Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



It’s Back: Tax Reform!

 

It wasn’t long ago that pundits were writing off tax reform in Virginia. Suddenly, a speech that turned into an op-ed has breathed new life into what is still an uphill struggle.

 

Sen. John Chichester, R-Stafford, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, gave a speech 

on August 5th to the Virginia Foundation for Research and Economic Education (Virginia FREE).  Virginia FREE was the group that made controversial ratings of Democrats as better on business issues than Republicans. Chichester’s speech, approvingly published on the op-ed pages of newspapers such as the Roanoke Times, was a clarion call to tax reform (read: tax increases) to deal with Virginia’s needs:

 

I get so frustrated when I hear my colleagues say, "No one is coming up to me on the street and saying they're undertaxed!"

 

Of course they're not. No one in Stafford County is telling me we need to renovate a dilapidated fire hazard in Capitol Square, but we do. No one is telling me we should replace our antiquated, inadequate telecommunications system for our state police, but we should. No one is telling me that our courts are overcrowded and understaffed, but they are.

 

Barnie Day breathlessly hailed Chichester’s speech in the Daily Press, quoting Sophocles and placing the impact of Chichester’s speech alongside Lincoln and Churchill. On a more practical level, shortly after Chichester’s speech/op-ed, Del. Allen Louderback, R-Luray, a member of the legislative tax reform commission, actually placed meaningful tax reform ideas on the table. Was there a connection? Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress, while skeptical of any real tax reform becoming law, nonetheless gave grudging credit to Louderback for keeping “meaty items on the menu.”

 

The case against tax reform that is not “revenue neutral” is still being actively advocated. In the Washington Post, Chris Edwards of the libertarian Cato Institute argued against increases in sales tax and corporate tax that he ascribes to Governor Warner. With Warner not putting specific proposals on the table yet, Edwards may need to address his argument to Chichester and Louderback.

 

Another Worry

 

Just when you thought there weren’t enough problems for the state budget, Margaret Edds of the Virginian-Pilot tells us to start worrying about prison overcrowding. She quotes estimates of new prison bed needs that are as high as 8,000 by 2010.

 

Commuter Tax Update

 

Norbert Michaels, a policy analyst at the Heritage Foundation, reviewed the District of Columbia budget for the Washington Post and found no justification for claims that a commuter tax on Virginians and Marylanders is needed. “The District doesn't need to collect more tax revenue -- it needs to do a better job with what it already gets,” Michaels concluded.

 

Damage Control

 

The Department of Environmental Quality, and, by implication, Governor Warner, took a beating over their handling of James River trash barge regulations. It fell to Secretary of Natural Resources W. Tayloe Murphy, Jr., to respond to a critical Daily Press editorial and change the subject from trash to Warner’s overall environmental record. Murphy recited a laundry list of initiatives while conspicuously avoiding any mention of trash barges.

 

Political Round-Up

 

Hugh Lessig and Terry Scanlon of the Daily Press profiled the two star-crossed candidates for state Republican Party chairperson, while Bob Gibson of the Daily Progress reviewed the sordid details of the eavesdropping scandal that finally created the opening … Is Northern Virginia “entitled” to a spot on the 2005 GOP ticket? R. H. Melton of the Washington Post explored that question. Although State Sen. Bill Bolling, R-Mechanicsville, is well ahead in the race for the Lieutenant Governor nomination, Congressman and would-be kingmaker Tom Davis is a leading proponent of putting a Northern Virginian in that spot. Davis’ choice is his protégé (and, apparently, so much more), Del. Jeannemarie Devolites, R-Vienna, now running for the senate. Another name mentioned is Prince William County Supervisor Chairman Sean Connaughton.

 

Jesse Todd of the Daily Press compared Virginia politics and its celebrity politicians to California’s and found them wanting. He offered this snarky commentary:

 

We do dull here, even though some Republicans have lately tried to liven things up by breaking the law in their efforts to eavesdrop on Democratic conference calls. One would think that if Democrats statewide had anything worth listening to, they would be saying it loudly.

 

Education Round-Up

 

In a rare find on the op-ed pages, a teacher actually praised the Standards of Learning tests.  Susan O’Brien Saccomando, a Fairfax County teacher writing in the Washington Post, made the case that the SOLs are working because students can’t pass just by “showing up.” Meanwhile, Radford Professor Vincent Hazleton blew the lid off conventional wisdom that says intercollegiate athletics are self-supporting. In a Roanoke Times piece, he pointed out that the average student at a Virginia state university pays almost $648 as an “athletic fee.” R. H. Melton of the Washington Post criticized the new Alliance for Virginia’s Students for “tiptoe[ing] around the elephant in the room -- the new taxes that many advocates say are essential to meeting the roughly $1 billion in documented school funding needs.”

 

Shameless Self-Reference

 

Your “Virginia Pundit Watch” correspondent was mentioned in Pamela Stallsmith’s front page, below-the-fold article on blogging in the Richmond Times-Dispatch. His musings on blogging and national events were also heard on the August 15th edition of C-Span’s “Washington Journal,” hosted by Brian Lamb. The streaming video of that appearance is available here.

 

Now, my fifteen minutes are up.

 

-- August 25, 2003

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.