Nice & Curious Questions

Edwin S. Clay III and Patricia Bangs


 

 

Virginia: Home of the Outdoor Privy Race

 

Or, Whatever Happened to Outdoor Plumbing?


 

Even in the 21st century, Virginia celebrates its long tradition of outdoor privies or outhouses, also once known by such euphemisms as necessaries, boghouses, jakes, garde-robes, conveniences and some 30 other terms.

 

On January 9, 2008, House Joint Resolution 76 was offered in the Virginia House of Delegates “recognizing the Town of Independence as the Official Home of the Grand Privy Race  in Virginia.” Adopted 88-7 on January 21, the resolution still awaits final approval in the Senate, according to the General Assembly website.

 

Independence, in Grayson County, organized its first Mountain Foliage Festival back in 1984. In addition to celebrating southwest Virginia’s traditional crafts and music, the powers-that-be decided to celebrate the humor of mountain folk with the first ever Grand Privy Race. Apparently, each October, contestants put outdoor privies on wheels and race down the streets in the center of town. The winners are crowned Grand Privy Champions. As the resolution goes on to explain, the Mountain Foliage Festival “includes a multitude of family-friendly activities, including a parade featuring the winner of the ‘Potty Princess Pageant,’ art and craft exhibits by regional artisans, plenty of delicious food, and diverse entertainment from bluegrass music to local theatre.” It sounds like a lot of fun and must draw quite a crowd!

 

Outdoor privies have a long history in the Old Dominion and some, built by founding fathers such as Washington and Jefferson, were quite elegant. In an article in CW Journal a few years back (“Necessary and Sufficient,” Autumn 2002), historian Michael Olmert, an expert on dependency buildings, discusses the structures in colonial Williamsburg. While those who reconstructed the town in the 1930s, built paired privies on several properties, in some cases there is no evidence such structures existed at those locations. However, there were quite elegant paired privies at Thomas Jefferson’s home in Poplar Forest and at Washington’s Mt. Vernon.

 

The folk belief is that privies were built in twos among the wealthy so that one could be cleaned, while the other was still in use. Jefferson’s and Washington’s privies were built in an octagonal shape, perhaps to resemble the baptisteries in Church of England buildings. They were built of brick with special features such as wood painted to resemble limestone. “This is architecture that celebrates, even elevates its earthy origins,” Olmert writes.

 

Most Williamsburg homes had much simpler “necessaries.” They were unpainted and not built to last. A few had pits and when the pit filled, they were moved. Most did not, and the belief is that waste was taken away through clean-out doors in the back of the privy or drawers under the seats.

 

Virginia also had multi-hole privies in its colonial era. Olmert describes a fancy one at the Westover Plantation that dates before 1783. It is reached by five steps – sort of a “temple” approach. There is a fireplace and a mantle inside, as well as two lower children’s commodes. At the top level there are three holes, with the central one obviously meant for the head of the family. It is “as if the family were going to court, not to a private function,” Olmert comments.

 

It would be more than a century before the backyard privy began to disappear. There had been experiments with indoor plumbing as far back as the 16th century when John Harrington invented a water closet for his godmother Queen Elizabeth I in 1596. But it wasn’t until 1885 that an inventor named Thomas Twyford changed the course of history by inventing a flush toilet made out of porcelain, much easier to clean than earlier wood or metal models.

 

It’s hard to know exactly when that familiar structure with the half moon began to disappear from the Virginia landscape, but it certainly corresponds to the transition from a rural to urban society that occurred in the commonwealth in the late 1930s, 1940s and 1950s. (By the way, apparently the half moon is an ancient symbol for “female” and in colonial days when many could not read, a privy with such a symbol was designated for women and one with a sunburst or circle for men. The half moon may have survived because it was easier to cut into a door than a sunburst.)

 

As late as 1995, there is a reference to hold-outs in rural Virginia Beach. An editorial in The Virginian-Pilot (“Privy to Politics,” August 13, 1995) admonishes rural farmers “who prefer privies in rural Virginia Beach to the officialdom accompanying septic tanks,” but want government intervention when they hope to subdivide and sell their land. The editorial refers to a City Council meeting in which the idea of a “privy patrol” was suggested to make sure city sanitation regulations were enforced in rural areas.

 

These days outdoor privies have become collectibles, even appearing on eBay, although they don’t seem to sell for much according to one commentator. And, “shipping could be a major pain.” (Outhouse FAQ).

 

Those interested in competing in the Grand Privy Race next fall can make their own equipment using instructions from the 1908 edition of "Household Discoveries and Mrs. Curtis's Cook Book." Her chapter on “How to Build a Privy” suggests surrounding it with latticework and vines. “This plan, which adds but little to the expense, renders the building much less unsightly and much more private.” Other construction plans can be found in "The Vanishing American Outhouse" by Robert S. Barlow, apparently the seminal work on the topic.

 

See you Saturday October 11 in Independence! Privies need to be at the starting line by 9 a.m.

 

NEXT: The Physics of Incentives:  Enterprise Zones in the Old Dominion

 

-- February 11, 2008

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

About "Nice & Curious"

 

In 1691, a group of English wits, calling themselves the Athenian Society, founded a publication entitled, "The Athenian Gazette or Causical Mercury, Resolving All the Most Nice and Curious Questions proposed by the Ingenious." The editors accepted questions posed by readers on any and all topics, and sought the most ingenious answers.

 

Inspired by their example, Edwin S. Clay III, president of the Virginia Library Association and Director of the Fairfax County Public Library, created an occasional column on Virginia facts that may require "ingenious answers" of the type favored by those 17th-century wags.

 

If you have a query, e-mail him at eclay0@fairfaxcounty.gov.

 

Fairfax County Public Library staff Patricia Bangs, Lois Kirkpatrick and MaryAnn Sheehan assist in the writing, editing and research of the column.

 

Read their profile and peruse back issues.