Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



Pundits Go Askew

 

The case of an obscure Newport News judge that obsessed one Tidewater pundit exploded into the biggest issue of the week for everyone, including one columnist not normally given to covering Richmond.

Daily Press columnist Jim Spencer had been flogging the story of Circuit Judge Verbena Askew’s travails before General Assembly courts committees. She had drawn criticism from Republicans for her alleged role in a sexual harassment suit settled by the City of Newport News. There were also allegations that her rumored sexual orientation was being used against her. 

 

When the judge was denied reappointment, Spencer attacked Senator Ken Stolle, R-Virginia Beach and attributed Askew’s defeat to “a corrupt political system.”

 

Other pundits piled on, notably Washington Post Metro columnist Marc Fisher. He called the vote on Askew

 

The culminating act in the General Assembly's Let's Hear Juicy Bits About Lesbians Week, a seedy little enterprise in which the ever-bolder Republican majority had itself a whale of a time grilling judges about their sexual pleasures.

 

Jeff Schapiro of the Richmond Times-Dispatch was more dispassionate. He traced a history of Republicans who have “chased a sitting judge from the bench” and noted that Democrats averaged rejecting two judges per year when they were in the majority. Schapiro guessed that Republicans might not pay a price for the Askew dust-up because of the safe seats they engineered through redistricting.

 

Look for commentators to use the aftermath of this controversy as a backdrop for future columns on bitter partisanship interfering with the General Assembly’s work.

 

Short Takes

 

Jim Spencer finally dropped the Askew case and launched a broadside against the spending habits of the Virginia Port Authority… Kay Slaughter, an attorney for the Southern Environmental Law Center and a former mayor of Charlottesville, bemoaned budget cuts to Virginia’s natural and historic preservation programs in a Daily Press op-ed … Former trucker Robert D. Gay suggested tolls on cars travelling I-81, not trucks, in a Roanoke Times commentary … Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot profiled brash anti-tax freshman Senator Ken Cuccinelli, R-Fairfax, writing, “I have seen the future, and it is impatient, irreverent, and girded with conviction.”

 

Preferences v. Preferences

 

Patrick Lackey of the Virginian-Pilot came out swinging in favor of the University of Michigan’s racial preference for admission by attacking “legacy” preferences. He never mentioned that a legacy preference was worth four points, while a racial preference was worth 20. He found a University of Virginia angle:

 

Admissions dean John Blackburn told The Wall Street Journal that the legacy program is needed to pay the bills. 'In light of very deep budget cuts from the state,'' he said, 'our private support, particularly from alumni, is crucial to maintaining the quality of the institution. The legacy preference helps ensure that support by recognizing their financial contributions and their service on university committees and task forces.''

 

About half of the $1.4 billion raised in a recent U.Va. fund drive came from out-of-state alumni.

 

Pundit v. Pundit

 

In a persuasive argument to nullify Virginia’s sodomy laws, the Richmond Times-Dispatch’s A. Barton Hinkle took a poke at Daily Press columnist Jim Spencer’s characterization of Delegate Robert McDonnell, R-Virginia Beach:

 

McDonnell's position does not make him - as a columnist for another newspaper called him - "Taliban Bob."

 

Pro-Choice, Pro-Chasm

 

Katherine B. Waddell, chairwoman of the Republican Pro-Choice Coalition of Virginia, commemorated the 30th anniversary of Roe v. Wade with an op-ed in the Richmond Times-Dispatch. She made a recommendation to pro-choice advocates:

 

One way pro-choice Virginians could honor the 30th anniversary of the Roe v. Wade decision is by working for a two-year moratorium on abortion-related legislation for consideration by the General Assembly.

 

Of course, by glossing over late-term abortion and parental notification, issues not a part of Roe, she probably guarantees that the pro-choice wing of the Republican Party in Virginia will continue to struggle.

 

Virginia Bashing

 

While still in Richmond after writing his column on Verbena Askew, Marc Fisher answered questions “live” on Washington Post Online. Asked about the Department of Homeland Security discarding Virginia as a headquarters location he joked, “Apparently, the Feds finally realized they'd forgotten about Virginia's sodomy law, and quickly retreated to the District.” He also took these comments from readers:

 

Having lived in Virginia for most of my life, I can say that there is a deep disrespect of homosexuals at many levels of government. This type of thinking is one of the major reasons I left the state. Why stay in the 18th century when a short drive takes you fresh into the modern world? My new home (D.C.) has its problems, but at least my private life doesn't make me a second-class citizen here.

 

We chose Maryland and thank God. Your column today reaches new lows for that sickening bunch in Richmond. I would be ashamed to have elected any of these folks. Sadly, few who did probably are.

-- January 27, 2002

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.