Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs


 

 

Run to Day Light

 

The best column of the week was Barnie Day’s analysis of the gubernatorial race, reprinted here at Bacon’s Rebellion. Day surveyed the current state of the race and potential future developments.

 

A Day source told him that everywhere he went, Virginians were “disappointed” in the current campaign, particularly its lack of  “gravitas.” That’s why no one is paying attention, according to Day, although the fact that it’s May, not October, and early campaigns are almost always panned by critics might have something to do with it.

 

More interesting is Day’s suggestion that “government by referenda” might become the defining issue of the race, offering the missing “gravitas.” Kilgore is proposing referenda on tax increases; Kaine opposes it.

It's got all the markers of an issue that could get legs. It is simple. There are significant consequences. It is reducible to sound-bite and bumper sticker ("Let the People Decide"). There are differences between the candidates. And it has the two characteristics that seem requisite anymore in politics. Does it pander? Does it insult our intelligence? Of course it does, on both counts.

Apparently, Day believes that because it is reducible to a bumper sticker, it’s automatically suspect.  Perhaps he should consider his side’s bumper sticker possibilities (“Let the Blue Ribbon Commission Decide” or “Let 21 Senators Decide”).

 

Still, candidates debating tax increases in terms of who determines tax increases and under what circumstances seems like a good issue to put before the voters. We can only hope that Day is on to something.

 

In other looks at the campaign, Jeff Schapiro speculated in the Richmond Times-Dispatch that issues outside Virginia might decide the gubernatorial race. Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress reviewed the debate issue from a tactical standpoint.  In the Washington Post, Gordon Morse found problems with Republican candidates Jerry Kilgore, George Fitch, and Bill Bolling. Democratic campaigns seem to be flawless and Morse finds some kind words for GOP Lt. Gov. candidate Sean Connaughton, although he stresses that’s not an endorsement.

 

Following the Money

 

Jeff Schapiro also wrote of a web site being built to allow anyone to review state spending. Showing a noteworthy lack of skepticism, Schapiro accepted Walter Kucharski’s declaration that the site will be from a “citizen’s point of view,” even though “two wonks” are constructing the page. Kucharski is the Auditor of Public Accounts. Citizens might feel more confident about the potential usefulness of the site if Lee and Paulette Albright of Montebello, the couple behind exposure of Department of Game and Inland Fisheries spending hijinks, tested the site before it debuts.

 

The Taxman Cometh

 

There has been some talk that Virginians are not particularly concerned about rising real estate tax bills. Perhaps that’s because no major pundits have bothered to ask. Wil LaViest of the Daily Press broke the moratorium, quoting numerous Hampton Road residents, including Rhonda Woods of Hampton: "I struggled to pay the payments on the house, and my house is paid off," she said. "Now I'm going to have to struggle to pay taxes.”

 

Roanoke Times, Last Bastion of the First Amendment

 

According to Kathryn Welch, a Blacksburg writer and industrial psychologist, “bullies … (like The Salt Lick?) try to silence Tommy Denton and staff, whose op-ed section is the only place in The [Roanoke] Times where moderate and progressive views appear. These same bullies also try to intimidate letter writers.” To Welch, editorial page editor Denton and his staff are “small town heroes” operating in a “hostile environment.”

 

Columnist Gets Results

 

Richmond Mayor Doug Wilder came to City Hall promising belt-tightening, but Michael Paul Williams of the Richmond Times-Dispatch noted that Wilder seemed oblivious to appearances regarding a proposed $25,000 pay raise that would bring his salary to $150,000 per year. That’s higher than the salaries of mayors in Atlanta, Baltimore, and Washington, DC. Shortly after Williams’ column appeared, Wilder announced that he would not accept the raise.

 

The Precipice of Development

 

A budget shortfall in rural Carroll County is causing supervisors to consider lifting a land-use tax assessment deferral policy on undeveloped land. Liz Field of Wytheville writes in the Roanoke Times that such a move would “destroy scenic open space” in an area increasingly dependent on tourism.

 

Blog Round-Up

 

Commonwealth Conservative played host to a national blog highlight program, “Carnival of the Vanities,” selflessly using the platform to introduce Virginia blogs to a wider audience.  Host John Behan also offered extensive coverage of the Tim Kaine campaign campaign, a subject ignored by most major pundits.  The Jaded JD offered analysis of the Kaine campaign based on recent poll results showing Kaine within the margin of error.

 

Incredibly detailed information on House of Delegate races races is available at Virginia House of Delegates Elections 2005, operated by the intriguingly named “Not Larry Sabato.” That moniker has spawned a host of imitators in comment sections, such as “Not Mark Rozell” (Rozell being an American University professor-pundit).

 

Anonymous blogging was debated at Bacon’s Rebellion, as was a code of ethics for bloggers.

 

This past week ended with a blog-sprawling discussion of the Virginia anti-tax philosophy, ignited by a question and fueled by the Phil Rodokanakis response on Bacon’s Rebellion and Norm Leahy’s riposte at One Man’s Trash. The campaign blog of Shaun Kenney also jumped into the fray. Kenney is a candidate in the House of Delegates race in the 54th District. The real-time back and forth among credible participants in blog discussions simply can’t be duplicated in print media.

 

-- May 23, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.