Guest Column

Joyce Wise Dodd



 

Barter Jump Starter

 

Careful development of the Barter Theatre's village green in downtown Abingdon could promote tourism in the quaint, historical town and, potentially, the rest of Southwest Virginia.


 

It was a dark and stormy day at the Barter Theatre’s new Playhouse Café in Abingdon. Severe storms could not keep show goers, locals and out-of-towners away from the funky new eatery. Each chair, stool, table, ornament and wall decoration was a Barter Theatre prop at some time during theatre’s last half century. Open less than two weeks, the café’s cash register was kerchinging.

 

Who would have thought the day would come when people would pay cash money to dine at a Barter establishment? In the hardscrabble days of the Great Depression, Barter founder and Glade Spring native Robert Porterfield brought a ragged band of actors south from New York where he had gone to become a star. The troupe performed plays for food, literally trading entertainment for chicken, ham, eggs or whatever else Grandma had in her larders.

 

On this particular day, as the Barter café crowd chatted over Shakespeare garden burgers, fancy teas and low-fat lattes, thunder clapped and a fire-blue stripe of lightning split a nearby hemlock exactly in half. Onlookers gawked as the giant tree crashed to the ground, flush with one of the plate glass windows.

 

Deafening silence. Then a startled young woman yelled that someone should “get Rick.” On cue, Barter Theatre Artistic Director Richard Rose, drenched in his rain jacket, strutted through the café and fretted with diners about the danger he had always known the tree had posed to theatre goers. In his typical serious but playful mood, Rose suggested that everyone go out and carry away part of the tree to remember its dramatic conclusion.

 

The story is emblematic of an economic development issue now facing the town of Abingdon, “nestled in the foothills of Southwest Virginia,” as Porterfield used to promote it.

 

Planned development of the so-called Barter Green, named for the green space located across West Main Street from Barter Theatre and adjacent to the renovated Barter’s Stage ll playhouse, has been 

generating atmospheric fireworks its own for the past two years. The issue: how to develop this green patch of land, the only one of its size remaining in the town's historic district?

 

Rick Rose’s vision encompasses not only the completion of Stage ll renovation, which includes the new café in the lobby, but the establishment of retail shops and apartment dwellings, dubbed the Stonewall Square Project. Barter owns the property, it can be argued, so it’s Barter’s business what it does with the land.

 

But the property sits squarely in the heart of the town’s historic district, and some townspeople feel that developing the green is just plain wrong. The Stage ll renovation and its café are a done deal. Barter renovated and expanded -- and the people came bearing cash. But the proposed transmogrification of the entire block on the north side of West Main St. between Church St. and the Martha Washington Inn strikes many as just too much.

 

The green development team has modified the architectural plans in response to criticism, and will revisit the issue in late June. Barter has stated its intention to develop the property over whatever period of time it takes to settle on a plan, create as much community unanimity as possible and raise funds necessary for the development.

 

There's a lot more at stake than a one-block plot of land. The Barter Theatre is one of the few destinations in Southwest Virginia capable of luring visitors from all over the United States and even other continents. The only other attraction that comes close is the Virginia Highlands Festival, which draws hundreds of thousands to the region for its annual two-week summer run -- but that could hardly be construed as a year-round economic boon.

 

On the other hand, a tremendous part of Barter's charm is its setting in downtown Abingdon, a historic district of brick-lined streets, 19th century architecture, and dignified old trees. Abingdon has maintained a charming, small-town ambiance seen in Lexington, perhaps, but in few other places in Virginia. Without its historic, small-town context, the theater loses much of its appeal. The challenge for Abingdon is to figure out how to harness the Barter's formidable drawing power to build a tourist industry -- without destroying the rare and impossible-to-reproduce atmosphere that draws visitors in the first place.

 

Abingdon may be small -- its population is less than 8,000 -- but it may be Southwest Virginia's best bet for economic development.

 

The coalfields are playing out, farms are dying and mill-towns shriveling as manufacturing moves off-shore. The U.S. is evolving into a knowledge-

intensive, innovation-based economy, driven forward by scientifically, artistically and entrepreneurially creative people who prefer living in places that look at lot more like Washington, D.C., or Charlottesville than Bristol or Big Stone Gap. 

