Nice & Curious Questions

Edwin S. Clay III and Patricia Bangs


 

Is Virginia Really a State? What the Heck is a Commonwealth?

 

It all started in 1619 at Jamestown. Gov. Sir George Yeardley authorized the first meeting of Virginia’s General Assembly, giving as one reason, “for the better establishing of a commonwealth here” (History of Virginia -- Meaning of Commonwealth).

 

The term "commonwealth," dating from the 15th century, derived from the old meaning of “weal” or “wealth,” which meant “well-being.” Commonwealth, then, originally meant a state or nation governed for the common good, rather than a specific class of people. The term probably arose to describe efforts to limit the power of kings – the most well-known being the Magna Carta in 1215. The term took on more specific political meaning between 1649 and 1660 when England had no monarch, but was ruled by a Lord Protector, the Puritan Oliver Cromwell. His government was called the Commonwealth of England.

 

Virginia, however, did not adopt the term commonwealth until the Revolutionary War. In colonial times, the state was officially known as the Colony and Dominion of Virginia. When delegates met in Williamsburg in 1776 to ratify a state constitution, they adopted “commonwealth” as the name for their new government – perhaps to echo the Puritans’ rebellion against the king of England more than 100 years earlier.

 

Besides Virginia, three other states – Massachusetts, Pennsylvania and Kentucky – still use the term commonwealth to describe their government. Massachusetts and Pennsylvania were among the thirteen colonies that originally broke ties with England in 1776. Founded by Puritans and Quakers respectively, Massachusetts and Pennsylvania also may have appreciated the historical significance of the term. Kentucky was a part of Virginia until it joined the nation as the 15th state in 1792 and kept the term in its new constitution.

 

So, what’s in a name? Are a commonwealth and a state the same thing? When it comes to our nation, the answer is yes. Basically, the term “commonwealth” is only symbolic. By ratifying the U.S. Constitution, which uses the term “state” to refer to subunits of the nation, Virginia, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania and Kentucky all must abide by the federal legal system and political order of the U.S. outlined in that document. It doesn’t matter what they call themselves.

 

But, just to confuse things, “commonwealth” does have other meanings. For example, Puerto Rico and the Northern Mariana Islands, both U.S. territories, are referred to as commonwealths. In this case, the term refers to the territories being self-governing and associated with the U.S. In Puerto Rico, residents are U.S. citizens, but cannot vote in the U.S.

 

Internationally, commonwealth has yet more meanings. The Commonwealth of Nations (once referred to as the British Commonwealth) refers to 53 nations that were once part of the British Empire. Unlike U.S. territories, they are not connected politically, but do have social, ideological and philosophical ties to each other. The Commonwealth of Independent States refers to 12 of the 15 former republics of the Soviet Union that have loose ties with each other. Even certain nations such as Australia, the Bahamas and Dominica also refer to themselves as commonwealths.

 

But the term is more than just a name with many meanings. Just think. Since the notion of states and commonwealths are interchangeable, we all could be residing in “The United Commonwealths of America,” instead of the good old U.S. of A.!

 

NEXT: Oh Say Can You See? Lookouts and Lighthouses in Virginia

 

-- November 6, 2006

 

(Got a question? Check out Ask a Librarian Live.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

About "Nice & Curious"

 

In 1691, a group of English wits, calling themselves the Athenian Society, founded a publication entitled, "The Athenian Gazette or Causical Mercury, Resolving All the Most Nice and Curious Questions proposed by the Ingenious." The editors accepted questions posed by readers on any and all topics, and sought the most ingenious answers.

 

Inspired by their example, Edwin S. Clay III, president of the Virginia Library Association and Director of the Fairfax County Public Library, created an occasional column on Virginia facts that may require "ingenious answers" of the type favored by those 17th-century wags.

 

If you have a query, e-mail him at eclay0@fairfaxcounty.gov.

 

Fairfax County Public Library staff Patricia Bangs, Lois Kirkpatrick and MaryAnn Sheehan assist in the writing, editing and research of the column.