Nice & Curious Questions

Edwin S. Clay III and Patricia Bangs


 

 

Pick 4 or Mega Millions

Lottery Games in Virginia 


 

When a Chesapeake, Va., woman won $400,000 in the Virginia Lottery’s Weekly Grand Game recently, she probably didn’t realize she was continuing an Old Dominion tradition. Lotteries have a long, if not always distinguished, history in the U.S. Like many other firsts in the nation, the earliest lottery was held to benefit Virginia.

 

When the Virginia Company ran into financial trouble supporting the Jamestown settlement, the king authorized the company to conduct a lottery for one year. The Virginia Company’s first lottery was held in London on July 20, 1612 (“Adoption of State Lotteries in the United States With a Closer Look at Illinois,” Independent Review, Winter 2006). Three other lotteries were held in the 1620s when the Virginia Company still failed to meet its financial goals, but eventually the House of Commons rescinded the company’s right to conduct lotteries. In doing so, it cited mismanagement and complaints that the lottery diverted money from legitimate businesses.

 

Still, lotteries, both private and public, thrived in colonial America. Thomas Jefferson, at the age of 83, attempted to give away land through a lottery to pay off $80,000 in debts. However, he failed to sell enough tickets to remove the debt before he died in 1826.

 

Over a 70-year period beginning in 1790, colleges such as Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale and others benefited from lotteries. In the early 1800s, lotteries were so popular that eight states raised $66.4 million in just one year – 1832. That sum was four times the expenditure of the federal government that year (“The Social and Economic Impact of State Lotteries,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, July 1984).

 

However, by the mid- to late-19th century, as corruption seeped into more and more government-run lotteries, with illegal schemes ranging from selling fake tickets to fixing the winners, the institution was abandoned. Louisiana’s state lottery, considered one of the most corrupt, was the last to be shut down in 1895. It would be 70 years before states would again experiment with lotteries to improve their bottom line.

 

New Hampshire led the lottery renaissance in 1964. As with many states at the time, NH relied heavily on property taxes and excise taxes on liquor and cigarettes for revenue. Lotteries, state officials hoped, would help keep taxes lower, though some critics argued that a lottery was a regressive tax on the less wealthy, not a voluntary tax on “those who choose to pay,” as Jefferson believed.

 

The Virginia Lottery grew out of this resurgence, although it wasn’t until 1987 that voters approved a state-wide lottery. The first Virginia Lottery, held in 1989, sold $409.1 million in tickets and gave out $205.9 million in prizes. It also raised $140.5 million for capital construction projects. From 1990–98, proceeds from the lottery were transferred to the state’s general fund. From 1999 on, they have been earmarked solely for educational purposes.

 

In 2006, the Virginia lottery sold more than $1.3 billion in tickets, gave out $773.5 million in prizes and raised $454 million for K-12 education – 10 percent of the state funding. Over the years, there have been some unusual lottery winners.

 

In 1992, an Australian group, led by professional lottery whiz Stefan Mandel, bought 5.5 million of the possible 7 million ticket combinations possible and won the $27 million jackpot. In the three days before the drawing, 20 representatives of the Lotto Fund of Melbourne, Australia crisscrossed the state snatching up as many of the tickets as possible. The 2,524 investors won $400 a year per each $3,000 unit bought. Needless to say, Virginia tightened the rules on block ticket purchases after that win (“Jackpot! Australian Group Wins Virginia Lottery,” People Weekly, April 6, 1992).

 

In 2004, a Virginia Beach woman, who had anonymously donated a kidney to a man she didn’t know, won half a million dollars. She was a cashier in the gift shop on the Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel, and she planned to use her windfall – $355,000 after taxes – to buy her first home, plus a truck for her husband, a car for herself, and help her daughter return to college as well as fix the car of the man who received kidney (“Kidney Donor Wins $500,000 Lottery Prize: Virginia Woman Plans to Help Kin, Organ Recipient,” Houston Chronicle, June 16, 2004).

 

Many big money winners have to make tough decisions on whether to take a lump sum payment or spread payments over time. In 2000, the CEO of the Henrico County Federal Credit Union won the $10.7 million grand prize in the multi-state Lotto game. She quickly discovered that her winnings would shrink to $3.7 million if she took the lump sum. Twenty-eight percent was held back for federal taxes and four percent went to the state, but another $3.5 million represented the interest that would have accrued if the amount had been in U.S. Treasury bonds and paid out over 26 years – the alternative to the lump-sum disbursement. Still, many winners choose the lump sum, believing they can make higher yield investments, or perhaps they don’t want to bet on their life span. (“Where Did All the Money Go?” Credit Union Journal, November 2000).

 

Finally, there are the cautionary tales. When a 24-year-old won $4.3 million in the Virginia Lottery in 1992, he already had a wild reputation. The money, which he chose to take in 20 yearly payments of $220,000, didn’t seem to change his ways. While he generously donated to the local volunteer fire department and rescue squad, and helped friends dig out swimming pools and driveways, by 2003 he was in jail, charged with attempting to kill a police officer. Police had dragged him naked from his pickup truck. “This man would have been better off without the money, frankly,” said the Henry County sheriff at the time. “It certainly didn’t help him, I can tell you that.” (“Be Careful What You Wish For; Lottery Win Exacerbated Va. Man’s Troubles, Friends and Family Say,” The Washington Post, June 26, 2003).

 

Still, those scratch cards are tempting, aren’t they?

 

NEXT: A Day’s Journey to the Courthouse: Virginia’s Counties

 

-- May 28, 2007

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

About "Nice & Curious"

 

In 1691, a group of English wits, calling themselves the Athenian Society, founded a publication entitled, "The Athenian Gazette or Causical Mercury, Resolving All the Most Nice and Curious Questions proposed by the Ingenious." The editors accepted questions posed by readers on any and all topics, and sought the most ingenious answers.

 

Inspired by their example, Edwin S. Clay III, president of the Virginia Library Association and Director of the Fairfax County Public Library, created an occasional column on Virginia facts that may require "ingenious answers" of the type favored by those 17th-century wags.

 

If you have a query, e-mail him at eclay0@fairfaxcounty.gov.

 

Fairfax County Public Library staff Patricia Bangs, Lois Kirkpatrick and MaryAnn Sheehan assist in the writing, editing and research of the column.

 

Read their profile and peruse back issues.