 

Community leaders in far Southwest Virginia are scrambling to identify an economic base with staying power in the Knowledge Economy. It isn't easy. To Washingtonians and Richmonders, the far Southwest is terra incognita -- the region beyond Roanoke, beyond Blacksburg, that drops off most weatherman's map. The region rolls squarely into the heart of Appalachia , a place easily stereotyped as The Sticks... a place where everyone is a relative of a relative... where satellite dishes sit atop shacks with sofas on the porch... where school is a place you drop out of.

 

The economic base is rapidly hollowing out. Factory  jobs have vaporized from areas such as Smyth County. Economic developers have managed to attract call centers, paying up to $12 an hour, but now that kind of work is moving overseas. College-educated Indians speaking fluent English will answer phones for a fraction of the lowest U.S. wages.

The bright side of Appalachia is the cognoscenti who trace their origins back to Pocahontas: the young professionals who rack up several degrees and come back to run for public office, the retirees who discover the benefits of smart, small town life. The lack of mean streets attracts people who have a deep need to feel safe. Abingdon has all that and, unlike most mill towns in Virginia's Southwest, so much more --  theater, history and lattes. It has the potential to become a magnet for the so-called "creative class" and the assets to build a tourism industry.

 

Abingdon can tout not only the historic Barter Theatre but the other amenities of a pedestrian-friendly downtown, including the region's finest hotel in the Martha Washington Inn, not to mention the Virginia Highlands Festival, the Virginia Creeper Trail and something-for-everyone Coomes Recreation Center.

 

What about the other, despairing communities of the far Southwest? Here’s a thought: Bundle the tourist possibilities. Lead with the Abingdon/Barter Theatre experience and advertise comfort-ride bus tours as A Relaxing and Educational One-, Two- or Three-Day Adventure.

 

The region has enough hotels, bed-and-breakfast homes, snazzy restaurants and other attractions to host tours based out of Abingdon. Smyth County is home to the ill-promoted Hungry Mother Park. The park has quiet forest-surrounded cabins, bridged walkways that follow babbling streams and a little beach on a sparkling lake. Thousands of local baby-boomers remember Hungry Mother as the place to go for fun in the sun. The park could be the centerpiece for a Smyth County abuzz with jobs, tourists and cash flow.

 

Saltville provided salt for the Confederate Army during the Civil War, making it a bull’s eye for Yankee invaders. Let tourists see the old town and tell them about its history.

 

Motor on to Bristol on the other side of Abingdon. That is where country music actually had its humble origin, but that fact remains mostly lost among the glitterati of Nashville and Branson, Missouri. A.P. Carter’s gravesite with its shiny Keep on the Sunnyside gold-plated record marker could be a tourist attraction in and of itself, if only more music lovers knew where to find the A.P. Carter Museum.

 

Burke’s Garden, near Tazewell, has been dubbed “God’s Thumbprint.” One of the most heavenly plots of land on earth, few tourists have ever heard of it, much less seen the lush phenomenon of “the garden.”

 

The mountains are not for everyone, so pump promotion for the lakes area that stretches from Virginia across the Tennessee border. A part of the country that once was mostly a wine spodie-odie hangout for teen-agers has been prosperously upgraded during the past three decades. The South Holston Lake now sports well-manicured boat docks from which vessels can be launched to view breathtaking sunrises and resplendent autumn sunsets. 

 

So, the Barter Green development continues according to phase, funding and compromise — the last compromise being the preservation of an historic stone wall, which runs the length of the block. Rick Rose and the Barter Green committee deal daily with the brutal downturn of the region's economy with creativity and imagination.

 

Let other areas of the Far Southwest look to Abingdon for inspiration, and as a hub and starting point for regional tour packages. The Mountain Empire just might one day become the Tourism Empire of the Southeast, as new economies are launched, new jobs created and world-wide excitement generated from the bundling of abundant extant resources.

 

-- June 16, 2003

 

Bring Home the Bacon

Help   About search

 

 

 

 

Joyce Wise Dodd is a native of Abingdon, a former administrator at Virginia Commonwealth University, former newspaper editor, and campaign manager of Congressman Rick Boucher's 2002 congressional campaign. She works with Bacon & Eggheads in Richmond, and is professor of communications at Appalachian State University in Boone, N.C.

 

Her e-mail address is jrwdodd@yahoo.com