March
Madness
The
GOP transportation plan isn't just bad policy,
it's bad politics. Republicans are fast losing
credibility as the party of low taxes and small
government.
The
most unpredictable basketball tournament, fueled
by the passion of youth, follows the historical
Ides, the time of foulest betrayal, to close a
month noted for ending the opposite of how it
began. It’s all March Madness.
This
March Virginia’s Republicans mimic the madness
in their own competition with themselves. No one
knows if they will end the month as lions or
sacrificial lambs. In either case, Republicans are
starting the month with a lot of hot wind.
The
groundwork was laid almost a half a year ago.
Republican Speaker of House Bill Howell, Attorney
General Bob McDonnell and selected senators and
delegates met secretly to create a
"compromise" transportation deal for
Virginia. They knew the Democrats had a winning
political issue for the General Assembly elections
in November 2007 if the Republicans did nothing on
transportation. The Republicans had to do something.
Something beats nothing. The problem was getting
something past His Lordship Sir John Chichester
and his tax-and-spend Republicans in the Senate.
"Something"
had to include more money, higher taxes -- just
don't call anything a "statewide" tax.
Not the higher fees, not the fines, not the
assorted regional revenues. Furthermore, push the
responsibility for raising the new tax revenues
onto the cities and counties. That way the
Republicans can shade the truth and say they
didn’t raise taxes.
RINOs
can point to more money, more money, more money -
even as the cash surplus continues to flood from
2004’s largest tax increase in Virginia history.
Throw in some borrowing which violates the spirit
of the Virginia Constitution, by not facing the
voters as bonds, and add less than one per cent of
the General Fund to complete the funding. Assemble
some land use reform and shift the burden and some
funding for roads from the Commonwealth to the
cities and counties. The particulars may be
flawed, but imperfection is the expected price of
legislative compromise. Finally, in the act, where
cynicism triumphs over good governance, re-create
the Frankenstein of old regional plans for NoVa
and Hampton Roads. Especially for my home here in
Tidewater.
The
compromise is dubious politics, and it's terrible
policy. Even according to the analysis of those
who support the taxes, congestion will continue to
increase. After 20 years of construction delays,
accidents and death there will be more
congestion across Hampton Roads. Telling The
People otherwise -– there's no way to sugar coat
this -– is a lie.
It's
a lie, too, about "regional
authorities". Whence cometh Regional
Government for the fourth time? Rejected by ’98
Constitutional Amendment, ’02 Transportation Tax
Scam Referendum, and ’05 votes against Jerry
Kilgore’s regionalism, the Republicans in the
General Assembly are going to cram an unwanted
idea down the voters’ throats.
Super
cynically, General Assembly Republicans rely on
seven Democrat-controlled cities and counties to
vote in an unelected, unaccountable, un-separated
powers Regional Government for all 13 localities.
How shrewd: Create a new level of government and
structure the governance so that it's dominated by
Democrats. Then hand over $209 million in fun
money from Year One – more in following years.
Republicans
betray the principles in their Virginia Republican
Creed by raising taxes – even as revenues and
spending skyrocket – and expanding, not
limiting, government against the will of The
People.
Republicans
do so with the intent of turning their plan into a
political shield that protects Republicans in the
fall General Assembly elections. The fearful panic
of losing the majority in the legislature and the
redistricting power after the 2010 census is
palpable. The Republicans are sweating fear of the
voters.
Enter
the new Chairman of the Republican Party of
Virginia, and former Republican National Committee
chairman: Ed Gillespie. Ed ran the table faster
than a Newark pool shark in his native New Jersey
to pick up the coronation
election. He is hustling
to get a State Central Committee (SCC) vote at the
24 March meeting to support the Republican
caucus’ Transportation abortion. He may win, but
the vote won’t be unanimous. I’ll vote against
it.
To
maintain any semblance of consistency, voting in
favor of the GOP transportation plan would require
repealing prior SCC resolutions containing
language to the effect:
...that
lower taxes create more jobs and more prosperity.
...that
higher taxes destroy jobs.
...that
higher taxes fall most heavily on Virginia's small
businesses which create the most new jobs.
...that
Virginians recently rejected in referenda an
earlier scheme to raise taxes.
...that
Republicans win most elections because Virginians
believe in promises made, promises kept.
...that
Virginia's government can and should live within
its means.
...that
a fair tax system is one which creates jobs and
prosperity, not one that destroys both.
(This
last statement, about Gov. Mark Warner's 04 Tax
increase, was ignored by Republicans in the
General Assembly who voted for what, at that time,
was the largest tax increase in Virginia history.)
Chairman
Gillespie authorized a commercial blaming Democrat
Governor Kaine using the name of the RPV, but
without a vote of the Executive Committee – to
the best of my knowledge – and, certainly
without the approval of the SCC.
Which
leads to ultimate insanity of the "stra-teg-ery":
Republicans can run "conservative"
Republicans for city and county governments to
stop the tax increases and regional government
passed by the Republican majority in the General
Assembly. Please read that again - s-l-o-w-l-y.
Except the voters in Virginia aren’t that
stupid. Conservatives aren’t that passive.
Conservatives across Virginia who have donated
real money or motivated serious advocacy groups
are going to meet (probably on the same day as the
SCC). The
object of their attention will be the Republicans:
the Caucus and the RPV.
The
Republican Caucus is bleeding Republican voters
from the base – again. At some point excessive
bleeding is fatal to the Party. Challengers to
Republican incumbents must file by April 13th. The
primaries close June 12th. If too few good men and
women can stand in the breach, then what to do?
Unfund the GOP for 07? For 08? Start a new
political Party?
Virginia’s
March Madness may turn the political status quo on
its head. It’s such a fickle month. March 2007
may be, like many historical Aprils, a month of
grave decisions.
--
March 5, 2007
|