Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Nothing is Certain But Abortion and Tax Fights

 

Virginia pundits have dropped their obsession with Judge Verbena Askew, replacing it with a fixation on General Assembly abortion legislation.

 

I've lost count of all the op-ed energy, pro and con, expended on this long-running issue that 

divides Virginians as well as Americans. A. Barton Hinkle of the Richmond Times-Dispatch had perhaps the most thoughtful piece, castigating the plastic fetus antics of Del. Richard Black, R-Loudoun, while admitting his own mixed personal feelings: “This column's policy view on abortion resembles that regarding gangsta rap: It's something difficult to abide but wrong to outlaw.”

 

Mark Smith of NARAL Virginia had no mixed feelings in his Roanoke Times piece, criticizing the “extremist zeal” of anti-abortion supporters. He accused them of wasting the General Assembly’s precious time. Radford professor William Oliver, also in the Times, denounced the paper for its biased reporting on the issue, favoring abortion. The Virginian-Pilot’s Margaret Edds wrote: “Welcome to the new Virginia. It makes me skittish. It's a Virginia in which the war against abortion is won by dictate rather than persuasion.”

 

Meanwhile, as the Virginia budget was being hammered out in a news vacuum, pundits and legislators wrote longingly of overhauling Virginia ’s tax code or saving the Commonwealth by either ending or keeping the estate tax. R. H. Melton of the Washington Post looked at history and current reality:

 

Modernizing the tax code -- so it helps, not hurts, local governments that are confronting bewildering and costly demands for services -- has long been a goal of state leaders, but it has been much easier to study the issue to death than to do something.

 

In short, tax restructuring is a politician's nightmare: It has no sex appeal as a campaign issue and is loaded with many election-time land mines.

 

Yet, there is a consensus to do something on taxes, albeit a fragile one that could blow away in the slightest partisan breeze.

 

Del. Steve Landes, R-Waynesboro, in the Roanoke Times, hailed several budget reforms Republicans have recommended. Continuing the Times’ op-ed proliferation, Del. Bob McDonnell, R-Virginia Beach, made a case for ending the estate tax on the same page that Del. Clifton “Chip” Woodrum, D-Roanoke, made a case against it. 

 

Margaret Edds continued her lament about the “new Virginia”:

 

A Virginia in which millionaires get a $136 million tax break pronto, while a cut in the sales tax on food goes on hold.

 

A Virginia in which few have the courage to support desperately needed reforms in the state tax code until after the next election -- if then.

 

Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress singled out the estate tax politics of Sen. Thomas Norment, R-Williamsburg. Describing him as a “clubby insider, Gibson attributes his support of ending the estate tax to “political atonement” for supporting the Hampton Roads transportation referendum. It’s also because Norment is facing a potential primary challenge from the right.

 

Colonial Capital Pundit Wrap-Up

 

In a Daily Press op-ed, Williamsburg Mayor Jeanne Zeidler defended rental inspections against a bill in the General Assembly that would end them. … Bill Bryant, a civic activist also writing in the Daily Press, laid out a plan for managing the growth that is threatening Williamsburg’s historic character. … College of William and Mary Men’s Soccer Coach Al Albert, in a passionate op-ed in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, urged changes to Title IX that would allow more male participation in college sports. (Full disclosure: Al Albert was my physical education professor for soccer and lacrosse, two required PE units that carried no credit at W&M).

 

Virginia Sightings

 

Del. Richard Black, R-Sterling, appeared with his pro-choice license plate in a Dahlia Lithwick legal story for Slate.OpinionJournal’s Best of the Web had fun with a Virginia General Assembly battle over a flag symbolizing Southern Heritage—the South Vietnamese flag.

 

Constructive Criticism, Friendly Advice

 

After a long hiatus, Gordon Morse is back, this time with a Washington Post op-ed excoriating Republicans in the General Assembly. Calling them “blinkered, provincial, self-aggrandizing, ecclesiastic and dumb,” Morse describes their budget proposals as a “debacle.” Gov. Mark R. Warner is urged to  “Dispense with humility and imitate the tiger: Unsheathe the veto pen, draw blood and let his voice, for once, emit passion.”

 

Send Money

 

Dan Hanfling, writing in the Washington Post, called for more federal money to support emergency preparedness at Northern Virginia hospitals. These hospitals would be on the front lines of any terrorist attack against the Nation’s Capital.  Hanfling is the director of emergency management and disaster medicine at Inova Health System.

 

The Million Dollar Question

 

According to Kerry Dougherty of the Virginian-Pilot, the million dollar question is, why is Hampton Roads called Hampton Roads? A Brooklyn caller told her it sounded like it was “out in the sticks.”

 

-- February 17, 2003

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.