Lief's Law

Joshua N. Lief



May the War Pass Quickly

 

The war on terror is real, but the case for invading Iraq is less than compelling. Bottom line: Support the president, pray for our soldiers and wish for a speedy end to the war.


We all have our story of what we were doing on September 11, 2001. Like members of the generation before mine who remember exactly what they were doing when they heard Kennedy was assassinated, we will tell our grandchildren where we were and what we were doing that day.

I was working as Deputy Secretary of Commerce and Trade in the Administration of Governor Jim Gilmore.  For nearly four years, we had leaped from issue-to-issue at breakneck speed – covering the entire gamut of economic activity in the Commonwealth and in preparing for and covering the General Assembly sessions. Then, in August and early September 2001, things slowed for the first time. I was just starting to think about what I would do if the upcoming gubernatorial election went Democratic, which at the time was starting to look like a strong possibility, when things got very busy, very fast.

Commerce and Trade is almost always involved in disaster response because of the impacts on the economy and the agencies that are part of the Secretariat. As Deputy Secretary, I had already handled disasters such as floods, fires, droughts, foot-and-mouth disease. After 9-11, I was appointed coordinator of the Virginia Post Attack Economic Task Force. We did a good job as far as government goes, increasing unemployment benefits, working to reopen Ronald Reagan airport, and assisting displaced Virginians in other ways. I met President Bush briefly when he came to reopen the airport. I'll never forget how the Governor and all in attendance basked in the presidential glow.

On a personal level, I watched the 9-11 events unfold in the Secretary’s office watching TV with our staff. I'd been fascinated by the construction of the twin towers as a child, and I felt so sure that the buildings would survive. I was shocked to the core to see them fall. A month or so later on a trip to visit my parents, I stopped off at ground zero around 2 a.m., walked around and cried. I visited the Pentagon the week of the attacks, and will never forget the sights, sounds and smells of that day.  

I accepted the invasion of Afghanistan and the hunt for Osama Bin Laden as a logical response to 9-11. However, I watched with more than a little concern as America started to change, even though I accept the reasons for that change. In Virginia, our wonderfully open State Capital became somewhat oppressive. Heretofore unheard-of measures – nametags, signing in, metal detectors, car checks, questions from uniformed officers – all have become a part of the post-9-11 world in Richmond. Freedom is the most prized thing our forefathers handed down to us, and I hate to believe that the terrorists have snatched even a small part of it from us.

Now we have invaded Iraq, and we appropriately ask ourselves: Is this just -- is this correct? We are told that Iraq has dreadful weapons and that it will use them. The comparison is made between appeasement of Saddam Hussein and Chamberlain’s infamous “peace in our time” appeasement of Hitler.[1] I trust President Bush and believe he has the best interests of the Nation at heart. But I cannot help ask the following questions:

  • Is America’s vital national interest at stake? That, in my opinion, is the benchmark question we must answer before putting our military into action.

  • Could we not contain Iraq by threatening to annihilate it if it dared to use Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs)? This was our policy towards the Soviet Union , a much greater threat, and it worked.

  • If Iraq and/or terrorists had WMDs to attack America, wouldn’t they have done so already?

  • With our economy suffering, is this the best use of America's resources?

  • Is this cause worth the loss of one American life (or dare I say the life of an innocent Iraqi)?

It is extremely important to stress, however, that we should be able to discuss the war and ask questions while still feeling a strong sense of pride in our nation, our leaders and troops.

When push comes to shove, we must put our trust in the president. He and his cabinet know so much more than we do. They are dealing with the situation round-the-clock. We pray for our soldiers and their families and, most particularly, we hope that we have equipped our soldiers with the best possible tools to do the job they must do. We pray the war will end quickly and positively and with the lowest human cost possible.

In many ways, I think the WW II - and perhaps even the Vietnam-generation -- had it easier than we do when grappling with issues of war and peace. In a pre-cable TV/pre-Internet world, people got daily updates from the newspapers, radio or evening news. Today's media delivers a continual, detailed flow of information – even when nothing newsworthy is happening. We are so bombarded with information and images that it can become difficult to carry on. We watch the news and want to see minute-by-minute reports with pictures, almost like it was a football game. We want to know what is going to happen, when it is going to happen and how it is going to happen. Can you imagine, in today’s media age, of the United States trying to pull off the feint toward Pas de Calais in France before landing on Normandy?

Terrorism and comparisons to Hitler notwithstanding, I don’t feel threatened by Iraq. Saddam Hussein lacks the capability to attack our country in any meaningful way. However, he has defied the world community. Our Commander In Chief has committed us to battle. Along with our allies, we have deployed an overwhelming force and will be victorious. We pray for the safety of our troops and for their families when they are faced with the ultimate sacrifice made on our behalf. We pray for the good judgment of our leaders. Most of all, we hope and pray for a swift conclusion to war.


[1] The comparison to Hitler was more accurate in 1991 when Iraq was invading a neighboring nation. Nazi Germany (along with its Axis allies) had expansionist desires of world domination – can the same be said about Iraq?   

-- March 24, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Profile

Joshua N. Lief is an attorney at Sands Anderson Marks & Miller in Richmond who specializes in Business and Government Affairs. He is a former Deputy and Secretary of Commerce and Trade during the Gilmore Administration. He can be reached by e-mail at jlief@sandsanderson.com