropping scandal refuses to die, much to the delight of Virginia Democrats. Jeff Schapiro traces the scandal’s newest and potentially juiciest link: Attorney General Jerry Kilgore. The essential case against the AG: 

 

Kilgore has generally ducked publicly discussing the details of this 20-month-old scandal. He defers to his handlers, who attempt to keep the opposition at bay with biting quotes that could further validate the impression that Kilgore has something to hide.

 

All Hail the Revolving Door

 

Delegate and pundit Preston Bryant, writing in his Roanoke Times column, heaped accolades on former delegate Jack Rollison, now working for VDOT Chief Philip Shucet. After losing his spring primary, Rollison was quoted as saying he was going to concentrate on his auto service business, but apparently an enhanced pension for staying in state government was more lucrative. Rollison does have extensive experience with transportation issues.

 

Wilder Agonistes

 

Former Governor L. Douglas Wilder used his Richmond Times-Dispatch commentary column to publish the letter he sent resigning his seat on the Board of Trustees of Virginia Union University.  Wilder, concerned about the financial health of the school and the apparent unwillingness of school’s president to accede to an audit, grandly placed his action in the context of “Forty years after the March on Washington led by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.”

 

Market Contraction

 

Virginia Pundit Watch offers a belated welcome to Barnie Day, newest member of the Bacon’s Rebellion family. Bacon’s Rebellion gain is VPW’s loss. Day has always been a rich source of no-holds-barred commentary from an unabashedly partisan point of view. Now that Day can be found in his entirety on these pages, Virginia Pundit Watch is going to have to dig deeper to find equally compelling bloviation.

 

-- October 6, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.